50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Middlefield

“Have not been there in 30 years several owners ago. My wife and I went on Sunday and had a great lunch. She had the calzone and I had a gyro. Best gyro I have had in a very long time. Owner and I believe his sons in kitchen very friendly and talked for a bit about recipes and food. Will be going back and recommending it highly. The new owners have hit this one out of the park.“

“I love the Pizza here!! The owners are always extremely friendly and accommodating!“

“Wow !!! A group of 4 of us were traveling through the area and needed a good place for Dinner …We called and made a reservation , the owner Al was very personable on the phone .We arrived for dinner and he had our name on table , and he introduced himself …We had a couple of beers while he explained the menu to us ….we Decided on a couple of appetizers and also a small pizza to sample before ordering our dinner . The appetizers arrived and were very good, but the star of the show was definitely the pizza , so much flavor … the crust was to die for light and airy and so much crunch in the crust !!!! Next was the Dinner - Chicken Francaise , Chicken Parm , Chicken Marsala , Fettuccini Carbonaro .All meals arrived hot and were Delicious …We also got to meets Al’s Daughter who was very personable just like her Father ….We wished we had this Restaurant in our community . Give this Restaurant a shot , you won’t regret it . Thank you“

“I've been quite impressed every time I've grabbed something with these guys! First time tested out with slices which were good, then had a surprisingly good penne alla vodka with shrimp- which were cooked to perfection, and tonight I got a Ceaser salad with shrimp and some wings- all really good! The shrimp again was very flavorful and not overcooked. I'm glad they're nearby because Brasa Bella will definitely become a staple for us! 😁 Support your local small businesses!!“

“their pizza is great and the owner & staff are good guys. i also recommend the tiramisu.“

“fresh Amazing Pizza. the crust was absolutely the best. you can tell they've been in business for 40 years still the same as when I was a kid. highly recommend for takeout, limited seating. no alcoholic beverages but you can purchase soda“

“There’s something about Main Street in Middletown that I really enjoy. On any given day it has this eclectic, culturally diverse vibe that makes it feel alive. Tibetan restaurants. Vegan spots. Italian. Mexican. Coffee shops and pastry counters.

On this particular day the sun was out, the sidewalks were busy, and people from all walks of life were strolling the street. It’s the kind of place where you can just sit for a bit, soak it all in, and watch the world go by.

Today we decided to stop into a new place: Middletown Halal Grill & Pizza.

We tried two pies: a classic cheese and a Philly cheesesteak pizza.

Both were excellent.

Everything started with a really flavorful crust. Nice balance of crisp on the outside with just the right amount of chew inside. The sauce was well balanced too. Not overly sweet, not acidic, just a nicely seasoned tomato sauce that let the other flavors shine.

The cheese pizza was simple and well executed. Cheese evenly distributed and melted perfectly, giving that smooth, creamy texture you want in a good slice.

The Philly pizza used the same base and added shaved steak, peppers, and onions. Great combination. No single ingredient trying to steal the show. Everything worked together.

They also offered a side of house-made tzatziki sauce for the Philly.

Now I know what you’re thinking… putting a cold white sauce on hot pizza can get you some funny looks. But trust me on this one. It worked. The tzatziki was made in-house, light, refreshing, and added a cool contrast to the rich steak and cheese.

Bonus points: the dough is made fresh daily.

The place itself is a cool little spot. Nothing fancy. Very unassuming. But sometimes those are the best places. A perfect stop to grab a pie, sit for a bit, people watch on Main Street, or catch up with friends over good food.

The staff was incredibly friendly and attentive, which always makes the experience better.

They offer a variety of other items too, wings, grinders, and more. Everything on the menu is Halal, meaning no pork. And honestly, that’s fine by me. This time I stuck with the pizzas, but next time I’m definitely going to try some of their Halal meats.

Solid pizza. Friendly people. Great Main Street vibe.

I’ll definitely be back“

“yes, highly recommend. pizza is really great, we ordered ahead to go for my mom's 81st. enjoyed by everyone!“

“First time trying Rendevous tonight with my Son. Amazing! The kid at 3/4 for a large pizza before we got back to Oxford. Saw the review on Barstool and had to go. Better than Pepe’s and more. Friendly Staff. Thanks. We will be back soon.“

“Just go here stop reading the reviews. Great staff even better pizza.

Went in one day looking for a slice have only gone there since. I won't get pizza anywhere else consistency is on point and the staff and owners are super friendly and the pizzas are always fantastic.“

“Good pizza, fast service and got a party of 21 in and out quickly with lots of kids.“

“There honestly is no better place to eat! The food is above and beyond EVERY time and we've been going here many many years! And not only is the food delicious, every single person who works there is spectacular! I truly mean that! They are all always the kindest most caring people, they know your name and treat you like family even in the most crazy hectic busy moments they make you smile and feel appreciated!! No better place to get food from and no better people to get to interact with!! Loooove Westside pizza!!!“

“Best pizza in the town ❤️good pizza ❤️“

“Great food“

“Great food. Excellent service. Our “go to” for pizza, subs and more! Great wine selection with a full bar!!“

“First time trying today. wonderful crust and the sauce is very good. Also has great staff. Highly recommend!“

“My son and I went today for lunch. I have been wanting a pistachio martini since I saw it made from the happy bartender with the huge smile. I didn’t get her name but see her on the Christos fb videos. Did not disappoint was delicious. She is a great bartender and a wonderful waitress l. We sat in the bar area and it was enjoyable as it wasn’t loud and the table gave us plenty of room for our meal. Brussels Sprouts were delicious as always I had a Cajun wrap and my son had a huge salad loaded with chicken and avocado 🥑 I remember Christos when it was in the plaza and the food never disappoints. I also enjoy the daily family specials text to me. If you haven’t signed up to get the daily specials text to you do it. So many great meals to pick up and bring home. There’s two different specials. Every day lunch and dinner. Give Christos a try if you haven’t been you won’t be disappointed. I live in West Haven but my son is lucky enough to live in North Haven and pick up from Christos on his way home from Westport.“

“Never disappointed. Food and service is the best!“

“I’ve been loving Zirios for a long time but I’m getting very upset with paying more and getting less ingredients, I mean real stingy. Sausage or meat ball, disappointed!“

“Antonio's on Route Five earns my highest recommendation - it's absolutely amazing. After accidentally misinterpreting the combo option as an opportunity to create a fully customized pizza, I was pleased to find the staff remarkably friendly and understanding when they clarified it only included all the meats and veggies . They made me a new pizza“

“I order all four locations“

“Hubbard Park has best pizza, grinders, salads, boneless chicken. They very nice and friendly and very fast. Prices are definitely worth the food very tasty. Delivery drivers are awesome and respectful. I actually was sad when they went on vacation because my husband and I are disabled and cooking sometimes is too much. Thank You Hubbard Park ❤️❤️❤️❤️ 5 Star rating“

“love this place. excellent food. ordered gnocci with sauteed zucchini and onions in red sauce, and side of sausage. it is out of this world good.“

“We stopped here a couple of months ago, on a whim, when we saw a sign advertising breakfast, and we've been back multiple times since. Their breakfast is the BEST around! The coffee, french toast, pancakes, eggs, and western omelette are all delicious, and the hashbrowns are like no other! Food is priced very well. Staff is very helpful and friendly. The restaurant and bathroom are VERY clean. Their bathroom even has a baby changing table. Highly recommend stopping in for a delicious start to your day!“

“Hands down the best pizza place in Wallingford!!! Highly recommended. Hopefully @barstoolsports gives them a review one day! My score is a solid 8.6 👍🏻 Also a big thank you to the owner Fabi for always giving the best service“

“I have been a loyal customer to honey spot since moving to Meriden 10 years ago I came from New Haven where pizza is perfect and hard to match and I have to say honey spot is the best!!! The customer service is wonderful and my orders are always correct and cooked to perfection!! They are so polite and even know it is me when I am calling!! I would give 10 stars if I could!!! If you haven’t been here before this is your sign to try it now!!! Thanks honey spot for making all my dinners with you a dream!!! You guys are the best!!“

“Great seating and atmosphere with an expansive selection of both food and drinks. Open wall connecting it to Gyro Love on the right side as well. Very good service and reasonable pricing. Single slices are amazing with bar because chicken and the cheese pizza slices being my favorite.“

“Excellent pizza. Thin crust, good red sauce, tasty toppings. Great central location too!“

“Good food, nice staff and clean facilities! Never had anything bad from there“

“I can’t say enough about Tommy’s Pizza Palace Vasili’s Greek Everything salad dressing!! I first came upon it at a craft show at Wadsworth mansion! It’s so delicious that it has become my mission to drive from Stamford to Middletown to pick it up! I grabbed two bottles on 8/17 and made the mistake of sharing with my family so I have to go back this week for more! I can’t wait for it to hit a local store near me! If it doesn’t I will absolutely continue to make the trip! Try it - you will not be disappointed! Thank you to everyone at Tommy’s Pizza palace - all of your food is amazing!!“

“My neighbor mentioned to me that he and his wife were going to lunch at Pete’s and said he was bringing his in laws. He and his in laws raved about the food. My neighbor said the roast beef (made in house) grinder was amazingly great. That’s my favorite, so I stopped by Pete’s a couple days ago and got the roast beef grinder with provalone cheese, mayo, roasted and banana peppers, shedded lettuce and tomato. It was sooo good that I had to go back in to let them know. Come to find out Pete’s dad made me the grinder. What a nice man!!! Talked to him for a few minutes. I found a place near home that I will be visiting again and again!!! Next time I’m trying a pizza. So many great reviews……I read them all!!!“

“Pizza is great……but the wings got to go never again.“

“We stop there every weekend and have breakfast, the staff is very friendly and they know what we order as we sit“

“Great service and a staple for great pizza. They know what they're doing in that place. My wife and I order from Gino's once a week for date night. The wings are the truth! Best in Ct!“

“I was ordering pizza to pick up on my way home. I was with my toddler and I obviously wasn’t going to leave her in the car and I didn’t really want to take her out of the car seat and put her back in two minutes later. When I called to order I asked if I could give them my credit card over the phone and if they wouldn’t mind bringing the pizza out to my car when I got there. They were very understanding and happy to accommodate. It was very helpful.“

“The arugula salad was the BEST salad I think I’ve ever had and we frequent many different restaurants weekly. Shroom pizza was delicious as well. Definitely will return.“

“Great pizza, great location and the nicest people you’ll ever meet!“

“Delicious pizza, but lately the delivery is making me want to stop ordering. With an already estimated time of 65 minutes for 1 pepperoni pizza, it goes well over another half hour or so… idk, disappointing“

“I had the opportunity to win a free lunch at my work place! It was as amazing as it looks in the pictures ! I picked the focaccia sandwiches- and caesar salad, and everything was delicious! I will be in to try your other dishes...❤ Thank you so much! Everyone enjoyed the lunch!“

“Placed a delivery order at night that was incorrect and by the time I seen the mistake they had closed for the night. The next day I called to let them know and they apologized plus replaced it without hesitation they are a family favorite and their service is awesome as well as all the food“

“I had such a wonderful experience at Bella’s Ristorante! The food was absolutely amazing—everything we ordered was delicious and full of flavor. The portions were generous, and we had more than enough to enjoy.What really stood out was how friendly and welcoming the staff were. Our food came out quickly, which made the whole experience even better.I’ll definitely be coming back again. Highly recommend!“

“I’m a regular here because I love it! The environment, the food and drinks, and the staff make this place a gem in Middletown. I recently had a small engagement celebration with friends where we also tied in a surprise pregnancy announcement and the restaurant was super helpful in my planning. I recommend Sicily to anyone!“

“This place never disappoints awesome people great, Pizza for any occasion no I was not paid to say that lol try it guys I promise is good“

“Cobb Salad,tasteful grilled chicken&bacon/great garlic rolls. Also,my favorite Pizza is Robs Pizza.“

“Can’t even believe how Abe from this restaurant spoke to me! I ordered a pizza for my kids and it came without sauce and when I called to explain, it was nothing but RUDENESS! He had the audacity to tell me I had to apologize to him and his counter girl before he would replace. He told me he didn’t care if he lost a customer, I had no idea who he was. He hung up on me and when I called back and asked for the owner to explain he started yelling and had his employees in the background yelling he was the boss and I had no idea who I was talkin to and I should find out before talking to him and hung up on me again! I called the Milford location and asked who the owner was, his name is OZ and he sounded like this was certainly not the 1st time he had a complaint. He apologized over and over but honestly I cannot believe the things he said! SMH worst customer service EVER GHETTO!!!!!“

“Today we visited Fabian.s.pizza at Portland Connecticut. Amazing food, yummy & delicious. Great menus, food hand made and fresh, kids friendly! Thank you very much for your hospitality!“

“We ordered catering for my daughter’s graduation from the S Main St location. The food was exceptional. We ordered chicken parm, chicken marsala & eggplant parm. Everything was amazing and the eggplant was by far the best I’ve ever had! Thank you!!!“

“I Came here for the first time because I could smell the pizza cooking from the parking lot. It smelled as good as it tasted! I ordered a large cheese pizza and salad with chicken. Staff was pleasant! Food was delivered quickly and tasted great! Will be back again !

Updated 5/9/2026

Still have awesome food and service here! We came here for Mother’s Day with a party of 7 and they got us right in! Staff was great ! We enjoyed our food too :)“

“Been going to Freddy’s forever! Haven’t found any other place that will beat the taste of Freddy’s original Greek taste since Freddy worked at the original ABC Pizza when we were in high school! Still the best! I have to drive a few miles but it’s always worth it!“

“Great menu, reasonable prices, and great service. We will be back. I give them 5 stars.“