4 Best Italian Restaurants in Eureka

Customers` Favorites

House Made Italian Sausage Pizza
Grilled Calamari Appetizer
Wild Mushroom Cobbler
Peach Caprese Salad
Polenta Lasagna
Creme Brulee
Macaroni
Roasted

“Tonight's dinner was my first meal here, I have to say the service, the food and the atmosphere are all what I was looking for on a slightly rainy evening. The dimly lit restaurant struck a good balance between comfort and sophistication, and the brick pizza oven gave the room an slight amber glow.The wait staff were all professional and welcoming — like I was a local — unafraid to spark a quick and friendly conversation.I read a lot about the mushroom cobbler, and when it came out, I had to instantly snap this photo. The presentation and the taste was so perfect. Crusty and savory on the outside and soft and creamy on the inside.If they ask you if you want the olives and tomatoes on your Italian mac and cheese, please consider saying YES. It did not disappoint.Brick and Fire was not hard to locate. With easy to find street parking, I was able to pop in about an hour and a half before they closed.”

Options

take-out
delivery
4.6Superb450 Reviews

Customers` Favorites

Polenta Special
Chocolate Cake

“We had food from Brick and Fire, and seated here as both restaurants are an extension of each other. (For food experience please check my review on the Brick and Fire page)The ambiance was really nice it was super quiet and relaxing. The service was amazing and our waitress was nice, welcoming, and friendly.No wine experience but we enjoyed our time here.”

Options

take-out
4.3Superb72 Reviews

Customers` Favorites

Sweet Potato Fries
Fresh Baked Bread
Polenta Fries

“My sister and I went here while spending time in Eureka. From the moment we walked in to the minute we left, we were treated so well. We were provided suggestions on wine, along with a tasting to decide. My sister had the jasmine old fashioned which was soooo smooth going down. I had the Vermintino white wine - delicious. We each had a Marche salad to start - wonderful. For dinner we had the chicken mushroom linguini and gnocchi Mediterranean - both were fresh and delicious. We shared the tiramisu and creme brûlée for dessert - they were fine though not our highlight. We would definitely go back if we ever were in Eureka.”

Options

take-out
delivery
4Good166 Reviews

Customers` Favorites

Pepperoni and Bacon Pizza
Cheeseburger Pizza
Salad Bar

“Amazing food! We had the calzone and ravioli and both were great. Fantastic salad bar. We stopped by on a road trip and so glad we did! The staff was extremely friendly and helpful on menu selections and local attractions. Highly recommend!”

Options

curbside pickup
delivery
take-out
4Good268 Reviews
Loading...

Eureka’s Other Flavors

View on map