6 Best Pizza Restaurants near Arcata

Dutchy's Pizza Pizza • $
1116 11th St, Arcata

Customers` Favorites

Hawaiian Pizza
The Hot Goat
Italian

“Pizza here is perfectly old-fashioned and satisfying. The sauce is incredible and the slices of pepperoni are the affordable, delicious greasiness you dream about! However if you are in the mood for vegetarian fare they have plenty of options like the Hot Goat, and even offer vegan cheese right on the main menu. There's an old school Pac Man video game and a couple of picnic tables outside. The indoor seating can get a little loud but I know some people are into it so they can watch sports or bring their family. Definitely recommend!“

4.4 Superb57 Reviews
Smug's Pizza Pizza • $
1034 G St, Arcata

Customers` Favorites

One Topping Pizza
Two Topping Pizza
Carnivore Pizza
Black Olives
Pizza Slice
Any

“My wife really enjoys pizza from Smug's and says it is the best. I am usually not a big pizza fan so I feel it's pretty much the same as any other pizza. It's a takeout place so don't plan on eating in. The service is very quick and friendly though. We usually get the herbivore pizza.“

4.4 Superb20 Reviews
Pauls Live From New York Pizza Arcata Pizza • $
665 Samoa Blvd, Arcata

Customers` Favorites

Paul's Sicilian Crust Cheese Pizza
Hawaiian Pizza with Jalape
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Godfather Pizza Slice
Pepperoni Pizza
The BBQ Pizza
The Godfather
Garlic Knots
Pesto Pizza

“Great food, gluten and dairy free options but fat kid at heart or not this is great pizza! 5 stars in the atmosphere because every TV was on sports and that's cool and all but at least put 1 on something else. But honestly that's really digging for something to complain about because this place is fantastic! For those not allergic to gluten you must try the Sicilian style(deep dish) was a personal favorite before lifestyle change“

4 Good56 Reviews
Westside Pizza Pizza • $
600 F St, Arcata

Customers` Favorites

Chocolate Chip Cookie
Chocolate Brownie
Westside Pizza
Chicken Wings
Sauce

“We stopped in for an easy dinner since it was late at night. The whole team was so friendly but Tracy was the person that took our order. Tracy was so nice and recommended the caesar salad WITH chicken. The salad did not disappoint. It seems really fresh and made to order. The pizza we had was equally delicious. Great food, great staff, awesome place!“

4.1 Good26 Reviews
Arcata Pizza & Deli Pizza • $
1057 H St, Arcata

Customers` Favorites

Pesto Turkey Sandwich
Cheesy Garlic Fries
French Dip Sandwich
Spicy Chicken Club
Black Bean Burger
Small French Fries
Slice of the Day
Veggie Sandwich
Old Bay Fries
Pepperoni Pie

“Lots of food options, and tasty pizza! Friendly staff, but food took a little while, and you have to walk up to the counter to get it after seating. Also, it's a small place and the line to order is real close to the tables, but I'd go again.?Vegetarian options: Black bean burgers?“

3.8 Good63 Reviews
Don's Donuts Pizza & Deli Donut Shops • $
933 H St, Arcata

Customers` Favorites

Milk Shakes and Apple Fritter
Old Fashion Cake
Waffle Cone
Croissants
Doughnut
Egg Roll
Donuts
Bagel
Rolls

“Careful with that "spicy chicken masterpiece" pizza. Listen, I enjoy eating spicy and leveling up and eating spicier peppers. But this pizza was THE hottest thing I've eaten in many years, if not of all time. There was so much pain (going in AND out). I think they gave me extra chili sauce. That can't be normal.That said, it was fudging delicious. I'd definitely settle for the regular chicken masterpiece next time, and add my own normal hot sauce. This was an experience to remember!!“

3.7 Good65 Reviews
Loading...
map Map