43 Best Pizza Restaurants near Newbury Park

“We’ve been loyal customers of Tony’s Pizza for years and genuinely love your food — which is why I wanted to share some honest feedback about our order tonight. This is the first time we’ve ever had an experience like this, so I’m hoping it was simply an off night or a very busy evening.

Unfortunately, every item in our order had an issue. The 6” meatball sub only had three meatballs inside, and the cannoli we ordered for dessert was burned. The cheese ravioli itself was fine, but the garlic bread that came with it was also badly burned. The biggest disappointment was the “Tony’s Sub.” It was completely drenched in oil — so much that it was dripping onto the floor when my son unwrapped it. The vegetables inside were cut into very large chunks that kept falling out of both ends, making it extremely messy and difficult to eat. He ultimately gave up and had to throw it away.

We’re sharing this because we truly enjoy Tony’s Pizza and order often. The quality is usually excellent, which is why tonight’s experience surprised us. We wanted to bring it to your attention in case something went wrong in the kitchen, and we hope to see things back to the great standard we’re used to next time.We’ve been loyal customers of Tony’s Pizza for years and genuinely love your food — which is why I wanted to share some honest feedback about our order tonight. This is the first time we’ve ever had an experience like this, so I’m hoping it was simply an off night or a very busy evening.

Unfortunately, every item in our order had an issue. The 6” meatball sub only had three meatballs inside, and the cannoli we ordered for dessert was burned. The cheese ravioli itself was fine, but the garlic bread that came with it was also badly burned. The biggest disappointment was the “Tony’s Sub.” It was completely drenched in oil — so much that it was dripping onto the floor when my son unwrapped it. The vegetables inside were cut into very large chunks that kept falling out of both ends, making it extremely messy and difficult to eat. He ultimately gave up and had to throw it away.

We’re sharing this because we truly enjoy Tony’s Pizza and order often. The quality is usually excellent, which is why tonight’s experience surprised us. We wanted to bring it to your attention in case something went wrong in the kitchen, and we hope to see things back to the great standard we’re used to next time.“

“I love this pizza and the people who work here. I dont alway order pizza, but if I'm on a budget or need something quick I can order with an app, I go to one of the chain pizza places in town. But when I want some really good pizza with fresh toppings, great combinations, and grid sides, I order Ameci online. Stay well my friends.“

“There pizza and wings are amazing 🤩“

“Good 🍗 bbq. Love the tri tip“

“Every time I've ordered there (Probably A Little Too Much) the pizza is perfectly cooked and warm, the soda is always cold and refreshing, and the sides always are good (especially parmasean bites). 10/10 Papa Johns is garbage compared to this“

“A++++ FOOD AND STAFF ARE GREAT!!!! -ROANESYMON“

“OMG! Finally found real NY Pizza in California! Love you guys!“

“Great vibe fantastic pizza and the best antipasto salad 😁 keto lovers they offer cauliflower crust we are trying next“

“Absolutely delicious pizza! Different styles of pizza are available. I look forward to trying them all. Nice restaurant. Casual and comfortable.“

“I'm truly grateful to have finally found something that worked. For years, I believed like everyone else that herpes had no real cure. After trying so many things with no results, I came across "Dr MOMOH" and everything changed. It's a relief to feel normal again after all this time.😇😇😇“

“Love this place and the people!!! ❤️❤️❤️“

“Delicious food, amazing cocktails!“

“The pizza here is amazing! Reminds me of east coast New Jersey pizza. We ordered the Brooklyn and the Hawaiian pizza.
Both were incredible. We also ordered the falafel, which was crispy on the outside and fluffy on the inside.

I wish we had pizza this good in Seattle…“

“quick hot and tasty was my slice! enjoyed i a lot thx Tony's“

“Breakfast at Tony’s is so good! We had eggs Benedict with the home fried potatoes and the eggs Florentine with hash browns. Both were delicious. The Benedict sauce was so good with a hint of sweet, maybe from the ham ? The potatoes were so good and done perfectly with onions and peppers. A perfect combination. Eggs Florentine with hash browns didn’t disappoint either. Both meals were yummy. I highly recommend Tony’s .“

“Marco’s Pizza is my go to whenever I’m looking for a tasty pizza that actually has quality ingredients on it. I hate ordering a pizza and it is all greasy or not enough toppings on it. Marco’s is the solution to that problem! Also if you haven’t tried their wings or Cheezybread, those are perfect for any game day party you’re going to have!“

“We’re new to the area & we love small businesses! I was able to walk in and order a pizza with a small 15 minute wait. Front desk was super friendly. I ordered a family meal that was advertised on their website in the coupons section and paid 37.99 for a large 1 topping pizza, spaghetti, garlic bread and a family size salad. It fed my family of 4 with leftovers. It’s conveniently located near CVS & Vons so while we waited for our pizza we walked to pick up a few things. Everything was bagged perfectly and made it warm by the time we got home. We will be regular customers!“

“Toppers Pizza is soooo good! From there super fresh toppings that ride the wave of cheesy delicious mozzarella all the way to the end of the pie. The bottom of the pizza maintains a beautiful crispness that hold all of the wonderful toppings up.

Pro Tip: Their homemade in-house ranch is some of the best I've ever had. Give your slice a little ranch bath...you're welcome!“

“Great pizza. I think it's better than Toppers (I know, heresy). Only down side seems like they were a bit understaffed so I waited about 45 min in the store to pick up my online takeout order after I arrived. The staff that was there was diligent despite being spread so thin. Quality of my food was not compromised! I recommend the thin crust Everest (combo).“

“I just wanted to thank the owner and staff for your generosity and patience yesterday on your busiest day of the year. On a whim I decided to stop by. My family was super happy when I got home. Our boys decided every Friday will be Valentino's. And I couldn't agree more. Thank you again.“

“great service good food & portions“

“If you follow What’s Gaby Cooking, you know how exciting it is to have Neighborly and Gaby’s right here in Westlake Village. Everything is fresh, flavorful, and beautifully prepared. The salads, bowls, and sandwiches are all incredible.

They recently added catering, and as a local realtor, I love having this local gem cater my broker open houses. The salads and sandwiches are always a huge hit.

Such a great addition to the Westlake Village food scene and one of my favorite local spots.“

“Prince St. Pizza goes crazy. The pepperoni is unreal, the crust hits, and the whole vibe is elite. Big shoutout to Eli too, dude’s service is on point, super chill, and keeps everything moving smooth. Absolute W. Miami frat boy approved 🍕😎“

“A special shout-out to Mike—his professionalism and warm attitude truly stand out. He goes above and beyond to make the place feel inviting and ensures you leave with a smile. Great food, great people, great vibe. Highly recommended! 🍕✨“

“I was starting to miss the flavors of home after weeks of eating American food. Luckily, my friend @Massimiliano Russomanno knew just the place to take me. Antonio Sessa's Made in Italy was a delightful surprise. Every bite transported me back to Italy. The food was prepared with such care and passion that it was clear this Italian Chef had a truly deep love for our cuisine. If you're craving authentic Italian food, I highly recommend giving this place a try 🥰🥰👍🏻🫶🙌🏻🙌🏻“

“I gave been away a long time. And miss you. My husband and two boys grew up eating there every week. The best pizza and the best salad I had every eeek and miss. You were family.to us. My husband passed away 20 years ago from cancer way to young.i now live in Arkansas near my grandchildren and son. My other son lives in Pa. Good to hear Ron you. Happy holidays to you!used to live in Woodland Hills then Arizona“

“The best Pizza in town! I highly recommend!“

“The Moorpark store never disappoints!
I order from them, at least twice a month.
Tonight was the first time that I actually really needed them, at 9:40 I woke up from a fever induced nap. I called and ordered a Pizza.
Something I would regularly not do so close to closing..
but they came through, they took my order.
They had my pizza ready in 20 minutes!

Big thank you to pizzaman dan and moorpark store!“

“So far the best authentic Italian pizza I have had in 10 years living in USA. And I am Italian so that says enough! Everything was perfect. High quality food. Forza ragazzi 🇮🇹🇮🇹🇮🇹“

“Absolutely amazing experience at Greco’s Pizza! The moment I walked in the door, Ricardo and his wife welcomed me with the warmest, most genuine hospitality. You can instantly tell this is a family-owned spot run by an authentic Italian family, and that makes all the difference. The place is super clean, well-kept, and gives off those classic neighborhood pizzeria vibes.

Now the pizza… WOW. Freshly made, full of flavor, and everything you'd hope for in authentic New York-style Italian pizza. You can’t go wrong here. The crust, the sauce, the cheese—it’s all on point. I left full, happy, and already thinking about my next visit.

Highly, highly recommend!“

“best pizza at the oaks mall“

“I really like this place and wish it could somehow get more visibility so that they stay in business! The pizza is always delicious, and the selection of beers on tap is great! There's outside seating as well, so that's a bonus! I feel like it's an awesome alternative to the busier places on the other side of Moorpark.“

“great food and service! will definately be back“

“After we responded to a 911 call at Humble boyz pizza, Austin personally came to our station with 5 boxes of pizza.

We absolutely appreciate the goodwill from Humble boys and will be customers for life.

We especially liked the margarita with balsamic and truffle glaze.“

“Very flavory pizza 🍕!!! You choose your favorite, regular, deep dish, etc. etc. They have a daily lunch special a salad 🥗 a personal pizza 🍕 and a drink 🥤!! That is a good deal! They also make the most delicious chocolate chip cookies 🍪 mmm really delicious 😋!“

“Great live music venue and great pizza!!“

“Oh my goodness I hope it’s not against the law to order pizza 🍕 every Saturday for the last three weekends!! Thank you So Much 😊“

“muy buen servicio solo nesesita más limpieza en los baños“

“Thanks for supporting our non profit and having affordable food for our family.“

“Great live music venue and great pizza!!“

“My go-to pizza place, their Individual pizza is soooo good! Great price, great quality and so delicious! My boyfriend really enjoys their Philly cheesesteak sandwiches. Their interior is pretty chill and they have a great arcade-like area in the back, with computers and a claw game. Additionally, their calzone is good, and adds variety to the menu as well. The foods is ready fast and never disappoints, 10/10 ?“

“The banner said under new ownership, but all the style, food and excellent service remained with the veteran crew. The food was delicious and the service was personable and outstanding. The homey small shop feel made it feel like family dinner instead of a restaurant. Will return again.“