10 Best Seafood Restaurants in Fenwick Island

“I have been missing some good seafood from my country and I say let’s try this place. No regrets. The food was great, pretty laid back ambiance. Customer service was A1. Keep doing you Rusty Jimmy.“

“Food was amazing as well as their service“

“Our food was delicious, but what was also great was Colleen. She couldn’t do enough for the four of us to make our lunch 👍 great.You have a jem of a server. Lynn 1/27/24“

“Our first visit there. I had shrimp and grits that were excellent. Very original Louisiana flavor. My wife had crab cakes with a house made sauce that was awesome. Our server, Luke, was fabulous also. Will definitely be returning.“

“Delicious Creamsicle Crush! Great server, meals came out quickly even though they were busy. I enjoyed my coconut shrimp especially because it wasn't greasy and the orange dipping sauce was enjoyable. My husband ordered the shrimp salad in a tomato. He did say it needed a little more seasoning so he asked for some Old Bay to add to it. We love coming here, but you need to arrive early or you will have a long wait!“

“We dined at One Coastal over the weekend. We had four people in our party and everyone ordered a different item on the menu. Food was fantastic! I enjoyed a simple pasta dish that was the most delish meal I’ve had in years. I shared with everyone at the table and everyone loved it. My husband had the pork chop and reported that it was delicious. My daughter had the scallops and said they were perfect. Her boyfriend had the flank steak and it looked terrific. But my pasta was PERFECTION!“

“The Station is absolutely beautiful — the entire place is decorated so well, and I loved all the little details. Unfortunately, the food was just okay, which was a bit of a bummer. I ordered their brunch special, a grilled cheese with tomato soup. The soup seemed microwaved, as it was very hot on top but cold on the bottom. For $16, that was disappointing.

Our bartender was also our server and seemed distracted and not very attentive. The service overall wasn’t great. However, the front manager was amazing. He could tell something was off with my dish, corrected it immediately, and took it off the bill. I truly hope the owners never lose him as an employee — he’s amazing and made a real difference in our experience.

I understand the restaurant is under new ownership and has only been open a short time. With such a beautiful space and a great front manager, I’m optimistic about its potential and would be happy to give it another try soon.“

“Best wings and fish tacos around!“

“Food is amazing and people are great! Had recent health diagnosis and can’t eat corn; asked if they could scoop with little corn - they picked corn out for me! Seafood is always fresh and top notch! 5 of 5!“

“Food: I had a 6 oz NY Strip, over easy eggs, home fries and toast for 16 bucks. I felt like that was phenomenal value. The steak was juicy and flavorful.

Service: We had a wonderful waitress and the service was fast and responsive.

Ambiance: Nothing special, but I do enjoy looking at their bakery selection.

I would highly recommend this place for breakfast.“