12 Best Pizza Restaurants in Gilroy

“High & Mighty Pizza join, not just any old joint, is a cowboy-and-cowgirl town with a modern twist. The atmosphere is welcoming, and the people are genuinely warm and friendly. I love being pampered, and this place knows how to make us feel special.

There is a pizza and salad and dessert for everyone. Our artisan pizza was loaded with pepperoni, sausage, and cheesy goodness, all complemented by a distinctive smoky barbecue flavor. The smokey after taste is their signature touch. I love it. The beautiful artisan crust reminded me of Italy, perfectly cooked in a wood-fired oven that must have a little magic in it, because every bite was delicious.

The first bite tingles and tantalizes the taste buds, then travels downstairs and hits a high note in my belly. Follow that with a sip of Besson wine and, OMG, pure heaven and the best kind of food coma!

We paired our beautiful pie with Besson Wines, making it the perfect date night with my gal.

We will definitely be back!“

“The staff are very friendly and helpful, and funny. The atmosphere is a little pizza shop Monterey inspired very nicely put together and good visuals on the walls and very cozy.
And the food is just perfect and you can just buy slices no need for a full pizza if you want.“

“such amazing food i really enjoy my evening when I come here for a meal“

“Leider war unser Besuch alles andere als angenehm. Wir hatten einen Platz im Schatten reserviert. Kamen an und bekamen erst mal eine Platz direkt in der Sonne zugeteilt. Wir dachten uns, naja, hilft ja nichts. Dann ging das Warten los. Wir saßen 25 Minuten in der prallen Sonne, ohne auch nur beachtet zu werden. Nach uns kommende Gäste wieder bedient, wir hatten weder Schatten noch Getränke. Irgendwann wurde ein Schattenplatz frei. Den schnappten wir uns dann. Und nach insgesamt 35 Minuten konnten wir auch endlich unsere Getränke bestellen (kurzzeitig waren wir schon am Überlegen lieber zum goldenen M zu fahren) Wir bestellten als zeitgleich Getränke und essen. Essen kam dann auch. Nur leider hatten wir kein Bedteck. Also wieder warten. Nach dem wir leicht angsäuert waren, genossen wir aber das leckere Essen. Die restlichen Pizza gaben wir der Bedienung zum einpacken. Wir bezahlten und warteten wieder - auf die eingepackte Pizza. Irgendwann ging mein Mann nach oben zur Theke, wo die Bedienung stand und Besteck abtrocknen. Auf unsere Frage wo denn die Pizza sei, "oh die hab ich ganz vergessen, da drüben steht sie" Naja ist halt alles andre als gut gelaufen an diesem Tag. Aber das Essen war wirklich lecker.“

“Came here for the lunch buffet with my son after hearing him rave about this place for quite some time, and it did not disappoint. Dennis was incredibly kind and thoughtful — I asked if there was any way to make a veggie-based pizza, and he happily made one fresh for me during the all-you-can-eat buffet. That level of kindness and customer service really stood out to me.
The atmosphere was welcoming, the food was great, and it made for such a nice lunch with my son. We’ll definitely be back. Thank you again, Dennis, for being so accommodating and kind!“

“This is my aunts favorite pizza place. I love that I can order her one and have it delivered with a personalized message. Living in Florida it can be hard to surprise her, and this works every time. Ya'll are a Gilroy staple, I remember having Straw Hat pizza as a kid and loving it. Keep up the great work. I look forward to ordering again. I F.L.Y. StrawHat Pizza Gilroy“

“Todas las pizzas 🍕 están muy buenas arina del día resiente echa“

“Great pizza.“

“our 2 grandsons Loved it there! The young lady working there was very kind and helpful. Game area was clean n bathroom was were also“

“MMMMMMM. MUY BUENA PIZZA �“

“RIKISIMAS YO COMO ESTÁ PIZZA DESDE TAMAULIPAS MUY BUENAS“