Alley House Grille
$$$ • American, New American, Vegetarian
Hours:
214 Pagosa St, Pagosa Springs
(970) 264-0999
About Alley House Grille
Customers' Favorites
Alley House Grille Reviews
Share your opinion about Alley House Grille
My wife and I went to Alley House Grille in Pagosa Springs tonight for our anniversary, and it was, without exaggeration, the worst dining experience either of us has ever had. If this is what they consider “fine dining,” then the bar must be somewhere in the basement.
They asked if we were celebrating a special occasion, but clearly that was just meaningless small talk, because our server couldn’t have cared less. Nothing about our experience reflected even the slightest...read full review
My husband and I went for Valentine's dinner on 2/15/25 due to work. We were really looking forward to a special night out. We had a lovely table right in front of the fireplace that we had requested. Then we ordered appetizers...green lip mussels. They were the farthest thing from green lip mussels we have ever seen. They might have been 1 inch big and cost $26.00!! We have had green lip mussels quite often and they were not! The bread was nicely toasted on the outside,...read full review
The atmosphere is nice, but food is not great for the price point. We ordered the alley house burger and it was well done despite our request for medium. In general, the food is forgettable. The service was so so also, as they are very busy and our server took a good while to get to our table.The margarita was good, however.
Menu
Hours
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | 4 - 9PM |
| Wednesday | 4 - 9PM |
| Thursday | 4 - 9PM |
| Friday | 4 - 9PM |
| Saturday | 4 - 9PM |
| Sunday | 4 - 9PM |
People in Pagosa Springs Also Viewed
Alley House Grille is a renowned restaurant known for its diverse menu and exceptional cocktails. The fine dining options may be on the pricier side, but the value received is often praised. Standout dishes include the fried cauliflower appetizer, shrimp scampi, and pork chop. The Caesar salad and Brussels sprouts side dish are seen as average.
The restaurant offers a romantic atmosphere with attentive service and a selection of fine wines. Recent reviews highlight the excellent food, with dishes like bison ribeye, beef rib eye, short ribs, and Chilean sea bass praised for their tenderness and flavor. The service is noted as excellent and efficient, and the restaurant is kept clean with a good ambiance. However, parking can be challenging due to nearby road construction.
Customers have enjoyed the Filet, Saffron and Tomato Risotto, and the Hot and Sweet Brussel Sprouts, which have been described as divine, delicious, and amazing. The Elk, Sea Bass, and ribeye dishes have also been praised for their outstanding taste and perfect cooking. The bread pudding with lemon sauce is an exceptional dessert. Alley House Grille is a must-visit for fine dining enthusiasts in Pagosa, and reservations are highly recommended.