7 Best Italian Restaurants near Eureka

Brick & Fire Bistro Mediterranean • $$
1630 F St, Eureka

Customers` Favorites

House Made Italian Sausage Pizza
Grilled Calamari Appetizer
Wild Local Mushroom Pizza
Housemade Bread Pudding
Wild Mushroom Cobbler
Peach Caprese Salad
Margherita Pizza
Polenta Lasagna
Macaroni&Cheese
Creme Brulee

“Good was great. Little priceyVegetarian options: They did have a bit of vegetarian options available.Dietary restrictions: They hade gluten free and vegetarian options and I bet would amend any order to someone's needs.Parking: It's kinda hit and miss, its street side“

4.6 Superb129 Reviews
Gabriel’s Italian Restaurant Italian • $$
216 E St, Eureka

Customers` Favorites

White Chocolate Creme Brulee
Spaghetti and Meatballs
Gnocchi Mediterranean
Sweet Potato Fries
Fresh Baked Bread
Mushroom Tower
New York Steak
Polenta Fries

“We had such an extraordinary dinner last night. Gabriel’s has never disappointed but last night with the power out downtown we had the pleasure of dining with a full house by candlelight. Our waiter went above and beyond bringing out course after course hot and seasoned perfectly even though I can’t imagine how the kitchen could pull that off with the lights out! Perfect N.Y. strip, fresh pasta al mare & chicken parm were all excellent . The live music was superb with the local guitar vocalist who entertained us all joyfully. What a special night and one we will remember well. Thank you!!!“

4.6 Superb59 Reviews
Babe's Pizza & Pasta Pizza • $$
4015 Walnut Dr, Eureka

Customers` Favorites

Roasted Chicken & Garlic Pizza
Pepperoni and Bacon Pizza
Single Spaghetti Plate
Cheeseburger Pizza
Deluxe Pizza
Garlic Bread
Cheesecake
Taco Pizza
Salad Bar
Meatballs

“The third time I’ve used the babes app and payed for an extra topping and they forget to actually put it on. Their pizza is good and customer service great, they’ll refund the cost of the extra topping if you call them and tell them it was forgotten. It’s just weird that it occurs every time. I even ordered no bbq sauce on my pizza and they got that correct, but they forgot to add the extra blt topping that I paid for.“

4.4 Superb90 Reviews
2 Doors Down Wine Bar Gastropubs • $$
1626 F St, Eureka

Customers` Favorites

Polenta Special
Chocolate Cake

“We had food from Brick and Fire, and seated here as both restaurants are an extension of each other. (For food experience please check my review on the Brick and Fire page)The ambiance was really nice it was super quiet and relaxing. The service was amazing and our waitress was nice, welcoming, and friendly.No wine experience but we enjoyed our time here.“

4.3 Superb71 Reviews
Paul’s live from ny pizza eureka ca Pizza • $
604 F St, Eureka

Customers` Favorites

Pepperoni Pizza with Fresh Tomato Slices and Extra Cheese
The Empire State Building Gluten Free Pizza
Pizza Slice with Salad
The Chicken Club Pizza
Meat Lovers Pizza
NY Style Pizza
The BBQ Pizza
The Godfather
Garlic Knots
New Amsterdam

“Best pizza on the west coast.Five years after this review, I'm eating at Live From New York in Eureka. Wishing I could meet Paul. This is seriously the best pizza I have ever had on the West Coast, or the Mountain West, or the Mid West, and as a guy from Jersey I can't say it's the best I have ever had, but low key it's amazing. Access to this quality of pizza is one of the reasons I ended up staying in this area.Honestly the whole menu is legit NY/NJ pizza shop. Eggplant Parm, cannoli, antipasti. It's so good.Paul's Live From New York, my love for you grows by the day.“

4.1 Good80 Reviews
Bayfront Restaurant Japanese • $$
1 F St, Eureka

Customers` Favorites

Tempura Vegetables
Teppanyaki Dinner
California Roll
Salmon Sashimi
Chicken Katsu
Fusion Roll
Lobster Roll
Volcano Roll
Golden Miso
Miso Soup

“The food is consistent and I love that, it's located right on the Bay which makes for great atmosphere.Their chicken katsu, with salad is a favorite. The service is good, the food is quick and good.We have done the teppanaki side years ago for Birthday party and it was alot of fun too. Food was great, fun interaction.“

3.6 Good77 Reviews
Mazzotti's - Italian Restaurant Italian • $$
773 8th St, Arcata - 6.08 miles

Customers` Favorites

Spaghetti Carbonara
Chicken Parmigiana
Fettucinne Alfredo
Chicken Marsala
Caesar Salad
Crab Cakes
Manicotti
Tiramisu
Calamari
Ravioli

“The pesto genovese is great. Great parmesan flavor, good basil flavor, very good. The steak tasted amazing, but the mashed potatoes were very runny and the cheese was too much, and very offputting. I would lighten it up. Pizzas are very crunchy and authentic toppings. Really nice and creamy mozzarella, great flavor. And I love the Siciliano, it was great.“

3.5 Good94 Reviews
Loading...

Eureka’s Other Flavors

map Map