12 Best Italian Restaurants in Pleasanton

“First time patrons loved everything about our experience food was delicious generous portions did not go home hungry great customer service and definitely will go again, we want to try everything on the menu Bravissimo Gracias por la Norte“

“Love their eggs Benedict and pork chops. Staff is always so nice. Great French fries!“

“Great food, nice staff and Chianti says it all! Oh they have pizza yet you should not hold the image of pizzeria / pizza parlor that leans to the slice o’pie on the east coast. This is nice dining!“

“We always enjoy the sitting outside people watching and getting excellent service and food. My wife inevitably gets one of the specials- and loves the seasonal change in the menus.“

“Great food and excellent service highly recommend!“

“The food was wonderful. Flavorful with beautiful plating.The restaurant was a simple but classy environment. Just the type of place I like to enjoy a meal.“

“Absolutely phenomenal service. Andrew was so knowledgeable and attentive. Our octopus, smoked tuna, ravioli Arogosta and short ribs were absolute perfection. I was so incredibly impressed once again- this is my new favorite place! HIGHLY recommend!“

“Have not been here since it was straw hat pizza. What an awesome change. Food and beer are very good. The service was impeccable thank you Ian and Collin for such a fun experience🍕“

“We ended up finding this place by chance because we’re waiting for a table at Bill’s Cafe. We decided to walk the plaza and I smelled the aroma of freshly made pizza. We had to GO in. As a New Yorker, I am seriously picky about my pizza. It needs to be thin, crispy with gooey cheese and a great sauce. This place checks off all of the boxes. The owner was super sweet and explained she got the ingredients from the East coast to make it truly delicious pizza. Don’t sleep on this gem!“

“Really good food and good ole stories from back in the old days.“

“First time visiting New York Pizza, and I have to say the staff is incredibly friendly! We ordered a slice of marinara and a veggie pizza for dinner, both of which were delicious. The seating is comfortable, making it a perfect spot to relax, hang out, and enjoy a bite.

It was a pleasure chatting with Johnny—such a great guy! We’ll definitely be back. Love supporting local businesses that really take the time to care for their customers. The vibes are great.

There is also plenty of parking nearby and downtown Pleasanton is very lively!“

“Thank you guys for the awesome pies. I am totally hooked!!!“