10 Best Ice Cream Shops near East Hampton

“The staff is always very friendly and the ice cream is delicious. My family loves this place.“

“Very friendly and what a great couple to host we hired them for our town football team as a pregame treat and their ice cream was phenomenal!!!! Highly recommend, looking forward to booking for my personal use in the near future. Ice cream is my weakness and they definitely pass the test .10/10“

“so many options and sizes!“

“Yesterday my friend and I stopped in after a performance at the Goodspeed . What a charming little place full of all kinds of delicious confections. Not only was the ice cream yummy, and we sampled several, but the young girl named Sydni working there was so friendly and accommodating and we enjoyed our stay immensely because of her as well as the tasty ice cream. Thank you Sydni for all your recommendations, we ended up with the 4 scoop sampler, which was delicious. You made our visit for ice scream a wonderful experience.“

“The girl that was working today 17/ September 2025, at 6:30pm was so nice and kind to me, she made my first experience at a Ben and Jerry’s very good and I plan to come back! She deserves a raise and she’s very sweet and was very quick with making my order, she was also very patient when I asked for a few samples since I’d never been here before!! 10/10“

“So glad we finally tried Robb's today! We LOVED it! ICE CREAM, made there, was excellent! Very creamy. Great mouth feel. NO crystallization. Many interesting varieties. Prices were very fair. $6 for 2 scoops in a yummy waffle cone was very good. People were very nice as well. Great price for all kinds of pumpkins too.“

“We go there A LOT alone over the years for the yummy lobster rolls and sundaes but this time we rented out their new pink shack for my baby shower. They did an absolute beautiful job on the inside. It was so perfect for this type or event. The owner was speedy, responsive, and sufficient. The day was perfect and would 10/10 recommend for your next get together or if you just wanted to stop by for a sweet treat, good food and great atmosphere“

“I am not typically an ice cream girl… I go along for the ride… but lavender honey did not go to waste nor disappoint!! Beyond delicious and great staff!“

“Excellent burgers!! Large portions! And the thick cut chips were crunchy and flavorful!!“

“My daughter and I go to this Sweet Frog location often as we live in town. We even continued to go during the height of the pandemic because it’s important to support small businesses. I never once complained when they barricaded their public bathrooms during Covid and didn’t allow anyone to use them. Not even when my daughter had an emergency bathroom situation did I complain. We went over to Whole Foods and figured it out. But tonight I felt not wanted there. Their posted hours for Friday state they are open 9:30pm. This is untrue they are open till 9. We arrived after an evening at the park around 8:40pm (plenty of time right). I was met with “Just so you know we’re closing in a minute”. No “Hi” no “Welcome to Sweet Frog”. I actually turned to the young man and said “I’m sorry?”. Because I was so taken back at the odd greeting I received. It was so cold and rude. I have no issues with a business letting me know it’s almost time to close. I won’t even enter a business super close to closing especially if I don’t believe I will be able to get out in time. From the reviews below this seems to be the norm here now. I have to say the Froyo is always good and always fresh and I’ve never had a problem with their products. It is expensive and they are back to weighing the cups again so just be prepared for at least $10-$12 for two ice creams at minimum.“