21 Best Pizza Restaurants in Fort Collins

Nick's Restaurant And Bar Italian • $$
1100 S College Ave, Fort Collins

Customers` Favorites

Brussels Sprouts Caesar Salad
Garlic Bread with Marinara
Nick’S Famous Burger
Bucatini Carbonara GF
Local Sausage Pizza
Chicken Parmigiana
Chicken Parmesan
Fried Mozzarella
Margherita Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza

“Awesome service, pet friendly in outdoor seating area, and the Local Sausage Pizza was fabulous. Thanks Luke and Andrea.“

4.2 Good196 Reviews
Totally 80's Pizza & Museum Pizza • $
2567 S Shields St Unit 4C, Fort Collins

Customers` Favorites

Yippee Ki Yah Mother Clucker Pizza
Ultimate Pepperoni Pizza Small 9
Giant Garlic Parmesan Twists
Totally 80s Supreme Pizza
Flamin' Hot Cheeto Pizza
Jalapeño and Cheese
New Wave Rave Pizza
Mozzarella Sticks
Spicy Pickle Fries
Maui Style Pizza

“200% recommend...touched my core and the pizza is amazing!!!“

4.8 Superb296 Reviews
Postcard Pizza Pizza Takeaway • $
133 Remington St, Fort Collins

Customers` Favorites

Large Pizza 8 Slices
Slice Margherita
Mikes Hot Honey
Pepperoni Pizza
Chocolate Chip
Side Hot Honey
Original

“Hearing the words "Fort Collins pizza" has always been a pain-point for me. When I moved to Fort Collins years ago, the lack of a good pizza was nothing short of heartbreaking. As of yesterday, I thought I had tried every pizza joint in the area, but I had not.
Enter Postcard Pizza.
Hidden away in Equinox brewing just next to Old Town square, I was recommended Postcard Pizza by a friend who described their experience as "life-changing". I have no better words to describe it.
From the pizza dough, to the sauce, to the crusted cheese corners and sides, the toppings, the texture, the mouthfeel...This was a DAMN good pizza. If this pizza was a 10 (and it was), the distance from 9 to 10 is so vast that it has never, and will never be traveled.

I shared it with a friend (her first time here as well) who has lived in Fort Collins her whole life. We both ate in complete silence, entranced at the symphony being played on our tastebuds. Square after square, bite after bite, until I broke the silence. With tears in my eyes, I asked her, "Are we in heaven? Is this the end?"

Memories of a childhood I don't even know belonged to me came rushing back. Suddenly I was 8 years old, dancing around my parents living room with Toby Keith's "Should've Been a Cowboy" playing on the stereo. I felt sunlight dance on my skin for the first time. Is life itself folding in on this pizza?
Atoms splitting, light being projected into and out of my eyes, energy radiating from one heart to the next. Scales of prejudice fell from me. The walls I've inadvertently put up to protect myself from hurt, the same walls which have shielded me from comfort, came crashing down around me. I felt; I saw God, and He was a pepperoni.
All the wars, religious debates, famines, deaths...all the love, children being born, cats sleeping in windows, the brisk air on a November morning...This whole thing called life. It all made sense. I made sense of it all. I found the meaning of life hidden between the sauce and the cheese of this pizza.

Pizza guy in the red shirt, I never got your name, but you have single handedly changed the trajectory of my life. Fort Collins pizza has been solved.

TL;DR: good pizza, will be back. May cause an existential crisis.“

4.9 Superb113 Reviews
The Corner Slice Pizza • $
172 N College Ave Suite C, Fort Collins

Customers` Favorites

Dairy Free Cheese Pizza with Pepperoni
Pepperoni Pizza by the Slice
Cheese Pizza by the Slice
Cheese and Supreme Pizza
Ringo's Meatball Parm
Cheese Garlic Bread
Garlic Pretzels 3
Margherita Pizza
I'll Pesto Pizza
Pepperoni Slice

“This is seriously the best pizza I’ve had in foco. The service is great! We stumbled on open mic night on Wednesdays..great local artists! Just a super nice place. Only reason for 4 vs 5 star on the atmosphere rating is you might have to park a few blocks away , but it’s worth it!“

4.7 Superb146 Reviews
La piadina - Italian Flatbread Sandwiches Pizza • $
234 N College Ave Unit B3, Fort Collins

Customers` Favorites

Piadina with Prosciutto Stracchino and Arugula
Garlic Piadina Bread
Meatball
Daniele

“Excellent food, great staff. La Piadina is top drawer.“

4.7 Superb109 Reviews
Slyce Pizza Co. Pizza • $
163 W Mountain Ave, Fort Collins

Customers` Favorites

Pizza by the Slice Dine in: Yes Outdoor seating: Yes Takeout: Yes
Pizza 1 2 Cheese Bread
Mac and Cheese Pizza
Half & Half Pizzas
Mac N Cheese Pizza
Individual Slices
Pepperoni Pizza
Buffalo Chicken
Artichoke Pesto
Hawaiian Pizza

“Great pizza great service“

4.4 Superb140 Reviews
Papa Murphy's | Take 'N' Bake Pizza Pizza • $
238 E Harmony Rd Suite D9, Fort Collins

Customers` Favorites

Mediterranean Chicken Garlic w O Sundried Tomatos
Create Your Own Half & Half Pizza Original Crust
Herb Chicken Mediterranean Pizza Baking Required
Papa's All Meat - Keto Friendly Baking Required
Chicken Bacon Artichoke Baking Required
Create Your Own Crustless Keto Friendly
Papa's All Meat Pizza Baking Required
Scratch-Made 5-Cheese Bread
Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough
Herb Chicken Mediterranean

“I went in, didn't find my pizza finished (I was early), and a fellow said, "It's right here. I'll get it done for you!"

I was bringing my wife back from eye surgery, and I really appreciated his swiftness, especially among the Tuesday crowd!

Of course, the pizza was made right as well.

Parking: Park over by the pet store. It's better than playing chicken with the other nut-jobs trying to get a sale-priced pizza!“

4.8 Superb51 Reviews
MOD Pizza Pizza • $
1013 Centre Ave, Fort Collins

Customers` Favorites

Pepperoni Sausage and Pineapple Pizza
PEPP Artichoke Black Olive Pizza
Create Your Own Pizza My Way
Hawaiin Mushroom Pizza
Create Your Own Pizza
Create Your Own Salad
Unlimited Toppings
BBQ Chicken Pizza
Mad Dog Mod Size
Gluten Free BYO

“We ordered Mod Pizza tonight and it was amazing! The toppings were fresh and delicious, the crust was crispy and fluffy, the cheese options were exciting, and the roasted garlic was a perfect addition! The salad was crispy and fresh. The No Name Cakes were perfect individual portions. Everything was absolutely incredible!“

4.6 Superb74 Reviews
Otto Pint Pizza • $
1100 Oakridge Dr, Fort Collins

Customers` Favorites

Burrata Dine in: Yes Outdoor seating: Yes Takeout: Yes
Weldwerks Pumpkin Pie Cheesecake Berliner
Build Your Own Pizza
Smoked Duck Pizza
Margherita Pizza
The Riviera Pizza
The Ziggy Pizza
Beer and Pizza
Dunkelweizen
Custom Pizza

“Great pizza spot!! The outdoor/indoor space is spacious and the staff is super friendly. I loved the chicken pesto pizza and how each pie is the perfect size for an individual order (with maybe a little extra for a snack later). Awesome little lunch spot and place to hang with friends!“

4.3 Superb126 Reviews
Cozzola's Pizza Pizza • $
1112 Oakridge Dr #114, Fort Collins

Customers` Favorites

Half and Half Hawaiian and Meat Eater
GF the Meat Eater Pizza 12
Barbecue Chicken Classic
12 Garlic Bread
Pesto Change-O
Montgomery Pass
Hannah's Pizza
Mama's Garden
The Omnivore
Big Veggie

“Cozzola's is my FAVORITE pizza in Fort Collins! Their crust is perfect, not too thin and not too thick. It's chewy and reheats well. I LOVE that they have cream cheese as a topping and they are generous with it, unlike a Krazy place that I know. The pizza is always ready when they say it will be. Yes, it costs a little bit more than some places, but I think it's a good value for the quality. Love it!

Parking: There are reserved spots for Cozzola's.“

4.6 Superb50 Reviews
Panhandler's Pizza - Fort Collins, CO Pizza • $
2721 S College Ave, Fort Collins

Customers` Favorites

California Artichoke Pizza
Chicago-Style Sausage Pizza
Combo Pizza by the Slice
The Lovehandler Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza Slice
Cheese Garlic Bread
Original Pan-Style
Slice of the Day
Pepperoni Slice
Deluxe Combo

“been going for 40 years and I've always loved the place. no better pizza around.“

4.2 Good112 Reviews
JJ's Wood Fired Pizza Pizza • $
4015 S Taft Hill Rd, Fort Collins

Customers` Favorites

Kids Cheese or Pepperoni Pizza
Garlic Bread Dippers
Meatball Appetizer
BBQ Chicken Pizza
Gluten Free Crust
Margherita Pizza
Margarita Pizza
Hawaiian Pizza
Lasagna Pizza
Caesar Salad

“#HiddenGemFoCo# definitely the best pizza in town for me and my family .“

4.2 Good111 Reviews
Beau Jo's Fort Collins Pizza • $
205 N College Ave, Fort Collins

Customers` Favorites

The Pizza Skillet LLB Pizza Pricing
Cherry Beau Jo's Dessert Cobbler
Cauliflower Crust Pizza
Sky Hawk Mountain Pizza
Cranberry Walnut Salad
Aiden's Street Pizza
Garlic Cheese Bread
Gluten Free Pizza
Margherita Pizza
The Motherlode

“Only tried the mountain crust pizza but it was really good 💯“

4.1 Good222 Reviews
Oregano's Italian • $
4235 S College Ave, Fort Collins

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Parmigiana with Linguini
El Diablo Shrimp Pasta
Kick-Butt Garlic Bread
The Big Beefstro Salad
Fried Zucchini Sticks
Julius Caesar Salad
Oregano’S Favorite
Italian Flag Lasagna
Garlic Cheese Bread
Boom Dip Appetizer

“Thank heavens we celebrated our 36 year anniversary at Oregano's yesterday! Jeffrey was fantastic by making us feel super special! Let's not forget how delicious the chicken Parm and pizza were as well! We love this place for the service, food and ambiance!! 5 stars always!!“

4.6 Superb242 Reviews
Blackjack Pizza & Salads Pizza • $
4206 S College Ave #107, Fort Collins

Customers` Favorites

Pepperoni Passion Pizza Large
Italian Sausage Pizza
Chicken Bacon Ranch
16 Xtra Large Pizza
Mediterranean Salad
Chocolate Brownie
Good Deal Pizza
Fantastic Pizza
Straight Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza

“Absolutely love this specific Blackjack Pizza! Logan is always so helpful, and remembers frequent customers. The delivery drivers are always prompt, courteous, and actual people who you can tell love their work, instead of ones from other pizza places that are always grumpy and in a rush.

We love getting either the pepperoni passion with cream cheese, or a double pepperoni with cream cheese.

One of the few places you can get an extra large pizza without breaking the bank.

Even their wings are absolutely wonderful, and still affordable.

If you haven’t tried them yet, what are you waiting for? ❤️“

4.1 Good68 Reviews
Pizza Casbah Pizza Delivery • $
126 W Laurel St, Fort Collins

Customers` Favorites

Mushroom Onion Pineapple Calzone
The Bronx Deluxe Pizza
Beach Bum Pizza 18
The Gyro Pizza 24
Hot Chicken Wings
Mozzarella Sticks
The New Yorker
Dipping Sauces
Cheese Slices
Mini Cannoli

“Absolutely hands down the best pizza in foco. As close to nyc style as you’ll get outside of Manhattan. Not to mention the interior is awesome and the staff and owner are amazing!“

4 Good105 Reviews
Mama Roni's Pizza Pizza • $
1006 Spring Creek Ln b4, Fort Collins

Customers` Favorites

Pepperoni Pizza Roll
Chicken Bacon Ranch
Cheese Pizza Roll
Colorado Pizza
Greek Salad
House Pizza
Supreme
Wings

“Best pizza EVER! Crust was amazing on the thin & crispy, done just the way I like it❤️“

4 Good93 Reviews
BJ's Restaurant & Brewhouse Pizza • $$
2670 E Harmony Rd, Fort Collins

Customers` Favorites

Southern Comfort Chicken Sandwich
BJ's Classic Chicken Sandwich
Hot Fudge Brownie Pizookie
BJ's Smokehouse Burger
Chicken Tortilla Soup
Bacon Cheeseburger
Avocado Egg Rolls
Mozzarella Sticks
House Wedge Salad
Deep Dish Ziti

“Food as always very good. Service from Cortney was superb, great attitude and a real pro. Seasonal drinks...outstanding.“

3.9 Good246 Reviews
Mama Roni's Pizza Pizza • $
4733 S Timberline Rd, Fort Collins

Customers` Favorites

Pesto Spinach Calzone
House Salad
Pizza Rolls

“Delicious pizza at a great price, not a long wait for food.“

3.8 Good40 Reviews
Cosmo's Pizza Pizza • $
1401 W Elizabeth St, Fort Collins

Customers` Favorites

Pepperoni Slice of Pie of the Day
Slice of Pizza Pepperoni and Bacon
Pepperoni and Sausage Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza Slice
New York-Style Pizza
Plain Cheese Pizza
The Supreme Pizza
Dipping Sauce
Half and Half
Calzones

“My daughter was living in FC and I was up visiting her, so she took me here for a real FC pizza joint (especially for late night!). Got the pepperoni with cream cheese slice and was rewarded with a few more gobs of cream cheese before a flash heat. The slices are big, the service is incredible, and the vibes are dope. Enjoyed the place for a good pick up pizza for lunch.“

3.8 Good61 Reviews
D.P. Dough Pizza • $
634 S College Ave, Fort Collins

Customers` Favorites

2 Calzones for 14 Winsday
Roni Zoni Takeout: Yes
Build Your Own Calzone
Chocolate Chip Cookie
Twilight Zone
All Calzones
Cheese Stix
Cheese Zone
Combat Zone
Tater Tots

“Usually not a problem but tonight they where well over the time the quoted me and definitely think the lady with gages and black hair needs a raise everytime she's working it's a great experience and is just all around better she dose it mainly alone and there was 4 people tonight“

3.8 Good133 Reviews

You May Also Like