Bagelry

$ • Bagels, Salad

Menu Order Online

About Bagelry

The Bagelry is a beloved spot that has remained largely unchanged over the decades on the East Side. It offers affordable and convenient options, including a variety of delicious, fresh bagels and toppings. The menu features many white flour and whole grain choices, with vegan options like vegan cream cheese, hummus, and tofu-based spreads. Their day-old bagel deals are popular, and the house-made hummus is considered the best ever by many customers.

The basic setting and limited menu may initially discourage some visitors seeking more elaborate choices, but everything they sell has been enjoyed by countless happy customers. The downtown location is known for its friendly and cheerful staff, making it a way kid-friendly place. Be sure to try the salmon and crema cheese bagel, and don't miss the tasty soups made daily. While service can be inconsistent, the Bagelry stands alongside renowned bagel spots in NYC, Montreal, and beyond, making it a must-visit. Customers can also find their other locations in Soquel and downtown Santa Cruz.

Customers' Favorites

Lox Deluxe Bagel Sandwich

Bagel Cream Cheese Only

Turkey Sandwich

Pink Flamingo

Everything

Hummus

Pesto

+4 more Show less

Photos

Add a Photo

View All Photos

Bagelry Reviews

4.4

135 ratings

76%

Food

Atmosphere

Service

Share your opinion about Bagelry

Write a review

I've been going here since I was a kid (30+ years ago) and they never disappoint. Good prices, great fresh bagels and toppings. A local staple

July 2026

I enjoy coming here for many reasons. They have sprouts! Their bagle with Hummus, sprouts & tomato is delicious, they remember my order & name when I walk in (who doesn't enjoy feeling special), all the employees are just great. Customer service reigns supreme here. Add great food. Equals = happy customer....me.

January 2026

Super friendly staff, really good bagels and toppings.
And the guy in the beanie is my dream man 🥰

January 2026

Read All Reviews(135)