10 Best American Restaurants in Pagosa Springs

“Sage Eatery is a great spot with delicious food and generous portion sizes that definitely leave you satisfied. The location is super convenient, which makes it an easy choice for lunch or dinner. Everything I’ve tried has been fresh and flavorful, and you can tell a lot of care goes into the food. The employees are friendly as well. The downside is that they’re closed on Sundays and Mondays. Order was wrong, but I appreciate that they corrected it. Wait times are long - 30+ minutes for burger and fries. Overall, still a place I really enjoy and recommend.“

“The Staff appeared as though they were a Well Oiled Machine. Each Employee helping each other. They seemed to be Friends with each other which came across to me as a customer as very polite and extremely attentive to anything I would have needed. Honestly one of the BEST Dining experiences I have EVER had. I would recommend Alley House to anyone who wanted GREAT Food with Fantastic wait staff as a Bonus!!!“

“Have been going there for over 20 years Last few months this is our Sunday morning getaway. Had the Pleasure of being served by Erin this morning. Wonderful. Hostess was having a bad day I guess but Erins Great service and happy playful manner made our day 👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻“

“We eat at Colorado Roadhouse every time we come to Pagosa. It’s always great food and the wait staff is great!“

“Aspen Springs Bar & Grill has a unique atmosphere that only the people of Aspen Springs can truly appreciate. Very welcoming and rural, with a touch of country charm. I have many good friends that frequent this place, so it's like my own personal Cheers. If you're new to the area you've gotta stop by and see for yourself.“

“Excellent food and quick service!“

“So we had out of town guests for a few days. The winning restaurant for food and atmosphere? Coyote Moon Lounge!!! Absolutely the best outdoor dining/drinking space in Pagosa. AND the best food!! Their Polish sausage, homemade mac and cheese, periogies, fried chicken tenders, scratch made sauces were all out of this world. Lots of shaded spaces, tables and couches. The service is on point. OHHH and the best Long Island Ice tea I have ever had. Hidden gem.“

“This is probably our favorite restaurant in Pagosa Springs. The menu is small but the atmosphere is the best, most relaxed in town. They have a small selection of their own brews as well as a few other local + national beers on tap. It's definitely a find an open table and sit kind of place and they'll bring you the menus and take your drink orders. Their IPA was fantastic and cold which felt great in the mildly warm weather. There was live music the evening we were there and he was so good, had some of his own songs as well as some well known covers. Amazing voice. The best part in my opinion is the super dog-friendliness of the joint. The outdoor area is big with a lot of picnic tables to sit at with your puppers. It's such a chill place to hang out for a bit and soak in the weather and have some good beer. Another huge bonus here is the food. Everything we've had here was fresh and delicious but somehow they have managed to have one of the best pizzas I've ever had anywhere. The crust is thick and has enough chew to it and the sauce and cheese are great. I don't know what it is about their pizza but OMG their pizza OMG. Love this place!“

“In 18-years, never a disappointment. Our last 2 servers were beyond sensational too. We expect great service but these two ladies knocked our socks off.“

“yummy burgers and ice cream“