4 Best Sandwich Shops in Laramie

“Stopped by McAlister’s in Laramie last night to redeem my tea pass, and I have to give a huge shoutout to Nathan (I’m guessing he’s the manager/owner). Hands down one of the nicest humans I’ve ever interacted with at a restaurant.

The cashier helping me hadn’t redeemed a tea pass before, and Nathan immediately stopped what he was doing to help—no frustration, no impatience, just kindness. He walked her through it step by step and made sure she felt supported, not like she was bothering him.

While he helped with my transaction, we stood there just genuinely chatting about all the tea deals, including Free Tea Day coming up in July. It was honestly just such a nice interaction. You don’t always see upper management step in like that, let alone with that much positivity and care for both their staff and customers.

Oh—and the tea was delicious, as always. I’ll definitely keep coming back, because of awesome people like Nathan and the whole team there.“

“Best Subway We've Had!

Stopped here on our way back to Colorado from Steamboat Springs and were blown away! My daughter and I each got a sandwich, cookies, and she grabbed a drink. As we were driving and eating, she paused and asked, “How’s yours?” I realized I’d been quietly enjoying it—it was honestly the best Subway sandwich I can remember having. Everything was fresh, perfectly made, and delicious.

She kept raving about how good her sandwich was too—and especially the lemonade. Not sure if they keep the drink machine cleaner than most, but whatever they’re doing, it’s working!

Bonus: the staff was super fast and efficient, which we really appreciated on a road trip.

Wish we lived closer because we’d be regulars!“

“Got two footings tonight and they were delicious! When we went into the restaurant the only person working was Ally and despite the Mobile orders and small line in the lobby she had such a great attitude and welcomed us in with a smile. I really appreciated her service and hope to see her again.“

“4 stars ⭐ I had never been to a Jimmy John's before living in Laramie. And, it was a decision made much too late. The menu is a little overwhelming with all the choices, but stuck with my standard BLT. I mean, how can a BLT go wrong? It can't. And, the chocolate chip cookies? Fantastic. Even better nice and warmed up“