facebook instagram facebook instagram

Paul’s live from ny pizza eureka ca

$ • Pizza, Italian

604 F St, Eureka
(707) 442-5800

Take-Out/Delivery Options

Customers' Favorites

Recent Reviews

3.8 - 281 reviews

Excellent Pizza, Excellent Beer, Friendly Staff.I will however not comment on the interior because the social media person bullied me before for the use of words to describe it, sadly not everyone has perfect eloquence to do so.

Best pizza on the west coast.Five years after this review, I'm eating at Live From New York in Eureka. Wishing I could meet Paul. This is seriously the best pizza I have ever had on the West Coast, or the Mountain West, or the Mid West, and as a guy from Jersey I can't say it's the best I have ever had, but low key it's amazing. Access to this quality of pizza is one of the reasons I ended up staying in this area.Honestly the whole menu is legit NY/NJ pizza shop. Eggplant Parm,...read full review

I haven’t been here for a while with Covid and their closure, but I was very happy to see they back up and running!I live in CO and travel here a few times a year. Paul’s is the BEST!! I’ve never had a bad pie here.It’s the closest thing to NY’s finest, I’d not even better!!!I’d give it 10*’s…

More Reviews(281)


View all photos


Monday 11:30AM - 8PM
Tuesday 11:30AM - 8PM
Wednesday 11:30AM - 8PM
Thursday 11:30AM - 8PM
Friday 11:30AM - 9PM
Saturday 11:30AM - 9PM
Sunday 12 - 8PM
Updated on: