11 Best Italian Restaurants in Surprise

“Beautiful atmosphere. The food is absolutely AMAZING. The lady that took my pickup order over the phone was very nice & I can’t believe how happy my family is over our meals. We got spaghetti with salad, bread (which is my favorite by the way), meatballs(10/10), and French onion soup! My kids don’t even like onions - yet loved the soup! Seriously give this place a 10/10. Thank you for a wonderful meal with my family.“

“I go to your restaurant quiet frequently. Yesterday and again today, our server was Tree. She was and is always a delightful wait person. She goes out of her way to make certain that our requests are met. In addition, she is friendly and always knows our names.“

“We visited Olive Garden on 04/14/26 and were lucky enough to have Kelsie G. as our server, and she delivered the best service we have ever experienced at any Olive Garden. Kelsie is exceptional — genuinely warm, incredibly attentive, and so dialed‑in that we never had to ask for a single thing. She anticipated every need before we even noticed it ourselves.

We go to this OG a lot! The food is always good but the reason we keep coming back... it's for the amazing service! Every waiter or waitress has the greatest attitude and always on top of their game except for today...... we had a waiter that was new and things were a little slow at a slow time of the day. That's ok, we've all been new but what stands out is we had Steph (a restaurant lead) come over, acknowledged that we were regulars and made sure things were back on track! Steph is one of those people that go above and beyond, and is always so pleasant and kind! Again, she's part of the reason we go back!
If you have not eaten at this OG, absolutely give it a try!
Thank you Steph for turning our dining experience pleasant once again! Your kindness means so much!

Previous Post
Her recommendations were perfect, her timing was flawless, and she made the entire meal feel special from start to finish. Kelsie didn’t just serve us dinner — she created an experience.

We will absolutely be returning because of her. Olive Garden is lucky to have someone of her caliber.“

“Food is delicious! Service fast! Great server!“

“Awesome job on the meatball sandwich! Great, friendly fast service!“

“Best kept secret in Surprise if you are in the mood for delicious Italian dishes! First time experience. Our waiter, Grayson went through the menu describing the dishes and flavors; expressed his favorites as well as customer favorites. No disappointments!! Every dish was incredible. Dishes arrived hot, plated beautifully and every bite savored because of its flavors.
As I observed, all of the wait staff were extremely attentive to the dining guests. Tables were bussed and readied for the next guest immediately so no dining guest was left to look at a dirty table.
The restaurant itself is open yet each seating gives space for table conversation. The design and colors chosen are pleasing and calming. Yes, as you can tell by my review we will return!
Mine is just one opinion, but if you choose to dine here, I hope your experience is as enjoyable as ours.“

“I don't eat red meat. But I do at Richie's. That should say it all.“

“I was a little frustrated, it was my first time to Rosati’s and it took quite a bit longer than expected for the pizza to be ready. However the pizza was delicious and definitely worth the wait. I will definitely go back for more!!“

“I'm a former resident of Connecticut where u can find the best Pizza restaurants in USA Pepe's, Zuppardi's Apizza, One6Three, Works, etc actually living in AZ but this restaurant in Surprise is the best one so far they could make competition with those in the Northeast, the pizza here is well prepare, quality of ingredients, well done and the affordable price you pay for a delicious pizza to enjoy your palete.“

“Food was yummy, portions were generous. Great service by Andy!“

“Get the pizza and wings! Yum!“