30 Best Pizza Restaurants in Peoria

“Had good food and Courtney H. took good care of us good sense of humor and she made sure our drinks never went empty.“

“Pizza is yummy and sandwich’s are delicious! You will feel like family when you are there. Thank you for supporting Liberty Lions.“

“Amazing pizza and great service! The crust was perfectly crispy, the toppings were fresh, and the flavors were on point. The staff was friendly and welcoming, and the atmosphere was clean and comfortable. Definitely a place I’ll be coming back to!!!! 👍🏼“

“⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ 5-Star Review
Mike’s Market is one of those true hidden gems that you almost don’t want to tell people about but it’s just too good not to share. From the moment I walked in, the vibe was welcoming and friendly, the kind of place where you can tell they genuinely care about their customers 😊👏
We ordered the garlic cheese pizza, and wow… absolutely incredible 🍕🧄🧀 The crust was perfectly cooked, not too thick and not too thin, with just the right balance of crunch and softness. The garlic flavor was bold but not overpowering, the cheese was melty and generous, and every slice tasted fresh and made with care. A large pizza easily fed four adults, and everyone was full and happy, which says a lot about the portion size and value.
What really stood out, besides the food, was how super nice and accommodating the staff was. Friendly service like that makes you want to come back again and again. This place is close to a friend’s house, and after this experience, it’s officially going to be a regular stop. If you’re anywhere near Peoria and want amazing pizza, great portions, fair prices, and awesome people, do yourself a favor and check this place out. You won’t regret it 😄🔥🍕“

“The Calzone is excellent. We ate there three times in the span of a couple of weeks while in AZ“

“Friendly staff and great food. Did not expect such large salads and took home half of a medium pizza.“

“Our pizza was great! I was thrilled to see a dairy free option for my lactose intolerant little man and the dairy free cheese was actually good!!! My daughter who usually claims she doesnt Like Papa Murphys said this location makes way better pizza than the one on 59th that closed! The employee was very friendly and my order was ready when I arrived! We are so happy this location is still open and still somewhat close to us, and worth the drive!“

“Great food & friendly staff … we went after it was featured on Good Morning Arizona TV program“

“Wowwww 🤩 i haven't had a deep dish this good in a long time! My friend told me about this place and i am sooo excited that she was right about the buttery crispy crust on the 4 corner pizza 😋😋 i took photos of the side and bottom so you can see how delicious it is and come here to try it for yourself 😎❤️ the cinnamon bread was sooo good too 😋😋❤️ the staff were friendly and helpful 😎❤️ i only gave 4 stars because we thought this was a dine in place but its not its a take out place 👎 they have some seating outside but we really wanted to enjoy indoor seating . So just remember, delicious food but take out only .“

“Pizza Star is the best .“

“Love this place! I take friends and family here when they come to town and want an amazing experience and great pizza 🙌“

“You all did it, great job. You can taste the food quality, pizza ingredients are obviously top quality and fresh, the wings slide right off the bone, perfect. Wish we would have tried this place years ago, you really gotta get your name out there. All I'm saying is, Tailgaters lost a customer today, for good. Tailgaters service is rude, ignores you, and doesn't care; food is mediocre at best. Uncle Sams, fast, friendly, delicious. You just got a new regular.“

“Medium size pizza place with beer and drinks. We were a party of 6 on a Friday night. No trouble getting a table. Waitress was excellent, courteous and helpful with menu questions I had. Prompt service. I had a slice of Chicken Cacciatore pizza and it was excellent. I added a dinner salad, salad was fresh and good, with Balsamic dressing. Great food and experience!“

“I stopped in while I was in the area for Sunday Breakfast. What a great decision. Great food. Waitress, Shandra, was very knowledgeable, fun and efficient. I’ll definitely be returning!“

“I love this place!“

“Hands down the best tasting Calazone I've had in Arizona. Nice friendly staff. Can't wait to sample more delicious items.“

“Yummmm…enough said! Keep it up❣️“

“So much fun.🤩 I like how you don’t have to carry around all those tickets anymore. It all goes on the card or bracelet“

“Great option in the Central Valley! Just moved to Glendale from N Phoenix and wanted a closer option. This definitely hit the spot! Quick delivery via third party delivery service and the pizza was awesome! Thanks Lucky’s!“

“CJ is a young man that has made customer service his art? He was prompt and always asked if we required more. I would definitely refer this young man to host all future parties. Private Room was nice but the location not so much, we were in the back where we could not see Our Guests or Children playing otherwise a very nice place.“

“Decided to try this place for the first time tonight and... way to leave something to be desired.

1. I'm gonna assume the dining room was half full of pizza boxes because of the super bowl tomorrow, so not counting that against ya.

2. Yes, I should've checked my order at the store, but it was already a late backup plan for dinner for the family. I ordered half cheese and half sausage and pepperoni since I have a 4 year old who loves cheese pizza. I get home to find half pep, half sausage. That said, the pizza did taste pretty good, especially when I took the pepperoni off one slice and added it to a slice of sausage.

3. Caesar salad was advertised to come tossed in dressing and it was dry. Thankfully I ordered an extra side of dressing and it turned out to be a pretty average salad.

4. Bread sticks were a waste of money. Imagine Olive Garden bread sticks, but with 1/10th of the garlic butter and dry. We didn't even finish half the order and I threw them out.

Will I be back? Jury's still out.

Update: Sub 48 hour response, which I'd even count as less than 24 because of the game yesterday. Thank you for the refund, you didn't need to do that. Also, not tossing the salads for pick up orders makes a lot of sense and I actually appreciate that. All in all, you have swayed the jury and I'll definitely give you guys another try in the not too distant future. Star ratings have also been updated.“

“Fox News just ate in New York at Grimaldi’s! I miss this pizza. I live in west Texas & none yet!“

“Awesome wings!!!! Lexi D is an amazing, professional server.“

“Price went up alot. Look on the website and it wasn't the same as what they quoted. Love the pizza and wings but won't order again. Over $60 Dollars for a XL pizza with 2 toppings and 24 wings.“

“Best Pizza I Have Ever Had & The Only Pizza I Will Eat.. Best Flavor, Very Fresh & Friendly Staff..Best At Everything!! I give them a 10++“

“Best hot wings e v e r!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!“

“Big fan of the hut. Love their pesto & chicken personal pan pizza. Came in tonight for some birthday breadsticks and Seth was great, friendly, and he made our breadsticks & cinnamon rolls FRESH! If anyone’s gonna make your cinnamon sticks, have Seth make them. He also has a 10/10 mustache. Thanks Pizza Hut!“

“I love Barro's pizza its NOT greasy at all and the crust is not hard its more of a soft crust like bread sticks.“

“We ordered white pizza today for the first time ; it was delicious. Thick , chewy crust , plenty of cheese ; very good . We definitely will be getting it again“

“Just had the deep dish Chicago style pizza and it's the best I've had around Sun City and even in town it was done so well tasted great would recommend to anyone that wants it deep dish Chicago style pizza“