10 Best Pizza Restaurants in Arroyo Grande

“Sept 2026 - This time when we got our pizza we chose to pick it up, we also ordered a garden salad, still fresh, the tomatoes and mushrooms were not. However, this time our pizza crust was burned and it was hard and chewy, we were disappointed. We still love the pizza and salad but we're disappointed with the quality this time.

I wrote this review I believe a year ago....Sept 2025
The pizza is always hot, always fresh. We also got the garden salad very fresh. For a medium combination pizza it was $30. The garden salad was around $11. A little pricey. Great atmosphere! Great service and staff and the restaurant was clean. Highly recommend if your in the area.“

“awesome as always thank you 👏 😎“

“We were just traveling through and stumbled upon this pizza place. We were pleasantly surprised with our vegetarian pizza. Great variety of veggies and super stringy cheese! Counter attendant was friendly and knowledgeable about the foods offered. Great place.“

“This was the first opportunity to eat at Gina's. The food ordered was delicious. The service provided was excellent. The waiter came to the table numerous times inquiring if we are enjoying our meal and if we needed any additional items. A definite place to return to. The location is within downtown Arroyo Grande with other businesses within walking distance. There is public parking in the rear of Gina's. Enjoy the bridges and the wandering roosters in the parking area.“

“awesome as always thank you 👏 😎“

“Great pizza and salads. Awesome atmosphere. Lots of heaters so it isn’t cold at all.“

“My pizza was delicious and surprisingly had a generous portion of ingredients. It had one of the highest quality sourced ingredients of any restaurant I have ever been to. By ordering online, I cut to the front of the in-store line. My pizza was ready in under 20-minutes. I would definitely recommend this Blaze Pizza location and will be back soon!“

“Good price for decent pizza but we got delivery and they forgot 2 of 4 pizzas. They refunded what they missed but we still had to pay all the delivery fees again to get the order to us.

Update - they refunded the pizza and delivery charge for the second delivery“

“"LIFE'S TOO SHORT . . . HAVE A BLAST!" Well, I certainly did. I discovered this establishment while on a trip to the San Luis Obispo area (combination of business and pleasure). My lawyer, Barry, and I decided to give it a try for lunch. Great selection of microbrews; always a plus. I had a couple pints of one their own IPAs. Barry just had iced tea. He doesn't drink; says it hinders his judgment on the job. In addition to representing me, he also aids in the evictions of apartment tenants who are several months late with their rent. (I've noticed a lot of them seem to be single mothers with at least three kids, but I digress.) We split the Chili Cheese Waffle Fries for a starter. Loaded with chili with the right balance of spice and heartiness to it. On top of that, it didn't give me any digestive issues! Excellent burgers here. I had the Jalapeno. Half-pounder and Angus, the way it should be. Barry had a Margherita Pizza, which I thought strange coming after chili cheese fries. He said it was a lot better than the one he had at Northern Italiano a few weeks back when meeting with another client of his named Lance. Our server, Amanda, was exceptional. Just the right amount of EYE CONTACT. Regularly CHECKED UP on us, but not to the point of intrusiveness. I emphasize those points because a lot of servers today don't understand that eye contact and checking up on the customer are indispensable components to providing quality service. Barry and I were tempted to take her golfing with us. Regards, Mitchell D. Cumstein“

“Refuse to give receipts, price gauging, horrible customer service and workers do not have access to perform basic customer service tasks.
One time a delivery person opened my door.
Do not care about customer satisfaction and do not give stuffed crust when ordered on multiple occasions.
food borne illness from this store the time the driver opened my apartment door.
Terrible customer service experience.“