24 Best Pizza Restaurants near Keystone

“Summit county’s best pizza!“

“Excellent pizza and service“

“Welcoming, warm fun atmosphere. Jeff, you made our celebration special. Thanks and hope to see you in the future. Till then, we totally recommend this place to all who visit Keystone Colorado.“

“There is a reason Rotolos has been in business since 1996. The food was delicious. The drink selection was fairly good. I wish they had a little more variety for draft beers. The atmosphere was probably missing something because we went during the off season. Ashlie, our waitress, was amazing and was the reason for the five-star review.“

“We absolutely admire the creativity and passion that Steep Brewing & Coffee Co. puts into every brew! We're inspired by your creations! Cheers!“

“We absolutely admire the creativity and passion that Steep Brewing & Coffee Co. puts into every brew! We're inspired by your creations! Cheers!“

“Amazing staff! We stayed in the River Run Dakota Lodge which had a heated pool for the kids and hot tubs for the adults. It was a quick 5 min walk to the gondola, groceries, and restaurants. Kids 2-day, full-day ski school was effective and gave parents time to ski.“

“Great pizza, great service. Great cookies.“

“I have known Nick N Willys for 4 years and have always really liked it in every aspect. The food is delicious, the service is excellent and the atmosphere of the restaurant is very pleasant. Always in the different seasons and celebrations of each year, the decoration of the restaurant is spectacular. The pizzas have varied flavors and are very delicious. The wings satisfy anyone. For all of the above, they won The Best of Summit award in 2022 and also in 2023 in the categories of best vegetarian food, best pizza and best wings in the county. In addition, the owners and employees are excellent people who always worry about maintaining the best quality and the best customer service. This time I had a personal size meat pizza, it was delicious. They also have a variety of drinks, including wines, beers and sodas. For all this, I totally recommend Nick N Willys.“

“So I was introduced to this place by my friends, and it lived up to all the hype. By far the best calzone I have ever had. This place was full on Wednesday night because of the free beer. So stop by and check out the pizza and calzones and the free beer on Wednesday nights. Trust me, you won't be disappointed.“

“My wife and I are plant-based, so Piante seemed a great option for dinner. The pizza was delicious, the service was prompt and friendly, and the atmosphere was casual and relaxing. If you're a pesto fan, check out Piante's kale-walnut pesto! The peanut butter-Oreo cheesecake is fantastic, as well. Enjoy!“

“I’m a local and will say this pizza is definitely at the top in the area. It’s delicious and well made. We’ve ordered it for catering events and ordered at home for a chill night in and it hits every time.

Dining in is a cute lil pizza bar and fun to grab a beer and slice. Definitely recommend.“

“Margherita Pizza and penne pasta were both delicious!“

“Great experience, good food and drinks! Live music“

“UPDATE: The owner called me and left me a message on 10/4/24 while I was camping. First, he gave me a full refund for my order, which was appreciated. Second, he said that they did a full inspection of their kitchen to try to figure out the problem, and they identified the polycarbonate containers they were using to hold ingredients, all NSF certified meaning they are not allowed to break. But it did break. He apologized profusely, they're lodging a complaint with the NSF foundation, and they are discontinuing the use of the containers. For that reason I am updating the rating to better reflect my experience before biting into the container piece, and for the response of the owner.

--
Last night I ordered two pizzas, one being a vegetarian pizza. I was enjoying it until the moment I chomped down on something really hard. I tried chewing it a couple of times but I realized that it was way too tough to chew, so I reached into my mouth to fish out whatever that thing was. I expected it to be a stem of a vegetable of some sort, but I was pretty shocked to find it was a very thin, very pointed, very hard piece of plastic that was about 1.5 inches long.

I'm so thankful I did not try to swallow it as it would have likely gotten stuck in my throat, or perhaps even caused damage to my intestines if it ever made it there. I don't know how something like that can make it into a pizza, and I am just super thankful that it was as large as it was, as something smaller may have been swallowed more quickly.

I hope that the owners of the business do some serious quality control work to make sure this does not happen to other customers. I'm including a picture of the piece of plastic.“

“We hosted a dinner at Fattys in their upstairs private space following our small wedding ceremony. 10/10 on everything - the food, the atmosphere, customer service - everything was top notch. So good that we had to stop in for one last dinner before leaving Breckenridge. Margo helped us plan the private event and went above and beyond. We hope to visit Breckenridge for many years to come and Fattys will be the first on our list of stops. It will forever will hold a special place in our hearts. Thank you Margo and Fattys Pizzeria!“

“we loved for dinner pizza and drinks nest to a river so relaxing“

“The food here is amazing!!! 10/10 recommend when you’re staying at Grand Timber Lodge!! They have the best staff there. Food is always fresh and made within a timely manner.“

“Awesome pizza large slices and great crust and flavor“

“Food was delicious!! I had pesto linguine with chicken and it was delicious. A salad comes with the entree also and was large. We ordered bruschetta for an appetizer and it also was terrific. Our server, Garrett, was very engaging and we will definitely return.“

“I love this place. I wish I could give it a 4.5. the atmosphere is difficult depending on the time of day. The patio is nice, if you can get a spot! ?

Parking: As with anywhere in Breckenridge, parking is tough to come by a lot of times“

“We stopped by Eric's for lunch. It was pretty busy but we were able to be seated right away. We had the kids Mac n Cheese, supreme nachos and kids burger. Food was great. Great service. It was a nice find. They were recommended by our hotel concierge.“

“Everything was great! The food was amazing and will go back once back in town.“

“Friendly and fast service, delicious NY style pizza (we got ours with basil and pepperoni). Great Pinot Grigio and beer on tap. It’s really close to the public parking and shuttle system which is super convenient if you enjoy walking. I do wish they would have a screen or something over the door, the sun was super bright and hot on our table. Otherwise, highly recommend if you’re in the area and craving some pizza! I can’t wait to come back and try some other dishes.“