11 Best Ice Cream Shops near East Hampton

“The staff is always very friendly and the ice cream is delicious. My family loves this place.“

“Our employer treated their employees to Blue Chip Creamery. We had their cookie ice cream sandwiches. Not only did they have a great selection but the cookies were fresh not hard and the ice cream was AMAZING!! All 100+ employees recommend them VERY HIGHLY!! They even delivered them to us and on time!! Thank you. We will use you again I'm sure!!“

“Best ice cream around and the best customer service“

“The chocolate chip cookie ice cream sandwiches are soooooo good 🤤😋“

“It's Ben & Jerries. They are awesome. Though staff seem a little short staffed for the cleaning and last minute service needs. Seems like often one person is there to do it all. But may have been a call out that day. Always clean, variety offered.“

“Wonderful. I like black raspberry and chocolate so tried the purple calf. It was super creamy“

“I love they have treats for my dog. ROSIE loves the yappy yogurt with the dog bone. We get them for all the grandpups when they come over.“

“Excellent burgers!! Large portions! And the thick cut chips were crunchy and flavorful!!“

“I am not typically an ice cream girl… I go along for the ride… but lavender honey did not go to waste nor disappoint!! Beyond delicious and great staff!“

“My daughter and I go to this Sweet Frog location often as we live in town. We even continued to go during the height of the pandemic because it’s important to support small businesses. I never once complained when they barricaded their public bathrooms during Covid and didn’t allow anyone to use them. Not even when my daughter had an emergency bathroom situation did I complain. We went over to Whole Foods and figured it out. But tonight I felt not wanted there. Their posted hours for Friday state they are open 9:30pm. This is untrue they are open till 9. We arrived after an evening at the park around 8:40pm (plenty of time right). I was met with “Just so you know we’re closing in a minute”. No “Hi” no “Welcome to Sweet Frog”. I actually turned to the young man and said “I’m sorry?”. Because I was so taken back at the odd greeting I received. It was so cold and rude. I have no issues with a business letting me know it’s almost time to close. I won’t even enter a business super close to closing especially if I don’t believe I will be able to get out in time. From the reviews below this seems to be the norm here now. I have to say the Froyo is always good and always fresh and I’ve never had a problem with their products. It is expensive and they are back to weighing the cups again so just be prepared for at least $10-$12 for two ice creams at minimum.“

“3/31/25. So I’m actually at the Dairy Queen restaurant right now compliments go out to the young lady working the front counter. She was pleasant, and I had sat down while I was waiting for my food. She actually brought my food to the table for me, which was very kind. Compliments should go to the rest of the staff tonight as well as they made my food and they seem happy serving other people. A restaurant is clean and very modern.“