30 Best Sandwich Shops in Fort Collins

“Such a gem of a spot. Lots of regular customers. I love it.“

“Yum yum delicious homemade food!“

“Excellent food, good price, lovely staff!“

“We were looking for a bite to eat late and found this place during CSU parents weekend. It was a very cool experience and the food and staff were great. The menu was interesting and we were surprised that the food names and wall art
were cannabis inspired. The food was very tasty and fresh. The vibe was fun. We embraced the experience since its a local student hang out. My husband ordered the 5 0 sandwich. They had bingo night in the bar area and we played while we ate. Would definitely go again!“

“There’s 6 of us in our family and ALL agree Cheba Hut is #1 in Fort Collins! Possibly the US but we haven’t ventured far from local, lol. The Griefo is BOMB! The White Willow is my husband fav, and seriously there’s not a bad thing on the menu !“

“I love that this Yampa is in such a convenient location! It’s easy access and very walkable. The service has always been amazing and they answer any questions with sincerity and patience. The food is a little pricy but for what you get, I say it’s worth it.“

“Discovered Ike’s from my work bringing it in for everyone! I couldn’t believe how amazing the Dutch crunch bread was and how many options they have on the menu! I’m currently working through all the menu items and haven’t found 1 that disappointed. Also met Ike and the man was super cool and chill! I’m happy to support this business. Also the app promotions are actually good and keep me coming back! Voted best sandwich in the world by Ike’s mom and also by me!

I’d recommend:
Pizzle
Hot Mamma Houda
M.I.L.F
Madison Bumgarner
Ménage a trois

Literally anything. The green Carmel apple sucker is also a great touch! Give it a try but be warned you might get addicted!“

“Absolutely great sandwiches!!!! The menu is hilariously fun and playful and the atmosphere is extremely family friendly! They also have vegetarian options available but I don’t partake in those options so dabble at your own risk there… the food is great the people are friendly and the price is fair. Definitely owe it to yourself to check this place out!!!! Oh and the lollipops are a fun touch 😜“

“My friend and I came to La Boutique today for lunch. When we walked in the door, we were greeted by 3 smiling faces. The owner greeted us in french. sandwiches are good, bring ur own condiments or u can buy some and take it home with u. I was really impressed with all the options for different meat, cheeses and many french bakery treats, including a couple gluten free options! must try there macarons. They are perfect. If u want any of these treats, come early as when they sell out, there gone. All staff seemed to love there jobs. I was very impressed with all the french treats, goodies and had a little of everything. This deli is a must try if u are in the area! We will be back!“

“Delicious Sandwiches and Staff was AMAZING!!! We will be back for sure!“

“Everything was wonderful! The food was fresh and tasted amazing, and the customer service was excellent. I went around 11:30, and I really liked that the restaurant wasn’t very busy, which made the atmosphere feel relaxed and enjoyable. I also loved that they had different shows playing on the TVs, which made the experience even better. And of course, the Kool-Aid never disappoints“

“awesome first time trying! it was great ! toasted sub and it was so fresh“

“The girl taking my order was so kind, friendly, and patient as I stumbled through a larger order! They were also so quick, and I was in and out in less than 5 minutes despite ordering 5 sandwiches. This was my first time here, and I would absolutely come back :)“

“I came in today and Spencer is one of the best employees I’ve ever had to deal with. I moved to Colorado about two months ago and going to the Subway is nothing like it is in Alaska. Spencer is one of the best employees he was super happy and when I told him that my sandwich was a little too raw, he made me another one and said don’t worry about it. It’s just it’s kind of crazy. You don’t find good customer service anymore but this guy he actually gave me a good customer service. I go to Subway probably three times a week and now I’m always gonna come to this location“

“Our subs are always good at Firehouse! The restaurant is clean and the service is friendly.“

“Mike and Mandy as managers are not taking care of orders properly. My most favorite item on my sandwich is pickles how does subway not have pickles?? Not only pickles but lettuce too. Please place orders accordingly as subway should never be out of lettuce or pickles. Thank you.“

“I had just started to wonder where my freaky fast sandwich was when the delivery guy called to say he was running behind and would be right over. These guys are awesome!!“

“Had a great lunch here today. The food is high quality, the new location is very convenient and the staff are friendly and attentive.

I was waiting in a long line about 130 pm today and Izzy came to each person in line to ask if anyone was having a hot sub (I was). She took my order, directed me to the front of the line where she took payment, and then she delivered my sub to me at my table.

Izzy's attention to service was appreciated. She is an asset to this business.

I'll be back!“

“I headed over here late at night when I was craving something hearty and indulgent. The menu is packed with some seriously wild combinations that sound like a dream when you are hungry. Everything I tried was cooked fresh and hit the spot, especially after a long day of exploring. It is definitely not the place to go if you are looking for a light salad, but for a fun, greasy treat, it totally delivers.“

“I picked up food today from this location and had the opportunity to work with Courtney who was by the way awesome from the time that I ordered the food and drove over to pick up my order her customer service was awesome on point and the food was great as well good job girl keep up the good work because of you I definitely would visit this location again thank you Courtney.“

“Wow I can't say enough about the professionalism, customer service and amazing toasted sandwiches at this Jimmy Johns. I had a not so great experience and shared the information with the manager to try and help and they responded with interest and a desire to try and correct going forward which is really all I'm interested in. If I have a bad experience that's life it happens but I try and see if there's an opportunity for a correction so possibly someone else doesn't have to experience the same. And the new toasted subs are Spot On! Quiznos back in the day was amazing and these are as good. Highly recommend toasted chicken ranch which was perfectly proportioned, hot, with loads of chicken. Well done!“

“friendly staff, quick service“

“We eat here on occasion. Everytime we have eaten at Jimmy's John's it has been very good. Never had a problem. If I had a complaint, it would be the tomatoes. They are sometimes ok, and other times not ok. But I get that at any sandwich shop. So I don't get tomatoes on my sandwich. That's an easy enough fix.
I have always loved Jimmy John's.“

“Exceptional service and food 💜“

“Blair and John are so good at what they do, make you feel welcome and make delicious sandwiches for you! My family of 4 have been choosing this Subway in particular for this incredible service. Will not visit another one in town. Blair's attention to my family's preferences, knowing when my kiddo upgraded his stomach for the foot long. She knew. Our kiddos feel very confident ordering their sandwiches as these two are so patient! As a customer, they make you feel special, like they remember you and your preferences. Feels so rare these days! Restaurant is always so clean, freshly stocked and they always get your order correct. Our sandwiches always taste like they are made with care and we really appreciate you, Blair and John!“

“This location has always been poorly kept. I believe there’s new management, in the last couple months it’s been much cleaner, better service, less homeless people hanging around ( they’re still outside but not in front of the store or inside) employees are nicer and seem to actually care what they’re doing. There’s still one kid I don’t know his name for sure as he never wears a name tag but he’s Hispanic and always wears an older subway jersey style shirt with glasses and if he’s alone the music is some cussing gangster stuff he’s terribly rude to everyone I stood in the lobby for a min before he came from in back to help me an all he said was “what do you want” everyone else is newer or very polite. I eat subway on average 3 times a week it’s inexpensive, an healthier than the other options on my way home this is my new go to store.“

“Overall great experience every time I go in, very speedy customer service and my order is always delicious and correct, the staff are really nice and the building is always clean. I have been going weekly for a few months now and have always been treated well each time. Amanda and pepa are very sweet and are very good at their jobs, and with how many times I visit they have practically memorized my order. Out of all the subways I have been to in Fort Collins this is my favorite one.“

“Customer service was great. Honestly 10/10 experience just for the look on the workers faces when someone took my sandwich before I could even get out of the booth.“

“I haven’t been to this location in a longtime because of a past experience. After trying it again I’m glad to say the Latina lady that helped me was amazing! She greated me with a beautiful smile and was kind and helpful! She is a great addition to your team and she deserves a raise! My cookie wasn’t stale and tasted delicious!“

“Awesome subs, wraps, salads. Hands down better than Subway :)“