17 Best Pizza Restaurants in Goodyear

“Very Tasty Pizza and! Very friendly and peoffessional staff.“

“Everything about this pizza was done right. The crust had the perfect balance of crispy and chewy, the sauce tasted fresh and well-seasoned, and the toppings were high quality without overwhelming the pizza itself. You can tell care goes into every pie here. ALSO the salad is amazing!“

“Great service! David was our server and he was fabulous! Thanks!!!!👍“

“Our Cowboy Pizza was really good.
But, I had to go to Estrella to get it.We live near Millenium High. Our Avondale location was closed by the owner. Our call to order was auto fwd to Estrella. This is a big difference in time spent to do business with Papa Murphy's. Don't see a second effort anytime soon.“

“We live nearby, so we go to Barro's on McDowell in Goodyear quite often. Both, my husband and I love their pizza, and I usually order wings . I can't consume a full order of wings, so I take the rest home. Lately the wings have been VERY dry . They are NOT as good as they used to be. Are they pre-cooked nowadays ? They taste even worse the next day when I try to reheat them (not in the microwave). :(“

“Best Gluten-free pizza I’ve had! I’m from the Chicago area and was visiting my sister in AZ, so we had the opportunity to try “Old Chicago” last Friday evening. There was a 35 minute wait. Totally worth the wait! We were seated within the time frame designated. All the staff were friendly and Brandy and Patti were awesome servers! Very personable and attentive. Our table split a big chicken salad, then enjoyed the Tavern Thin Pizza and I had the GF pizza. It really was the best GF crust I’ve had. We did end up taking most of the pizza home to enjoy the next day. Food was great, as was the atmosphere. Very clean. It’s understandable why there is a crowd. Would love to come back here!“

“The reservation process was very easy and fast to set up for a table. The staff was very friendly and professional and assisted our table to check on how we are doing many times throughout our stay. Great experience. We will be back. Thank you!!“

“first of all. wings are big and delicious. sauces are great! good price. second of all. just got a sausage and cheese pizza this is barros on steroids. so good“

“Chili cheese fries and the patriot burger were amazing!!! My server Aminata was FANTASTIC!!! Can’t wait to go back!“

“Absolutely the best pizza I've had in Phoenix! 🍕

I ordered the Wings and the Pepperoni & Sausage, and both were outstanding. The crust is perfectly thin and crispy with just the right amount of chew — exactly how I like it. The sauce is fresh, garlicky, and not too sweet, and the cheese is gooey and flavorful without being greasy.

The toppings were generous and high quality. You can really taste that everything is fresh. Even the side of garlic bread was warm, soft inside, and crispy on the edges — addictive!
Service was super friendly and fast. My order was ready right on time for pickup, and the staff even threw in a couple of extra dipping sauces with a smile.

This place has easily become my new go-to pizza spot in the valley. If you're looking for authentic, delicious pizza that doesn't break the bank, stop by here immediately. You won't be disappointed!

Highly recommend — I’ll definitely be back soon (probably this weekend 😂).“

“We order fairly often & our only complaint is that our store #9208 doesn't read/follow the instructions to NOT include salad dressings & forks. We realize they're likely just wanting to provide great customer service by including those but it's frustrating when we've specifically updated our profile/checkout instructions to NOT include those (to avoid waste). Other than that, the pizza is always hot whether it's delivered or we opt to utilize curbside. The wings, breadbites & sandwiches are decent. LOVE their prepackaged salads. And we didn't realize how addicting their brownies would be! (You've been warned! ;) ) Oh, and love their tracker & rewards program! <3 THANKS :D“

“my daughter & i regularly go to the one in avondale, az. and the manager Laura & crew member camden are outstanding! She well trained her crew on service & helps to make each experience memorable. I will definitely keep coming to this location. Pizza & selection of food is outstanding too!“

“I started an online order and waited for my tracker to let me know it was ready, so I walked in about the time it normally would be ready for pick up. The team member I talked to said they had no orders come in due to a blackout from the dust storm that just happened. I was ready to submit my order again and pay but they were amazing and made my order for me free of charge. Both team members were great to work with and were very helpful and nice! 10/10 will go back and recommend to anyone!“

“Amazing people and delicious food“

“This is my first time ever going into a MOD Pizza and it was such a delight, the worker who was up front at the time was really nice to me and helped explain everything from the menu items along with different sauce offerings and also what I wanted on the pizza. It was nice that she asked if I was allergic because I asked for the cauliflower option. I got my order pretty quickly since it was relatively empty. The food tastes wonderful and it definitely hit the spot. I will definitely come back again when I have the chance or if I'm in the area. Carla was a real delight and also was really attentive. She made ordering easy along with them explaining to me how the stuff on the app can get me free points to be used for free meals. So it was a great time and I highly recommend people to go here.“

“First time here. HIGHLY recommend the artichoke, shrimp and crab dip. It was the best part. I wish they served it in a bread bowl. Straight from Heaven. The lemon chicken tortelloni was just ok because the chicken was very dry. The flavors were good though. My husband was very pleased with the Italiano sandwich. He said it was what he would expect if he were actually in Italy. Dessert was also very good. The hot honey cinnamon crunch and the big warm chocolate cookie topped with ice cream we're worth going back for. We will definitely go back. Next time I will try their highly acclaimed spaghetti and meatballs.“

“We had a great experience at Tailgaters. The service was excellent and completely on point. Our waitress Dre was attentive, friendly and made sure we had everything we needed throughout our visit. The food and atmosphere were both enjoyable and we will definitely be back!“