Rotten City Pizza

$$ • Pizza

6613 Hollis St, Emeryville
(510) 655-2489


Take-Out/Delivery Options


Reviews for Rotten City Pizza

Not bad, but location is off the beaten path and it’s way overpriced. It’s still on the better end of NY style you find in the Bay but Arinel’s is the only competent Bay Area purveyor with a decent price point.Solid, but hard pass on the price. Definitely didn’t blow my mind either.

I grew up in NYC and this is the closest thing I've had to a real thin crust pie in a while. It's definitely still missing something but I don't think it's the pizzas fault. Probably the air or something. The west coast doesn't have the saliva of angry yelling Yorkers everywhere. Maybe this is what pizza is suppose to taste like.But anyways, great work for brining me home. They have good booze too. Looks like they sell mostly from local breweries. Good stuff

Pizza is still great. However the “1/4 pie aka fat slice” is really no bigger than the original slices. the original slice and the 1/4 pie can fit in the same size box I don’t see the size difference only the price difference. Wtbs I’ll probably just order the subs and salad. They are just as great as the pizza but more food for your money.

More Reviews(180)


Monday 12 - 8PM
Tuesday 12 - 8PM
Wednesday 12 - 8PM
Thursday 12 - 8PM
Friday 12 - 8PM
Saturday 12 - 8PM
Sunday 12 - 8PM

Hours or services may differ due to COVID-19. Please contact the business directly to verify hours and availability.