“This place was awesome, and the food was absolutely fabulous. It was a little sugary, but if you have a high tolerance, unlike me, you could finish it all they also let you take your cups home I think they may not now because I came here in 2017 on a family trip but this place was awesome and I hope that even if I post this message 7 years later that this place is still doing greatWheelchair accessibility: I believe they have a ramp and ends of the tables that are wheelchair accessible please keep in mind that I am going off of memory from 7 years ago“
“I ordered a cake from Edgar's in Madison for my daughter's Birthday. I wanted something that looked classic. I checked all of the cake options online at their website. I selected the "Sophia" cake and then called to place my order. The Edgar's staff was very friendly and helpful. I wanted lemon buttercream between the layers and a Happy Birthday inscription on top of the cake. The cake was ready on the day and time promised and it turned out beautiful! Everyone raved about how delicious the cake tasted. The cake and icing were both very light and not heavy at all. The lemon buttercream between the layers was perfect. I highly recommend Edgar's and very highly recommend the "Sophia" cake.“
“The staff here are top notch, they're always extremely nice and give excellent service! The cakes are all amazing (my current favorite is the pumpkin spice flavor)! I've been here several times since it opened and have never been disappointed! Keep up the great work!“
“Well, this place can be a roller coaster. Some times is good, some times is some what. For the high price they charge it should be more consistent. So we ordered 2 boxes of 4 it took 25 minutes to get there and after waiting we were told it is going to take another 20 minutes. So the order we got, not up to the value of $12+ the peanut butter cookies were some thin, some over cooked and some bit chewy not consistent across 4. As for the cookies and creme after waiting 20 minutes on top of the 25 driving for pick up. We were told that they ran out of them. So a complete miss. The only reason I give 4 is because I have come other days and got what I paid, granted the fault is on the staff running the Saturday afternoon shift today.“