10 Best Italian Restaurants in Goodyear

“Came here with my family to celebrate a birthday, had an excellent experience at Olive Garden thanks to our server, Dez. From the moment we were seated, Dez was friendly, attentive, and professional. He made sure our drinks stayed full, checked in at the perfect times, and made us feel genuinely welcome throughout the meal 10/10.“

“I LOVE Dino’s!! If you’re in the Goodyear / Avondale area you have to eat here! Delicious food ! Never a wait even during peak hours. Good pizza , wings , calzones. Athenian club - amazing meal for two! If you’re looking for a new restaurant to try or if you just haven’t been in a while; get in!! Support our lovely local small businesses!“

“Great food & friendly service.“

“Very Tasty Pizza and! Very friendly and peoffessional staff.“

“Everything about this pizza was done right. The crust had the perfect balance of crispy and chewy, the sauce tasted fresh and well-seasoned, and the toppings were high quality without overwhelming the pizza itself. You can tell care goes into every pie here. ALSO the salad is amazing!“

“This is a nice little fast dining Italian restaurant. The service and employees are exceptional. The prices were very reasonable, and the food decent. We purchased a Vegetable Pizza, chicken wings, and fried mushrooms. I would recommend if you are looking for a fast dining Italian restaurant experience.“

“First time here. HIGHLY recommend the artichoke, shrimp and crab dip. It was the best part. I wish they served it in a bread bowl. Straight from Heaven. The lemon chicken tortelloni was just ok because the chicken was very dry. The flavors were good though. My husband was very pleased with the Italiano sandwich. He said it was what he would expect if he were actually in Italy. Dessert was also very good. The hot honey cinnamon crunch and the big warm chocolate cookie topped with ice cream we're worth going back for. We will definitely go back. Next time I will try their highly acclaimed spaghetti and meatballs.“

“Great service! David was our server and he was fabulous! Thanks!!!!👍“

“Absolutely the best pizza I've had in Phoenix! 🍕

I ordered the Wings and the Pepperoni & Sausage, and both were outstanding. The crust is perfectly thin and crispy with just the right amount of chew — exactly how I like it. The sauce is fresh, garlicky, and not too sweet, and the cheese is gooey and flavorful without being greasy.

The toppings were generous and high quality. You can really taste that everything is fresh. Even the side of garlic bread was warm, soft inside, and crispy on the edges — addictive!
Service was super friendly and fast. My order was ready right on time for pickup, and the staff even threw in a couple of extra dipping sauces with a smile.

This place has easily become my new go-to pizza spot in the valley. If you're looking for authentic, delicious pizza that doesn't break the bank, stop by here immediately. You won't be disappointed!

Highly recommend — I’ll definitely be back soon (probably this weekend 😂).“

“We live nearby, so we go to Barro's on McDowell in Goodyear quite often. Both, my husband and I love their pizza, and I usually order wings . I can't consume a full order of wings, so I take the rest home. Lately the wings have been VERY dry . They are NOT as good as they used to be. Are they pre-cooked nowadays ? They taste even worse the next day when I try to reheat them (not in the microwave). :(“