15 Best Pizza Restaurants in Middletown

“Five stars simply don’t seem like enough for the outstanding experience I had at Middletown Grill & Pizza.

From the moment I walked in, Brother Hamid demonstrated what true customer service should look like. He was welcoming, professional, attentive, respectful, and genuinely cared about making sure every customer had a great experience. His positive attitude and dedication to excellence stood out in every interaction.

The food was excellent, the atmosphere was warm and inviting, and the service was second to none. Brother Hamid went above and beyond in every category of customer service, making me feel valued and appreciated as a customer.

If you’re looking for great food and exceptional hospitality, Middletown Grill & Pizza is the place to be. Brother Hamid is a tremendous asset to the business and sets a standard that is difficult to match.

Thank you for the outstanding service. I will definitely be returning and highly recommend this establishment to everyone.“

“Great food“

“yes, highly recommend. pizza is really great, we ordered ahead to go for my mom's 81st. enjoyed by everyone!“

“The arugula salad was the BEST salad I think I’ve ever had and we frequent many different restaurants weekly. Shroom pizza was delicious as well. Definitely will return.“

“Placed a delivery order at night that was incorrect and by the time I seen the mistake they had closed for the night. The next day I called to let them know and they apologized plus replaced it without hesitation they are a family favorite and their service is awesome as well as all the food“

“Ravioli was very good. Homemade Tasty sauce but I do like a little more pepper in my sauce“

“Sfogliatelle! They offer it frozen! Get it, pop it in your air fryer until golden brown and enjoy feeling like you are in heaven. It’s filled fully with great quality cheese and orange peel. It’s frozen so you can keep it on hand and feel free to lie to your friends that you made it. Best enjoyed alone with a cup of coffee on a quiet morning.“

“We ordered catering for my daughter’s graduation from the S Main St location. The food was exceptional. We ordered chicken parm, chicken marsala & eggplant parm. Everything was amazing and the eggplant was by far the best I’ve ever had! Thank you!!!“

“I’m a regular here because I love it! The environment, the food and drinks, and the staff make this place a gem in Middletown. I recently had a small engagement celebration with friends where we also tied in a surprise pregnancy announcement and the restaurant was super helpful in my planning. I recommend Sicily to anyone!“

“Maria is amazing she is professional, kind and caring! All of my cakes, cookies and food for my parties are made by Mazzota's Bakery! Her attention to detail and always willing to go above and beyond to make the perfect cake for all of my events! I refer her to everyone bc she bakes with all her heart! María is always willing to complete an order even if it's last minute! Mazzotta's Bakery is the place to order for any event -just order and you will see how great her cakes, cookies and food is for yourself .🩷thank you“

“Vero's never dissapoints! Best broccoli rabe pizza, amazing local farmed sausage, delicious dinners & oh my god the bread! Fabulous!“

“Italian grinders are my favorite here. My kids like the buffalo chicken pizza here. Great crunchy crust
Wide variety of beer selection and have a full bar. Has bingo, live music and other activities.

Wheelchair accessibility: Many handicap spots“

“We ordered catering for my daughter’s graduation from the S Main St location. The food was exceptional. We ordered chicken parm, chicken marsala & eggplant parm. Everything was amazing and the eggplant was by far the best I’ve ever had! Thank you!!!“

“I returned today 2 months after leaving a negative review. I took a chance by purchasing a small cheese pie. I was very happy with the pizza today. I will come back again to my favorite pizzeria.“

“Ordering from here for years, never an issue 👍“