13 Best Sandwich Shops in Madison

“I cannot rave enough about “The Bomb” sandwich!! So delicious/flavorful! Yum! They are also very attentive and kind to their customers. Definitely earned this 5 ⭐️ review!!“

“I stepped out of rut (Original Deluxe) and ordered an Italian Calzone. Very different than any I’ve had (Oregon to Miami). You eat it like a sandwich. Plenty of meat, but desperately needed Ricotta, mushrooms and more onions. Well, back to the Original Deluxe.“

“We went to Chicken Salad Chick for the first time today! We placed a pick up order and our food was ready within 10 minutes. The food itself was great, although we received a partially wrong order. We both got three scoops and one of my husbands scoops was the wrong salad but he still enjoyed it. The only one that was eh was the buffalo chicken salad, it was just sooo spicy, but we know someone else might love that! I can’t speak for the service very much because all we did was pick it up but it was clean, fast, and tasty!“

“Trell *sp., was so pleasant of a young man., great manners. And I saw him 1st hand have to save the day when someone took the wrong bag of food (I guess doordash) he made a couple jokes and got right on it to put the customer at ease. Also gave me a solid recommendation on the most meat sub the JJ..“

“Out of all the Subway locations I've visited, this is my favorite. I have always been greeted by the staff and the food has been fresh w/ good quality. I appreciate the way this location runs. Pick up orders are noticed and prepared on time here as well, which is something I've had issues with at other locations.“

“🚨This is my go to Subway. The manager is so cool and professional. I have never came across an employee that was having a bad day. They seem to love working there. Rarely do I find a Subway with a 100 Health Score but this one had one. Everything is always so clean and bread and veggies are always fresh. Cookies are fresh too.“

“Listen here! I’ve been going to Jersey Mikes for YEARS - I’ve had good experiences and I’ve had not so good customer service. Today (Sept. 18th 2025 at 11:30am) was my first visit at this specific location and I have to say everything was above and beyond excellent.

First of all, the blonde lady with the bun greeted every customer who came in the door, asked every person in line how their day was going, and thanked every customer when they left. She is a prime example of superb customer service and honestly deserves a raise. Whatever she is getting paid, it needs to be higher - she is a rare find these days! Y’all better know her value and don’t let her go.

The dark skinned gentleman who made my sandwich was lovely as well. The ingredients were fresh, the bacon was crispy and soooo good.

The shop was clean and inviting. Tables were clean. The team was working steadily and focused on their work the whole time I was there.

This is the best Jersey Mike’s location I’ve ever been to overall. Nice work y’all 👏🏼 I will be back!“

“My family and I visited this Subway today, and we were really impressed. The restaurant was clean and well-maintained. We ordered the Chicken Bacon Ranch, BMT, and Tuna subs — all were delicious! Mrs. Rose, the manager, was incredibly helpful and kind. We really appreciated the excellent service and will definitely be coming back next time“

“We ordered two trays online (1 toasted and 1 cold) thinking that “toasted” would be warm/steamed like in the restaurant. When I picked them up, the bread was toasted and then put in the cooler. When I explained what I had wanted, David was more than willing to accommodate me but told me I’d have to wait about 15 minutes. I totally understood that, but he insisted on giving me a gift card to make up for my wait. Cameron set about remaking the tray of subs using steamed meat and cheese! David and Cameron are two of the best!!! They kept apologizing about how long I had to wait. They were so quick to correct the order!“

“I order both to go and in store here pretty often! I moved further into Madison, but I still make the drive for this location because they always get my order perfect! I'm super picky about how much sauce goes on my sandwich and this location always put the perfect amount!“

“Great experience, but I was not able to order extra pickles on the side like I can at the one on 72. Other than that it was a great experience and the food was really delicious. I also had a coupon that I got since this is a new location. Very happy to not have to drive down 72 to get chicken salad chick.“

“The manager Matt is incredible, he truly has made such a difference in the Madison location, I have loved firehouse for years but the previous management and staff at this location ruined it completely for me from their bad attitudes to the way the subs tasted. Since Matt has been there my family started going back to firehouse because of how much things have changed for the better, the quality of food and service is exceptional. We’re so happy Matt is there and we’re so thankful for him.“

“Love the sandwiches! Will be back. Service was great, too, and they were busy. Please keep in mind and show some grace since they just opened and have kinks to work out.“