26 Best Pizza Restaurants in Surprise

“This was our first time ordering from Papa Murphy's and we'll definitely be back. We ordered the cowboy pizza minus the olives and it was made correctly and on time. When I walked in I wasn't sure where to pick up the pizza, but the staff helped direct me to the right place. It was really busy since it was Christmas Eve but staff was welcoming and helpful. The pizza was delicious too!!“

“I did not eat inside but where i do order online I am always given quick and convenient service. I’ve gotten the Chicago deep dish many times but this most recent visit was by far the best. They had put light sauce as I ordered and the seasoning they used to top the pizza was a 10/10 it tasted so much better than every other time I’ve ordered the same pizza.I would definitely get it again.“

“we have been out here in AZ for 16 years from Chicago. there is no other pizza we choose Deno's is the place. Never scrimps. Great sausage, only thin crust no other crust choices , thin crust cut in squares, the real way. their beef sandwiches are great ,piled high with lots of beef get more gravy on the side. Fries, ex excellent.. they are the real deal. have small dining area tables, go up and order your food they bring to you. self serve soda, you can also byob here. been going here many years , down home real chi pizza. no other crust offered here,they only make the thin crust piled high . eat in or pick up. not sure if door dash or others . this is the local treasure.“

“Awesome job on the meatball sandwich! Great, friendly fast service!“

“These boys at Luckys’s pizza in surprise were so precious! they made sure my food was all there, interacted with Ellyott and were so polite and adorable!!! Food was delicious but the customer service is why i’ll return 😍“

“was like a real East Coast pizza.“

“Pizza specials are great for lunch. I love Barros pizza ?. This is from the sub sandwiches, to the pizza lunch specials pizza, salad and a drink, to the amazing whole pizzas it's a favorite. I'll get photos next time. Staff was friendly.“

“We are new to Surprise and spent some time trying different pizza places around town. And this place has the best thin crust (east coast style) hands down. Crust, sauce and toppings are fresh and delicious. Definitely worth checking out!“

“the pizza was 5star. tons of cheese great crust. closet to NY pizza since I've lived here.“

“Food was yummy, portions were generous. Great service by Andy!“

“Tap House Sports Grill – A Must-Visit Spot for Great Food & Drinks If you're looking for a top-notch dining experience, look no further than Tap House Sports Grill. From the moment you walk in, you're greeted with a welcoming atmosphere, friendly service, and an unbeatable selection of food and drinks. Let’s start with the food—the Slider is an absolute must-try. Perfectly seasoned and cooked to perfection, it’s one of the best in town. The Stromboli and Calzone are also highly recommended, stuffed with delicious fillings and baked just right. And if you're in the mood for an appetizer, the Dugout Dip is a real winner! Honestly, there’s not a single dish here that isn’t top-notch. The kitchen staff knows what they’re doing, and every bite proves it. Now, let’s talk drinks. Tap House Sports Grill boasts an amazing beer selection and a great variety of tequilas. Whether you're a craft beer lover or a tequila enthusiast, there’s something for you. And if you love a good cocktail, their Bloody Mary and Bloody Maria are absolute game-changers—especially with the bacon garnish! The bartenders—Jen, Chris, and Makynzie—are fantastic. They know their craft, mix up killer drinks, and keep the good times rolling. Every server here goes above and beyond to make sure your meal, drinks, and overall experience are nothing short of excellent. If you haven’t been to Tap House Sports Grill yet, it’s time to change that. Whether you're stopping by for a meal, drinks, or just to enjoy the atmosphere, you won’t be disappointed. Highly recommended!“

“Just discovered this place near my office. I have visited twice recently for carryout lunch. Both times something different, and both times highly satisfied. Today, however, I have to brag loudly about the Eggplant Parmesan Hoagie - - - - absolutely delicious!!!“

“This place was delicious and great priced! I was in town visiting family and had never gone to Surprise before. My roommate took me here for lunch and I went back twice! Try their Suicide Sauce! I bought two to-go containers to take back to San Diego.“

“I ordered a American Hawaiian pizza. I asked for 1/2 pepperoni only and The rest of the toppings on the other half, pizza came just as I ordered. It was crunchy and very delicious.
I also order chicken wings mild. They were delicious and crispy, for some people might be overcooked, but to me it was perfect kinda like eating, cracklings and chicken wings at the same time. I will definitely come back. Also, the lady who Took my order was helpful.“

“Get the pizza and wings! Yum!“

“I love this mod pizza so much! All of the employees and mangers are so sweet, they take the time out of their day and ask you how yours is. Never had a wrong order or bad experience here! Even through DoorDash they are amazing!

Kid-friendliness: Always quick to ask if you’re having a good day, and have genuine connections with there customers!“

“My husband went in tonight and the staff was so wonderful it inspired me to write a long overdo review. We’ve lived down the road from this location for over two years and have gotten more pizza than I would like to admit. The staff is fantastic, they’ve always gotten our correct order, it’s always hot and ready and who can beat hungry Howies crust?? Especially the stuffed crust. Thank you everyone that was there tonight! You guys are wonderful and we’ll be back of course!“

“Best pizza in town. Pan pizza with White sauce with pep or sausage and if you like spicey add jalepeno.. man o man.. everyone i know calls it the rukis cuz it is amazing and my goto. Simply the best pizza ever.. pair it with some dots.. and your will thank me later for the rukis combo... trust...

Kid-friendliness: My daughter rides with me all the time, they are all always kind and acknowledge her and greeting her.“

“I love this place! Great food and always ready on time. As a teacher they are so supportive of the Book It! program and I am grateful for that. They have assisted our school for years! A BIG thank you to this location for all their dedication to service!!Noah and Brynn are always ready and willing to support our local teachers! They are friendly and provide outstanding service.“

“The food is good and the employees are awesome. I scored Service low because the last time I was there I was charged a 4% service fee for using my debit card...I'm very disappointed that they are doing that and will not be going back unless they stop charging that fee. ?“

“I believe this was a non dine in place. Pizza was excellent for sure and I have been dying for some Pizza hut Pizza! Idk perhaps it's just a favorite of mine. I love the hand tossed or pan, Supreme or pepperoni. But whatever the Pizza is I'm sure it's delish! I will always be a customer for their Pizza. Thanks Pizza UT for making such scrumptious Pizza for all the years I've know ya. Your P-awesome!“

“Are you searching for a small place in Surprise, AZ for an upcoming celebration with great delicious menu? Look no further and reserve a mid-size private dining room at Mountain Mike’s Pizza conveniently located near Grand Ave & Bell Road. This spot has a great staff who are always providing a welcoming atmosphere in a super clean environment. The food is delicious and reasonably priced. (Thank you for reading this review - I am writing reviews of everywhere I eat when I dine out, places I shop, movies I watch and much more. Stay posted with #ReviewByTsídiiAbíní)“

“People make mistakes and our food took longer than expected. I don’t fault them for this as it was probably their busiest day. What I can applaud is there ability to quickly resolve an issue. We are not all going to be the first served but I can respect when someone admits to an issue and works towards a resolution. Overall I will come back and try again since they try so hard. It is a new restaurant give them time to build.

Kid-friendliness: A lot of people have kids so you don’t feel like the odd one out.“

“These were such a sad example for the pepperoni puffs. It was so small that the slice of pepperoni would have been way to big for them. They tasted burnt and were hard to in general. Overall I'd say, don't have high hopes with these, especially in Surprise, Arizona.“

“Queen creek location first trip. Everything was great! Jessica was a great hostess. Would highly recommend!“

“If I could give 10 Stars I definitely would! Linda the manager at this store is awesome and definitely pulled through for me! I ordered a pizza and I got somebody else's pizza and it was a couple of months back and she completely remembered and let me redeem my original order! Although they only go back 30 days to redeem your pizza, she worked with me and it was a wonderful experience! Linda keep up the great work you're awesome!“