10 Best Pizza Restaurants in Eureka

“While we are looking for a nice place for dinner. It came cross that this restaurant has a high reviews. So we came in without a reservation, well, we thought Eureka is a small town...well, we were told the sitting were completely full. But, these are nice people, and we can dine at "Two Doors down wine bar". Same menu same kitchen, the food, yes, all great! Adding a photo of Grill Calamari, this is nothing like what you had before and it is so good.“

“WONDERFUL experience. The food was AMAZING, the decor was AWESOME, the staff was EXCELLENT. I'm from out of town and went on a whim, I had a doctor's appointment nearby. The price was affordable and just the whole experience was really great. Highly recommend!! They make everything including the sauces by hand. So worth it!!Parking: Parking was easier found behind the buildingKid-friendliness: Plenty of space for the kiddos!!“

“We love this family pizza place! They have A delicious gluten free crust. My boys love the arcade! The salad bar is pretty good too. Haven't tried any of their pastas yet. But hoping they also have that in gluten free also! The service is always excellent here. I love their point system, it always saves me a few bucks. It is a family friendly atmosphere. Can't go wrong with Babe's Pizza Pasta!“

“Was up in Eureka with my college soccer team for a game vs Humboldt and needed a place that could seat about 24 and get quality food out quickly. Did some research and cane across Paul's who had great reviews and space with tables and booths. I let each table order their own food so we got a range of pizzas including massive XL's, pasta and salads. Food came out fast and was excellent. Portions were perfect and the staff was very accommodating and friendly. The place lived up to the hype. Definitely recommend and if back up north I know where I'll be headed.“

“Amazing staff, always a fun experience. More than just great pizza! Consistently fast. The manager is super friendly as well. ❤️Vegetarian options: A vast array of veggies and even a vegan Italian sausageDietary restrictions: Two different gluten friendly crusts as well as a great dairy free cheese“

“I grew up where the best pizza in the world is grown, so needless to say i know good pizza( so i guess i said it even though i didnt have to...ah £¥ck it) well this is in the top 2 or 3 on the west coast and some days it is mos def #1, and always worth it! Stoked to have found it?“

“Pizza is good for the price. The normal cheese is great. Bread sticks taste like shoe rubber and they have the texture like a shoe also so id avoid them otherwise food is good. Crappy location with bums all day in and out but they gotta eat tooStaff is always nice and helpful , it just gets crowded sometimes always order ahead .parking sucks sometimes.“

“Well this use to be my fave place, called about ordering and applying my rewards for a discount, the girl that answer said she didn't know how and the other person was to busy to help. I get it I also do customer service work, but there's a certain way to treat customers. So the cook Gee called me back! I ended up getting my rewards and ordering from the app, went in to pick up and Gee came out to apologize and gave me a free order or bread sticks, he was super nice. He said a couple people called out, I appreciate his efforts thou. I was having an off day too, say this made my night! & I got my Pizza with a 49% off since the 49ers won“

“Two PizzasI bought two family size pizzas at Murphy’s Pizza in Henderson Center after walking our dog Coyote on the beach. On the way home I had one more stop to make at Winco. This became a dilemma since I would have to leave the pizzas alone with Coyote who was already scoping them out as belonging to her. Usually I save getting the pizza until last when running errands just to avoid this kind of situation.I had gotten two bags of cement on our route home so I figured I could cover the pizzas with a ground cloth and then lay one of the bags over the whole thing. Yeah, I figured they would be more squished but what could I do? I took the pizzas out of the back and stuck them on the roof while I arranged the spot to put them. They looked pretty good up there, far from Coyote, but it was way too tempting a place to leave them even for a minute.As I left I didn’t take a backward glance as I usually do to make sure Coyote and the car are good.On my way out from Winco, walking toward the car, I thought perhaps Coyote had nibbled on any bit of pizza that wasn’t directly under the cement bag but she wouldn’t get much at least. I felt good about the whole thing.I gave Coyote some hugs and then started loading stuff out of the cart and into the car. Something wasn’t right though….where were the dang pizzas? I ruled out Coyote pretty quick since there was no wrapping laying all over the place. Once when our other dog Bella had eaten six of those giant poppy seed muffins while I jogged back into Winco to get one more item, the inside of the car had been mayhem with stuff all over the place and cellophane stuck to the windows.With Coyote ruled out and Bella still back at home I realized I had left the pizzas on the top of the car!Doh! Someone had abscumed (sounds better than absconded) with them. I figured some homeless person. That was ok in a way, at least they would get a good meal. I also figured it could have been anyone. Anyone about to climb into their car noticing two lonely pizzas just crying for a home. I can imagine the thoughts going through someone’s head, “Well, I don’t usually steal but I was also taught to not look a gift horse in the mouth.”I went back to Murphy’s Pizza and ordered two more pizzas, them asking “back so soon”? We had a good laugh when I told them what a lame thing I had done.Well I have to give a shout out to Papa Murphys in Henderson Center. They made up the order again and wouldn’t let me pay for them. Dang...Thanks Papa Murphy’s!“

“Stopped in for lunch this past weekend and not knowing what the establishment was like, I was a bit surprised by the inside. I don't know what I expected, maybe a fancy restaurant vibe? Lol but it's a very comfortable restaurant/bar environment. The wait staff was super personable- we even spoke to one of the owners who was very detailed on the pizzas he had put together, how he came up with them, his wife's desserts, etc. I was pleasantly surprised all around at how welcoming it was. When it comes to the food we had the namesake Pizza, a Madrone. It wasn't the traditional style pizza but a true thin crust, wood fired, fresh ingredient pizza and it was amazing. We also had some draft root beers that had some great flavor and not to mentions some Chocolate Peppermint Cheesecake which was simply delightful. And I was surprised that for two of us, splitting a pizza, dessert and two root beers was so reasonably priced! There's more on the menu and we will be back again to try the rest. Stop in and give the pizza a whirl, and try the beers on tap too! There's plenty of unique drafts!“