29 Best Pizza Restaurants in Surprise

“This was our first time ordering from Papa Murphy's and we'll definitely be back. We ordered the cowboy pizza minus the olives and it was made correctly and on time. When I walked in I wasn't sure where to pick up the pizza, but the staff helped direct me to the right place. It was really busy since it was Christmas Eve but staff was welcoming and helpful. The pizza was delicious too!!“

“Ordered pizza and wings last week and STILL thinking about it! You KNOW when it’s good cheese!!! 🧀 My son and I were truly WOW’d, SOOO good!!! Do yourself a favor and get the garlic crust!! Keep up the great work!!! 🍕🥰“

“These boys at Luckys’s pizza in surprise were so precious! they made sure my food was all there, interacted with Ellyott and were so polite and adorable!!! Food was delicious but the customer service is why i’ll return 😍“

“Awesome job on the meatball sandwich! Great, friendly fast service!“

“I was a little frustrated, it was my first time to Rosati’s and it took quite a bit longer than expected for the pizza to be ready. However the pizza was delicious and definitely worth the wait. I will definitely go back for more!!“

“we have been out here in AZ for 16 years from Chicago. there is no other pizza we choose Deno's is the place. Never scrimps. Great sausage, only thin crust no other crust choices , thin crust cut in squares, the real way. their beef sandwiches are great ,piled high with lots of beef get more gravy on the side. Fries, ex excellent.. they are the real deal. have small dining area tables, go up and order your food they bring to you. self serve soda, you can also byob here. been going here many years , down home real chi pizza. no other crust offered here,they only make the thin crust piled high . eat in or pick up. not sure if door dash or others . this is the local treasure.“

“I love Pizza Hut and it’s always so clean and welcoming whenever I visit one. I always appreciate having a place to sit even if the restaurant is smaller. Highly recommend visiting this one! They have a very diverse group of workers 🏳️‍🌈:)“

“was like a real East Coast pizza.“

“I'm so happy we have another pizza place by us "Waddell" folks (the forgotten community for delivery). Food was amazing. Extremely quick delivery (and they followed instructions). Pleasant customer service (had to call after I placed my online order because I forgot to add a couple items). ZERO complaints! Will order again for sure ? “

“you guys are amazing! I enjoy my visits each time I'm in amazing staff, food and drinks! :) I love the buffalo chicken pizza and my favorite drinks are the mango vodoo ranger and the white chocolate beer with a shot of skrewball“

“We are new to Surprise and spent some time trying different pizza places around town. And this place has the best thin crust (east coast style) hands down. Crust, sauce and toppings are fresh and delicious. Definitely worth checking out!“

“Best decision I’ve made today. I was out by Surprise and wanted pizza. Pizza is a safe food during this pregnancy. So glad I came here. The BEST pizza crust ever. Everything was made to order and fresh. Atmosphere is chill and low key. If I’m ever in this area again I am stopping in for sure.“

“This was our first time having pizza here and we were impressed by the large menu and the great service. The portion sizes were huge. Then the food came, fast and it was fabulous! We ordered a large pizza, a couple salads and a meatball sandwich. Their sauce was great tasty and has to be homemade full of flavor. We normally order from another pizza place and have for years, very loyal customers. We were actually divided between 2 different ones, we have switched now. We are a US Pizza Family lol“

“Food was yummy, portions were generous. Great service by Andy!“

“I'm a former resident of Connecticut where u can find the best Pizza restaurants in USA Pepe's, Zuppardi's Apizza, One6Three, Works, etc actually living in AZ but this restaurant in Surprise is the best one so far they could make competition with those in the Northeast, the pizza here is well prepare, quality of ingredients, well done and the affordable price you pay for a delicious pizza to enjoy your palete.“

“Just discovered this place near my office. I have visited twice recently for carryout lunch. Both times something different, and both times highly satisfied. Today, however, I have to brag loudly about the Eggplant Parmesan Hoagie - - - - absolutely delicious!!!“

“I took a small party in the evening to Wing Street, this was my first visit. I was impressed by the broad variety of flavorings they used for their wings. I like hot, hot ,hot and they supplied it and the heat did not take away from the flavor of the wings. We order a large tray of wings and they brought out containers of sauces for us to try and I tried them all.I walked away thinking that I had to return to this place. We took a lot of wings home that night.“

“I do love Jet’s pizza and order frequently. Sadly, the last two pizzas I ordered were not up to par. The toppings were scattered helter skelter leaving slices with minimal toppings. The Eugene Supreme I tried for the first time barely had any sausage. I have previously found the toppings to be generous. I hope this is corrected soon as $20 for a specialty pizza is expensive for me

EDIT 7/3/2026
Update to my earlier review. I’ve ordered 3-4 pizzas since my review and am happy to report all toppings sitting comfortably atop my pizza and deliciousness in every bite. My favorite is the Ultimate Pepperoni Four Square with butter crust. Thank you Jets for making such a fabulous pizza (and I’m a Chicago burbs pizza snob to boot!)“

“I don't drink but the food was good, got the Reuben came with a huge amount of good fries. My buddy who did drink had good local beer and some Laphroaig which is always good. But the service was especially quick, soon as I finished my water she got me a new one. He only had an empty glass when he chose. We went on a weeknight when it wasn't too busy“

“Get the pizza and wings! Yum!“

“Encountered an issue with Doordash. Staff took it upon themselves to go above and beyond, comping the order as a resolution to Doordashes mistake. It was an unexpected gesture and greatly appreciated. I highly recommend this store. Delicious pizza, great service!“

“Employee attended me on the spot great customer service & food 🔥🔥🔥🤙🏽“

“Great food. Sad they had run out of calamari by 6pm. Must be really good! Service was really great. Our server had a great personality and was very attentive. Super nice and clean establishment. Portions of pastas are huge. Even the kids menu. Portions are equal to regular portions so if you have littles, you may want them to share.“

“Are you searching for a small place in Surprise, AZ for an upcoming celebration with great delicious menu? Look no further and reserve a mid-size private dining room at Mountain Mike’s Pizza conveniently located near Grand Ave & Bell Road. This spot has a great staff who are always providing a welcoming atmosphere in a super clean environment. The food is delicious and reasonably priced. (Thank you for reading this review - I am writing reviews of everywhere I eat when I dine out, places I shop, movies I watch and much more. Stay posted with #ReviewByTsídiiAbíní)“

“Queen creek location first trip. Everything was great! Jessica was a great hostess. Would highly recommend!“

“My pizza order took 10 extra minutes and I wasn't mad. The cashier was very sweet. It's the day before Thanksgiving. Everyone wanted an easy meal. There was a girl there, definitely not a lady, with two children, cussing up a storm because she had to wait five minutes. Great role model. She was just awful and the staff was so patient with her. Thanks to all the staff there for the delicious pizza and outstanding customer service on such a busy night.“

“10/10 tonight! It was easy and quick to order online. Was able to take advantage of the great deal they had for the second night in a row. My kids were so excited to build their own half of a pizza. It was ready quick and I was promptly handed my hot pizzas with a smile. Even found time to ask if there was anything else and wish me a good night. The pizzas were perfect! Well distributed toppings and equally cut slices. Everyone was impressed and full. Great experience!“

“Karissa, Giselle, Johanna, Isha, Bryanna and Keyla have always had great customer service towards me with welcoming energy! It makes me want to come back for my plain pretzel bites. They have great conversations with me and I even come in to just say hi to them, they know me as Jared :)
The ladies are always working hard and I would love if they got shown some appreciation for their hard work.
THANK YOU“

“Best kept secret in Surprise if you are in the mood for delicious Italian dishes! First time experience. Our waiter, Grayson went through the menu describing the dishes and flavors; expressed his favorites as well as customer favorites. No disappointments!! Every dish was incredible. Dishes arrived hot, plated beautifully and every bite savored because of its flavors.
As I observed, all of the wait staff were extremely attentive to the dining guests. Tables were bussed and readied for the next guest immediately so no dining guest was left to look at a dirty table.
The restaurant itself is open yet each seating gives space for table conversation. The design and colors chosen are pleasing and calming. Yes, as you can tell by my review we will return!
Mine is just one opinion, but if you choose to dine here, I hope your experience is as enjoyable as ours.“