34 Best Sandwich Shops near New Castle

“Best meatball sandwich I have ever eaten!! Meatballs were so fresh“

“The New Castle Farmer's Market was one of those places early on I was eyeing to check out when I moved out to Delaware. This especially includes the whole wing that is Stoltzfus' different shops. For my first time here, I decided to have some breakfast as the market opened.
Being a sausage sandwich shop, I was definitely expecting some sort of breakfast offering. This is something they definitely offer in addition to a lunch menu. For that morning, I had their breakfast special which is a sausage with egg...and optionally cheese, onions and peppers...on a sausage roll, served with a hashbrown and drink for around $10. You can also choose between a mild sausage and a spicy one; given how hit-and-miss sausage can be for me, I stuck with mild.
The sausage was well-cooked, juicy and just about the right about of snap from the casing and the eggs were fluffy and fresh...but maybe needs a little bit of salt to taste. The roll does a great job holding up the sausage and fixings. The only shortfall was that the hashbrown was a little greasy and perhaps a little small for a side; won't hold it against them that much as hashbrowns aren't the easiest form of potato to keep grease-free.
There is a sitting area behind their stand behind Stoltzfus' bakery stand so you can sit and enjoy that sausage or their other fare including other breakfast dishes. The atmosphere...it's a Farmer's Market so I don’t over think it. It simple yet functional and feels like how a market stall should.
I might come by for their lunch menu sometime (which I believe is served from when the market opens except on Sunday when the Stoltzfus stalls are closed). But for breakfast, definitely give them a try. Pro tip: be sure to pick up a pint of juice from the nearby juice counter for breakfast.

Parking: As part of the New Castle Farmer's Market, there's a very big parking lot with plenty of spaces to park. This includes spaces for those physically challenged. The doors are also automatic so access is also not a problem.“

“They don't tell you this , they have two cheese steaks one that has better steak for about a dollar more and one with regular steak and if you have to say the better meat . Get drinks and chips at wawa and the store on rt40 seems to have better service and food. It's good food and today it's hard to find so enjoy yourself and get a Bobby!“

“Sabatina's knocked it out of the park for my husband's birthday. we ordered a couple of sandwich trays and chicken tenders and everything was fresh and outstanding! the ladies in the shop even helped my daughter and I carry our food down the street since it was DE City Day and Clinton Street was blocked off. We can't wait to order again!“

“The original and the best!“

“Great experience, excellent food, and the staff were very friendly. The owner also spent a few minutes speaking to us. A really nice guy. Awesome all the way around!!! ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️“

“Place is better then your regular Primos! They really seem to all Care and seem like they put heart into each hoagie!“

“Employees are very sweet. I usually place an order to go and it is immediately done! I once dropped a note and an employee followed me out to return it to me. Food is healthier than other places. Love the muffins. My go to is the Chihuahua which has chicken. The owners are great friends with my brother. Love the magnets and the Catholic references. Regardless of your background, this place is very welcoming and friendly.“

“I like to grab breakfast before work here when I'm in a rush. I often use delivery apps for pickup and their food is delicious and quick. I typically get a sausage egg and cheese bagel and maybe a muffin and all their ingredients are fresh nutrient dense. I do wish the prices would go down just slightly or if they offered smaller and less expensive portions, this is not something to have everyday. Highly recommend the golden retriever for a lunch option.“

“First walking in. I got the vibe that this is what an "Authentic" sandwich shop is supposed to be. Not super pretty and vibrant. But clean and about their business. Ordering was easy, and the cashier guided through my order. The sandwich was LOADED! I ordered the spicy Italian. Onion rings were... onion rings. So they were delicious as well. This is the type of place that I would frequent often if there was one here in the Atlanta surrounding areas.“

“This is by far the BEST cafe I’ve been to so far. Everything is a 10 for me especially their bagels, I haven’t been able to find a better one since I’ve tried their asiago bagel 😌 keep up the great work guys!!!“

“Terrible service and the food is even worse. The owners daughter is not at all professional at all. Very rude.“

“As much as I paid for a large ham sub this is what I got. PATHETIC! 2 slices of cheese and about 5 very thin ham slices. I could have made this myself for half the cost. I won’t be back for a sandwich again.“

“The Subs other then the Fresh Turkey Is Light On The Meat For Italian Sub. Pleasantville Countrymaid Beats Them On That. They Should Use Serpe’s Rolls They’re Always Fresh. Goodfellas Rolls Can Be Tough Which Means Stale. Owned A Bread Route for 30 years Couldn’t Leave Stale Bread On The Shelf“

“Great selection of sandwiches and soups, I just wish they had more soup sizes instead of just "decent, if a bit smallish" and "a week's supply". Other than that, it's my go to place for a quick soup. Prices are reasonable and service is fast.“

“It's hard to find a great team nowadays. Rude worker! However, I don't expect to spend $36 on my food and drive 23 mins for rudeness.

They missed an ingredient, and I didn't expect to be fact-checked in the manner I was as if I would lie about a pepper. After offering to go get my food out of the car, she continued to yell at the worker across the counter. She shoved 2 baby long hots in a side cup angrily.

Sorry, but it was offensive after I spent $36 on ONE sandwich, a bag of chips, and a drink. And the guy who made it said I doubt I put them in there. She then told me what sandwich I ordered, and I corrected her and said I ordered this with extras, so maybe you're confused. My food absolutely came with long hots. I've been eating the same thing for 20 years. ?

I use to FREQUENT this place, and they knew me. I'm the great tipper, especially around the holidays, because they were so nice! I miss the old crew!“

“We come down from Bucks County, Pa for your amazing subs! Love you guys! 😻“

“Turkey was dry so Bobbie was no good. Reached out to give them a chance to make it right and got radio silence. Plenty of other good sandwich shops in the area, skip capriottis.

Update: Owners reached out and resolved the issue. Will be back to give them another shot“

“I have been doing a job two half blocks away from Young's, therefore I have been in there quite a bit lately. For a corner store their food is pretty good and the kid behind the counter is friendly. It seems to be much cleaner than most other corner stores in Wilmington also.“

“The man who operates this location, atleast the one who was there today, was exceptional. Incredibly nice, and friendly. Actually sincerely asked how our day was going and even offered my son a free cookie when he didnt finish his pretzel. The world needs more people like this guy.“

“Boy try the scrambled egg sandwich ? in the morning hours before lunch. Tasty and cheap. I might have to go there tomorrow morning come to think of it.

Parking: Parking on Hutton street where I did some asbestos cleanup abatement a couple months back is also an option.“

“We go there often, I get my Big Kahuna and wife gets her sub in a tub.. Workers behind the counter are very friendly and attentive. Keep up the good work!“

“Second time I purchased a burger @ Stu & Sammy’s and it was literally raw….. I ended up ONCE AGAIN wasting $10 because I couldn’t eat it and couldn’t take it back because my lunch hour was up.“

“The place is feeling a little unkept. The food is still delicious, but I felt like place could close any day now. We need changing America. This administration is going to destroy small businesses in America. I pray for change and getting back to providing for the legal citizens of this great country. We've lost our way. 4 more years of this administration will end it for so many of us.

Wheelchair accessibility: Wheel chair accessible doors.“

“The "Sandwich Artests" were great my sandwich was well done and was not soggy by the time I got to eating it which is a big problem from time to time with subways. The location is very small in a very small truck stop and as such if there are more then 2 people in line it gets a little hectic.“

“i love jimmy johns so much. i always order 16" #6's. a little sad my phone's service fies in there,but gosh. also shout-out to Cheryl, or Sherry? Cherilee? oh gosh im so sorry ? i suck with names but you're the bomb. thank you so much for the paper plates and getting something out of my hair :3 you rockalso it's nice on others to recognize me and get the usual too c:

Vegetarian options: the #6 veggie. i usually ask for no cheese and no mayo too“

“This place is great! We love the great banter between the employees! I have no idea why there are comments on here about employees being rude. I can’t wait for them to open up indoor dining! We went to the one on 202. The place is nice, but the staff there has a lot to learn from the people on Silverside!!! We will continue to go to the Silverside location, as their staff is great!!! If people can’t have a bit of fun at work, then it isn’t a great place to work. The staff there is always busy. Give them a break.“

“I left a negative review of the Newark location because the staff are just brain dead college kids but I've always loved Capriotti's. It's just part of living in Delaware, for whatever that's worth. This location had a few weeks where it was touch and go about half a year ago (looks like the reviews reflect that as well, quite a few disgruntled remarks), they'd be closed at odd hours and some of their staff were questionable to put it politely, but it looks like they've turned it around since then. If one of these places has the staff it needs, then it's worth going to. It's really a matter of knowing what's going on in what location. This place seems like it's up and running efficiently again so hopefully they keep it that way.I hardly ever have a problem with this place at least when it's actually open.“

“Love! My favorite is the bacon 3 cheese and every time I order it, it’s perfect. Every now and then I get the bacon cheese fries and they are a true guilt pleasure. Also the customer service is great never had an issue. Very friendly. Awesome food“

“This place is AMAZING! The young man that greeted me suggested & sandwich that turned out to be quite tasty. I stopped to grab a quick bite & met the most nicest people working at Jimmy’s! It was such a pleasant experience & I even met Jimmy himself (see pic). The prices are great, the food is great & the owner & employees just burst with positive vibes! This is definitely one of my favorite places on market st. You may just catch me outside of Jimmy’s with my guitar & a sandwich. 15 Star ⭐️ place!!!“

“Really good experience every time we order here, nice staff and excellent food! Order is always ready within 2 minutes of the pickup time.

Vegetarian options: Some vegetarian options.

Parking: Loads of parking spots.

Kid-friendliness: Staff is nice to kids.

Wheelchair accessibility: Wheelchair accessible“

“Love going here. Service is always super quick. Staff might actually be mind readers because they know exactly what I am going to order depending on the weather. It's really nice to go someplace where they always remember your name. Never had a bad meal here“