6 Best Pizza Restaurants near Capitola

Village Host Pizza & Grill Pizza • $$
819 Bay Ave, Capitola

Customers` Favorites

Build Your Own Baked Sandwich
The Village Combination Pizza
Two Topping Personal Pizza
SM Build Your Own Pizza
Pesto Chicken Sandwich
MD Pesto Chicken Pizza
P Pesto Chicken Pizza
Chicken Pesto Sandwich
The Triple P Pizza
Fresh Salad Bar

“Always fast service and never any mistakes with my orders. I honestly don’t understand why there CANT be an up charge for an additional item for the Pizza Sandwich. I’ve had mushrooms added previously but when they’re busy, it’s not okay. I always tip 18-20% and even more yesterday when I somehow accidentally added an extra item to a personal pizza and was refunded.When you only get a measly 6 jalapeños as your second item, are a few mushrooms gonna be a huge deal? Wouldn’t customer satisfaction be worth $.75? I’m lost on why you can add tons to a pizza and get charged for that but not on a sandwich. ?‍♀️“

4.7 Superb50 Reviews
Caruso's Tuscan Cuisine Italian • $$
115 San Jose Ave, Capitola

Customers` Favorites

Special Request Spaghetti with Clam in White Wine
Dischetti Ai Tartufo
Spaghetti Carbonara
Spaghetti Bolognese
Spaghetti Marinara
Seafood Fettuccine
Gnocchi Bolognese
Spaghetti Pollo
Insalata Mista
Bufala Caprese

“This place is wonderful! We both enjoyed the friendly hostess and server. Our appetizer and both entrees were perfect! One was ordered "spicy" and turned out to be the perfect amount of spiciness. This was a special night and we were grateful for the sweet, quiet ambiance.“

4.5 Superb86 Reviews
Pizza My Heart Pizza • $
2180 41st Ave, Capitola

Customers` Favorites

Large Mushroom Pepperoni Pizza
Old-School Pepperoni Pizza
Big Sur Slice of Pizza
Assorted Pizza Slices
Pizza by the Slice
Award Winning Pizza
Cheese Pizza Slice
Watsonville Slice
Maui Wowie Slice
Pizza and Salad

“This place is wonderful. The staff went above and beyond the expectation and delivered excellent quality customer service with a smile. It is located around a weirdly named street but that makes is even more charming and funky classic to the theme of Pizza My Heart. The place is well kept,Clean and holds a lot of local gem history on the walls.Dietary restrictions: The staff is mindful of people with food allergies and will custom make a pizza for you even if it is just one pieceParking: Limited so may need to carpool if you have a large group after sportsKid-friendliness: Very kid friendly astmosphere. It is kitty corner to the freeway entrance so it is funky with the location but the fountain drinks have good selection and it is clean. Close to local surf sport beaches.Wheelchair accessibility: Place is friendly to able folks in a wheelchair“

4.4 Superb149 Reviews
La Marea Cafe & Pizzeria Salad • $
311 Capitola Ave, Capitola

Customers` Favorites

Bagel and Cream Cheese
Gluten Free Pizza
Slice

“Finally some good food and coffee in the village! So stoked to have this place to walk to. The bagels, pizza, and drinks are all so good. Im obsessed. Some of my favorites: - The pistachio scone is always a must get - Riviera bagel is SO good - Carla latte - Blackberry matcha - Pizza You honestly can't go wrong here! LOVE!“

4.8 Superb18 Reviews
Pizza My Heart Pizza • $
209 Esplanade, Capitola

Customers` Favorites

Big Sur Slice of Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza Slice
The Classic Pizza
Seasonal Salad
Side of Ranch
Fountain Soda
Big Sur Pizza
Pesto Pizza
Pesto Slice
Little Sur

“Quickly made my online order of bbq chicken before the due time. The staff were attentive and considerate, even made relevant small talk which getting me checked out. The place was clean and orderly, felt a bright and crisp vibe throughout the experience.“

4.4 Superb63 Reviews
Cork and Fork Capitola Wine Bar • $$
312 Capitola Ave, Capitola

“Nice location, comfortable fun setting with fun live music. The owner is oddly rude, I ordered a wine flight, she seemed annoyed we were there but served us. I just thought maybe it was busy so didn't think much of it. She brought out our drinks and my flight good but wouldn't tell us what was in each glass. At first I thought maybe the rudeness was a joke, but no just didn't want to tell us what I was drinking. I was hoping to order a glass of one of the ones I liked but the owner was so rude we decided to just leave and move on. Very odd and disappointing. Maybe it was just a bad day.Update: thanks for the reply. We didn't realize how the blind flight worked and it was busy near closing so I guess we didn't pursue it too much. We will have to come try again, I did love the ambience and the flight was good. Maybe update the menu to explain how the blind flight works.“

4 Good22 Reviews