Paul's Live From New York Pizza

$ • Pizza, Italian

604 F St, Eureka
(707) 442-5800


Take-Out/Delivery Options


Recent Reviews

Not going to lie one bit they have ruined a pizza for me and my family with how good the options were. I bought food for five people total of about what I think I bought seven slices for less than 50 bucks and they were all very good. I cannot compete with that anywhere near where I'm at so I feel really bad now.Kid-friendliness: My 4-year-old daughter was goofing around and they kind of let her be her nobody yelled to her for you know not doing anything that we would do full review

Exceptional pizza, the sauce was especially good. Nice wide open seating and friendly staff. It's street parking, but when we went for dinner there wasn't an issue finding a space.

Honestly the best pizza I've had in town BUT the lady working the register was the worst experience I've ever had with restaurant staff. We had to say our order five times but she kept interrupting and trying to do a whole standup comedy routine. She was not funny and was terrible at her job to the point where we are only going to the Arcata location from now on so we never have to interact with her again.

More Reviews(148)


Monday 11:30AM - 9PM
Tuesday 11:30AM - 9PM
Wednesday 11:30AM - 9PM
Thursday 11:30AM - 9PM
Friday 11:30AM - 10PM
Saturday 11:30AM - 10PM
Sunday Closed