19 Best Pizza Restaurants in Santa Maria

“Papa Murphy's is awesome take and bake pizza. The staff are very helpful and cool to meet. Their food is excellent and that is coming from an Italian from a long line of central coast Italian restaurant owners. Thank you guys for offering some great traditional food from southern Italy with your own Papa Murphy's twist. I am also very happy that they accept EBT which is great for the community. Thanks again!“

“Fastquickcourteousandhelpfulservice great staff“

“Food is delicious! Everything I have tried is scrumptious! Love the soup and salad lunch deal! The homemade minestrone soup is so good! But my most favorite dish of all is the chicken piccata! The best I have ever had! I highly recommend it but it’s only served on the last Weekend of the month!“

“Great pizza, ready when promised! Very appetizing combination of ingredients, plenty of cheese,along with other toppings. We really like the large Deluxe, which feeds our family of four, plus a couple of slices leftover for a lunch. Delicious!“

“Writing

Google/Yelp Review
The food was good, and our pizza and breadsticks came out in a timely manner. The lemonade was out when we ordered, but once I let the staff know, it was promptly replaced, so I appreciated that.
Unfortunately, the experience took a turn for the worse when our server cleared our table while we were still there playing games. We still had a couple slices of pizza and some wings left, along with our drinks, and all of it was thrown away. When I went back to the table and told him we weren’t finished, he simply apologized. I understand that mistakes happen, but I feel like the situation could have been handled better.

At the very least, I would have appreciated an offer to replace the food that was thrown away—a small pizza, some wings, and new drinks. Unfortunately, that incident really affected our overall experience and left us disappointed. The food itself was good, but the way this situation was handled is what ultimately made the visit a negative experience for me.“

“You can relax and watch TV. You can have a beer or a glass of wine. The kids can spend all your quarters on the video games lol Their pizza is a little pricey but we’ll worth it. It is great quality food Their always always clean. Be aware that servers are serving your food. If you need something ask one of the girls and the will try and accommodate you. Enjoy!!!!“

“we love this Blaze, Tristan is awesome. he is super efficient and fast. He knows pizza. He is friendly. He seems to be able to do it all and more. what a rockstar! Danielle is a pro at the oven and super nice. She has a great attitude and really cares about what she does. There is a girl at the topping station that is Breaking world record topping speeds. These guys all need raises.“

“It certainly has come a long way of the days of having the creepy singing bears. Lots to entertain my two year old granddaughter. The “meal deals” really aren’t deals. You’re better off ordering everything separately. This pizza is surprisingly good. We will definitely take the two year old back there.“

“👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍 Great pizza and fantastic sandwiches!“

“I love their fried pickles“

“I love this restaurant and the owner is fabulous ❤️“

“One of my favorite pizzas on the central coast. Robust, full-bodied sauce, chewy dense crust with very little un-topping'd handle, smoky-umami cheese, and great topping choices. Definitely not for sit-in, but great for takeout or delivery. Always bogo by default, so plan for getting 2.“

“Live down the street, been wanting to check Fire and Vice out- today was the day.
Had a great experience. Justin helped with our food selection since it was our first time- I had a spicy Hawaiian pizza ( delicious) and the bf had a spicy Italian sausage with onion rings. Even the onion rings were just right- not over done and melted in your mouth.
If you haven’t been by yet- I recommend go see what you have been missing out on!
They have a beer and wine bar, outside dinning if you and friends and or family wanna hang out and enjoy drinks around a fire table - just tell Justin and he will get it going for you!
I plan on returning- especially to try the coffee menu.
Lastly- the prices are reasonable. We appreciate that. Thank you Justin and Fire and Vice. I will be seeing you again soon.“

“I was greated with the biggest smile and warmest welcome. The service was great and food fantastic!“

“Kazen is very attentive & kind. I enjoy the spicy hot wings & pizza very much. The restaurant ambiance is clean & cozy- great for family gatherings & kid friendly. 👍“

“Excellent service. The finest cusine. Very beautiful scenery with a lighting that compliments my look. The atmosphere here is almost like im at home with the Warm,ambient laughter,and friendly faces of the employees. The service is by far the best I have ever experienced on this planet and off this planet. None of this is an exaggeration. If you come her to me n ends pizza. You'll never go to lil c again.

You come for the pizza and stay for thr friends.“

“Being from NYC, the area itself was different. But the hospitality was excellent.“

“I currently live in Bakersfield California and my son is there (Santa Maria) for an all day track and field meet. He forgot his wallet here and called me, upset (but willing to wait to eat until he returned home). With three hours between us, I decided to call Dominos pizza because as a mom, you find any way to make sure your children are taken care of. RICHARD was amazing. He took my order and made sure my son had something to eat for the day. He personally delivered it and made sure to find my son, amongst all of the other students there on campus. He is God sent. His personality was uplifting and I am forever grateful for his kindness. Domino’s Pizza scored when they hired this young man. #Dominos #Forevergrateful #Richardisthebest“

“The pizza when lucky has a distinct tasting bite when it comes to the baked pizza dough.
It's semi dough-ie lingering taste fills the vacant pocket of air in the mouth, and it's satisfying.
It's really hot in the store next to longs drug store.“