11 Best Pizza Restaurants in Watsonville

“my first time here, so so delicious 😋“

“Love that we can grab pizza and snacks all in one place, delicious!“

“Innovative gourmet options. The ricotta was fresh, airy, like a cloud warmed by the rich hot pizza dough, topped with arugula and edible flowers. Apple fennel arugula salad. Delightful service and energy. A must go.“

“Growing up in Watsonville, Pizza Mia was the quintessential spot for a quick, satisfying slice, a concept that feels rare these days. Returning after more than a decade, I was eager to see if it lived up to my memories, and it absolutely did.

The pizza remains consistently good, the crust is thin but not too thin, with a soft, fluffy interior and a satisfying crisp. The sauce is the real standout, it's light, slightly sweet, and perfectly balanced, complementing every bite. It is simple, unpretentious, and exactly what you hope for from a neighborhood pizzeria.

Service is fast, and the pricing is fair. I had three slices of pepperoni pizza and three water bottles for $13.81. What struck me most is how Pizza Mia manages to deliver both nostalgia and quality, proving that some local favorites are timeless. The only downside is that I noticed the seating area is now closed, which is a bummer as that was a place to sit, eat, and enjoy your pizza and maybe play an arcade game.

For anyone in Watsonville craving a classic slice done right, this is a must visit!“

“Sooo disappointed! Highly recommended! We purchased to go an extra large combination When we got home and opened the box: Totally dry and overcooked I would have liked to send them a message - rather than - Facebook. Not an option. Lynne“

“I come get a slice here often. It’s unfortunate that the price has gone up so much in recent years but I guess that’s true of most places. When slices were $1.50 it was a great deal. Now it’s just about average. The pizza isn’t the best, but it’s consistent and it will satisfy that craving you have for a slice. I like that you can get just a slice or two if you want. The dining area is usually quiet, with plenty of seating for just yourself or you and a couple friends. They have some games for the kids. I like that you get the sweet smell of the breads being baked at the panaderia next door. Parking is usually no problem. The staff is friendly.“

“We order many pizza's every year for our daughter's birthday parties we have at the park down the street. This place is amazing and the service is always awesome! I also enjoy supporting a local business!“

“I don’t like there service.“

“It was delivered and I was just a touch disappointed.

I love Mountain Mike's and their toppings here were a bit dry.

I think next time I need to ask for a bit more sauce and toppings.

Just disappointed.“

“I greatly appreciate the staff's courtesy in making a call when I inadvertently ordered two items, as it is indeed one order. They were kind enough to clarify this matter with me, and my experience feels like if any other place would have done so, they would not bother... on top of it all, I have had such a good experience there“

“Been eating here all my life and it's the only location I trust. The others I've tried in places like Hayward, Sacramento, etc. all let me down with burnt or cold pizzas at some point or another.

That said, its popularity also makes it really busy much of the time, and staff can be a bit all over the place trying to accommodate orders coming in from DoorDash, online, phone, and the counter. Be patient with them. It's worth it.“