6 Best Italian Restaurants near Eureka

“While we are looking for a nice place for dinner. It came cross that this restaurant has a high reviews. So we came in without a reservation, well, we thought Eureka is a small town...well, we were told the sitting were completely full. But, these are nice people, and we can dine at "Two Doors down wine bar". Same menu same kitchen, the food, yes, all great! Adding a photo of Grill Calamari, this is nothing like what you had before and it is so good.“

“We had such an extraordinary dinner last night. Gabriel’s has never disappointed but last night with the power out downtown we had the pleasure of dining with a full house by candlelight. Our waiter went above and beyond bringing out course after course hot and seasoned perfectly even though I can’t imagine how the kitchen could pull that off with the lights out! Perfect N.Y. strip, fresh pasta al mare & chicken parm were all excellent . The live music was superb with the local guitar vocalist who entertained us all joyfully. What a special night and one we will remember well. Thank you!!!“

“We love this family pizza place! They have A delicious gluten free crust. My boys love the arcade! The salad bar is pretty good too. Haven't tried any of their pastas yet. But hoping they also have that in gluten free also! The service is always excellent here. I love their point system, it always saves me a few bucks. It is a family friendly atmosphere. Can't go wrong with Babe's Pizza Pasta!“

“My friends and I came here for their New Year's Eve 5 course dinner plan, and let me tell you that it was soo delicious. Each round came out amazing and the server was really nice as well. A super chill place to drink and eat and just hang.“

“Was up in Eureka with my college soccer team for a game vs Humboldt and needed a place that could seat about 24 and get quality food out quickly. Did some research and cane across Paul's who had great reviews and space with tables and booths. I let each table order their own food so we got a range of pizzas including massive XL's, pasta and salads. Food came out fast and was excellent. Portions were perfect and the staff was very accommodating and friendly. The place lived up to the hype. Definitely recommend and if back up north I know where I'll be headed.“

“Absolutely great experience! The appetizers at the bar were awesome. Once we got to the teppenyaki table, it was even better. We were a party of 10, and our server Vanessa was the absolute best!!! She was so incredibly helpful and efficient. And she has the best attitude!! The chef was amazing and our food was so tasty! All this while the place was busy... and I do mean BUSY!! GREAT PLACE TO BE!“