12 Best American Restaurants in New Castle

“My friend and I took a girls road trip today and ended up in New Castle. We decided to try Jessop's Tavern for lunch and absolutely loved it. Friendly warm atmosphere, friendly staff and delicious lunch! So glad we decided to stop in. We will definitely be back!“

“If you want the BEST COOK THE BEST WAITRESS THE BEST FRESHEST SALAD THE BEST MAC & CHEESE BEST LIVER GRAVY AND ONIONS ALL FOOD Surrounded by the CLEANEST area around IT IS here!!!“

“I had seen their 4.8 rating on google maps for several months. I was a little skeptical. I was happily surprised how good Appleby's was. Let's remember it is a gas station. I am pretty sure it was a husbadn and wife team working. Good taste and amount for price.“

“Best food ever. Everything was fresh. Service was great and with a smile. Loved the live Jazz to! Will definitely be back soon.“

“1/2 off on seafood I like that 😁“

“The service is great here, and this restaurant has been a staple in the family for year's. Also my waitress (Ivory) service was outstanding! Ivory was very thorough with everything.“

“I have been a fan of this place forever. If you love hotdogs, this is the spot for you. Foot long dogs on great rolls. You can have them plain or with the works. Worth a trip.

Parking: Can get busy at lunch but usually you can find a spot“

“Sunset Subs and Steaks is our favorite spot whenever we travel from New Jersey to Delaware. We always make it a point to stop here. They have the best cheesesteaks in town, packed with meat, cheese, and perfectly grilled.

This time, we decided to stop for breakfast. We ordered two egg and cheese wraps with mushrooms and our favorite sauce, Boom Boom. This sauce is a delicious mix of peppers and garlic that will take you straight to heaven if you like spicy flavors. The wraps were loaded with mushrooms, and the eggs were perfectly cooked and never dry.

Listening to the owner’s suggestions is always a good idea; he really knows what he’s talking about. We appreciate that everything is fresh, of high quality, and clearly made with love. This family-owned business is dedicated to serving the community’s needs, and it shows.

Sunset Subs and Steaks is definitely a place to visit whenever you’re in town!“

“The hot wings are spectacular, consistently extra crispy as ordered.“

“My husband and I have been here a few times for his pool League. The barmaid Shelly is very friendly. She was very helpful with recommendations from the menu. We've had the chicken cheese steak, chicken tenders, and hamburger. My favorite is the grilled chicken salad. It's generously sized and topped with an entire chicken breast. The chicken is very tender. The fries are delicious as well.*** They add a 3-4% (can't remember the exact amount) fee for credit card payments. They do not allow tips on credit cards. TIPS ARE CASH ONLY. Although this can be a bit of an inconvenience, we make sure to bring cash.

Wheelchair accessibility: There are no stairs“

“My sister and I were running around in Delaware with our kids and we decided it was time for lunch and relax. We stopped here for the first time and it was SUPPER. Our server, Marlon, was AMAZING! He remembered our 6 orders without any notes and he was supper attentive. He even made our kids feel great. Please stop by this location and ask for Marlon.“

“Too much phone talk. I watched a waitress look at me then turn away to her phone conversation.
Some people are funny that way I guess. Good thing she was not my waitress. I would not have tipped her. My waitress was good and the food was good. I'll be back.“