12 Best Pizza Restaurants near Mill Bay

“This is hands down the best pizza store, not just because their pizza is fantastic, but because the staff are exceptional. They are truly salt of the earth people who genuinely care about you and your kids. They always go the extra mile to make our kids feel special whenever we pick up our pizza. Thank you! Your service on our pizza nights has created wonderful memories for us and our children.“

“The pizza is AMAZING!!! It is absolutely the best pizza we have had in the last 20 years! Great job!!!!“

“This is the best pizza around and has been for as long as I can remember.“

“Tried the turkey dinner pizza tonight and it was amazing! If you’ve been thinking about trying it, do it!“

“⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ Closest to dining in Italy as we can get for now haha 🇮🇹 So much love to this amazing restaurant and family, thank you for helping my lil family celebrate the best birthday ever. Grateful for this amazing place with amazing staff and comfort food, and the best fuzeball memories being made🔥“

“Wow—what truly exceptional customer service from Timothy! We were blown away by the surprise of a delicious pizza, crafted with such care, love, and passion. It wasn’t just food; it was a gesture that made our day. Thank you from the bottom of our hearts, Domino's Pizza Duncan. You went above and beyond, and it didn’t go unnoticed. With dedicated, thoughtful leaders like Tim, your team is destined for great things. Keep shining, Domino's Pizza Duncan—you’ve earned every bit of this praise! 😊🍕 #VeggieLoversDelight#Ash :)“

“Great pizza, just wish I could order extra sauce a little dry. Tried to find it on the web order site seems it doesn’t exist, too bad!“

“I've eaten Peninsula Pizza and Keating many times. Those are good pizzas, especially Keating. But Villages is truly better. Every few months I go back to the other two, just thinking I may have been wrong, but every time I do, I'm reminded that Villages is better!“

“We are visiting from Ontario and have been trying BBQ chicken pizzas all across the country, this one is the closest we have had to the best one at Diana’s Pizza in Hamilton. I’m partial to the barbecue sauce they use at home, but a real good wheel. Lots of toppings, nice and hot. Pretty nice guy at the counter, made me feel real welcome, anyway if you are in the neighbourhood and need a good pizza, you should try them.“

“We always enjoy Sarpinos on those busy don't want to cook nights. As a family of 7, there's something for everyone. It's easy to order and we usually pick up, which is easy as well. We had a mishap with delivery once and Sarpinos staff and owner handled it gracefully. They were very accommodating and kind.
We find the customer service at Sarpinos Shawnigan is always kind, welcoming and they are fast!
Thanks for being our go to pizza place for years now!“

“I used to dread approaching the bottle neck known as Duncan... one way to ease the rage is to stop in a grab a few slices of pizza. The slices are big enough to numb the entire aggravation of getting to the other side of town. Plenty of cheese, quality toppings and no wait time. Thumbs up from me.“

“food quality is very poor. Every time I order food or come in to eat the food that's being served is rotten! stop serving expired food and toss it out. Boston Pizza use to be an upper scale restaurant now it feels like an average bar with crappie food that's way over priced. It's truly a shame“