11 Best Pizza Restaurants in Eureka

“Hands down the best pizza in the county. The owners and staff are wonderful. Not only the best pizza but try there sandwiches. The meatball sandwich is my favorite and there pesto raviolis my favorite pasta. They also support/sponsor local sports and our community. Thanks, Babes D.Wheeler“

“This is a fantastic spot for locally made pizza in Eureka! The pizza here is truly exceptional, offering fresh ingredients and delicious flavors that stand out. Whether you're a local or just passing through, this place is a must-visit for anyone who loves great pizza. Highly recommend stopping by for a tasty and satisfying meal!“

“Excellent food and the service was great! The crème brûlée was amazing with the orange and chili in it..“

“Great service, the staff does get busy with online orders which then makes dine in staff wait to place their orders.

Parking: There are spots, but it is a shared parking lot.

Wheelchair accessibility: There are 2 spots in front of the restaurant.“

“So glad we tried this local pizza place while visiting Eureka. We accidentally picked up the wrong order but they were super cool about it and let us just keep the other pizzas without having to go back. Although we didn’t get what we ordered, let me tell you, this pizza is SO GOOD. The dough was amazing, quality cheese and toppings, and HUGE 16” pies! I wish I could take this place back home with me.“

“We took a field trip here for lunch. The service was excellent. The gal that took our order was so polite and patient. We ordered the pizza buffet. She took our buffet orders and served us drink. The upside it that The drinks come with the buffet. I have been places where you have to get a drink separate. So that's a plus!The pizza that was already out still looked fresh and delicious. It also tasted fresh and delicious. Great salad options, and the dressing is already in a small container for you. So you don't have to worry about making a mess with the pouring spoons.We also ordered traditional buffalo wings. The Buffalo wings were a very good size. Not tiny at all, with plenty of sauce. We also ordered some boneless wings for the little guys. They loved them!Five Star food, and five star service! We will have our next field trip lunch here again.“

“Two PizzasI bought two family size pizzas at Murphy’s Pizza in Henderson Center after walking our dog Coyote on the beach. On the way home I had one more stop to make at Winco. This became a dilemma since I would have to leave the pizzas alone with Coyote who was already scoping them out as belonging to her. Usually I save getting the pizza until last when running errands just to avoid this kind of situation.I had gotten two bags of cement on our route home so I figured I could cover the pizzas with a ground cloth and then lay one of the bags over the whole thing. Yeah, I figured they would be more squished but what could I do? I took the pizzas out of the back and stuck them on the roof while I arranged the spot to put them. They looked pretty good up there, far from Coyote, but it was way too tempting a place to leave them even for a minute.As I left I didn’t take a backward glance as I usually do to make sure Coyote and the car are good.On my way out from Winco, walking toward the car, I thought perhaps Coyote had nibbled on any bit of pizza that wasn’t directly under the cement bag but she wouldn’t get much at least. I felt good about the whole thing.I gave Coyote some hugs and then started loading stuff out of the cart and into the car. Something wasn’t right though….where were the dang pizzas? I ruled out Coyote pretty quick since there was no wrapping laying all over the place. Once when our other dog Bella had eaten six of those giant poppy seed muffins while I jogged back into Winco to get one more item, the inside of the car had been mayhem with stuff all over the place and cellophane stuck to the windows.With Coyote ruled out and Bella still back at home I realized I had left the pizzas on the top of the car!Doh! Someone had abscumed (sounds better than absconded) with them. I figured some homeless person. That was ok in a way, at least they would get a good meal. I also figured it could have been anyone. Anyone about to climb into their car noticing two lonely pizzas just crying for a home. I can imagine the thoughts going through someone’s head, “Well, I don’t usually steal but I was also taught to not look a gift horse in the mouth.”I went back to Murphy’s Pizza and ordered two more pizzas, them asking “back so soon”? We had a good laugh when I told them what a lame thing I had done.Well I have to give a shout out to Papa Murphys in Henderson Center. They made up the order again and wouldn’t let me pay for them. Dang...Thanks Papa Murphy’s!“

“Always great service, our go-to for pizza and all haven't gotten a wrong order yet

Dietary restrictions: Easy to make your own, one of ours can't have cheese and he hasn't had any issues with the pizza made

Parking: Small parking lot but it's never really busy enough to worry - even if the lot filled up, there's still street parking.“

“fast service...easy to read menu... 6 dollars a pizza ...“

“First off, the food is incredible. It's our favorite date night spot, ESPECIALLY for the pepperoni pizza paired with the Shannon ridge wine.
The ambience and the atmosphere is perfect.It's cozy, intimate, but open and lively.
Plus the service is always top tier.
And our favorite waiter Connor is so handsome and charming, we sometimes go there just to hangout with him.
Best restaurant in Humboldt. We need more places like this in town!“

“Literally home of the best barbecue Hawaiian pizza I've ever had my entire life I get one every day and will continue to do so as long as their quality of food remains the same.As far as service goes there's only one person who works inside there that has really bad customer service he's a heavy set, native American kid instead of him being rude he just seems like he needs a little guidance“