30 Best Sandwich Shops near New Castle

“I’ve been looking for a good sausage and pepper sub and have tried probably every pizzeria within a 10 mile radius. This was hands down the best sausage and pepper sub I’ve had in a long time. Oh and they put marinara sauce on it to! Mmm Good 😋“

“Best meatball sandwich I have ever eaten!! Meatballs were so fresh“

“There are not too many places in Delaware that does a hoagie right. This place is a go-to for game day or any time you want a delicious hoagie. They are nice folks and courteous. Standing room only. Get in, order, wait 10 minutes and get out!“

“Sabatina's knocked it out of the park for my husband's birthday. we ordered a couple of sandwich trays and chicken tenders and everything was fresh and outstanding! the ladies in the shop even helped my daughter and I carry our food down the street since it was DE City Day and Clinton Street was blocked off. We can't wait to order again!“

“The original and the best!“

“Terrible service and the food is even worse. The owners daughter is not at all professional at all. Very rude.“

“Food was 2 sandwhiches, 2 bags of chips, and a banana foster muffin. Sandwhiches were very good & worth the money. Think Panera prices (I think, haven't been in a bit), but the food is actually good and not hospital food.

The bananas foster muffin was amazing & makes me wish I lived closer!“

“Great experience, excellent food, and the staff were very friendly. The owner also spent a few minutes speaking to us. A really nice guy. Awesome all the way around!!! ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️“

“This was my first time eating at Cava and the person who made my order Yoselin did an amazing job! She gave me exactly what i wanted and was so polite to me. Her service at Cava was 10/10! She even offered to help me choose something to get since it was my first time and her patience with me was nice of her as I didn’t know what to get at first. The food was also a 10/10, the chicken was really tasty and so were the fresh pita chips that i got. Cava is going to be now my first choice when it comes to eating out Thanks to Yoselin!“

“I was in the area for an appointment and got hungry so I went looking s d found PureBreads Deli. It is so cute and comfortable . The staff were very helpful regarding food allergy questions. Whuke i was there an okder gentleman came in and rhe greetes him by his name and said you want your normal..... They care about their customers. They have a contest to design a magnetic for them. You should check it out whether you eat in or take it out it's a definite place to try.
I got the BLT with Avacado.❤️“

“I absolutely love the vibe of this place. It has a timeless, old-school charm that feels like stepping back a few decades. The seating isn’t fancy and the artwork on the walls hasn’t changed in years, which gives it a nostalgic, slightly run-down feel, but in the best way possible. This is a place that Anthony Bourdain would consider a classic American lunch spot.

Everything about this restaurant matches that character: the food is classic, comforting, and consistently delicious; the staff are friendly and genuine, making the experience even better. I’ve beenq here multiple times now and it’s become my go-to lunch spot. So far, I haven’t been disappointed and I don’t expect to be any time soon!“

“Purchased an Italian Diablo & some potato salad. Both were very good. I have been having a little trouble finding a convenient nearby sub shop, gave Primo a try and it worked out well. I really appreciate the ability to order & pay on line. You can request a pick up time when ordering which is also very convenient.“

“Place is better then your regular Primos! They really seem to all Care and seem like they put heart into each hoagie!“

“This is by far the BEST cafe I’ve been to so far. Everything is a 10 for me especially their bagels, I haven’t been able to find a better one since I’ve tried their asiago bagel 😌 keep up the great work guys!!!“

“The Subs other then the Fresh Turkey Is Light On The Meat For Italian Sub. Pleasantville Countrymaid Beats Them On That. They Should Use Serpe’s Rolls They’re Always Fresh. Goodfellas Rolls Can Be Tough Which Means Stale. Owned A Bread Route for 30 years Couldn’t Leave Stale Bread On The Shelf“

“Great selection of sandwiches and soups, I just wish they had more soup sizes instead of just "decent, if a bit smallish" and "a week's supply". Other than that, it's my go to place for a quick soup. Prices are reasonable and service is fast.“

“This place is great! We love the great banter between the employees! I have no idea why there are comments on here about employees being rude. I can’t wait for them to open up indoor dining! We went to the one on 202. The place is nice, but the staff there has a lot to learn from the people on Silverside!!! We will continue to go to the Silverside location, as their staff is great!!! If people can’t have a bit of fun at work, then it isn’t a great place to work. The staff there is always busy. Give them a break.“

“The man who operates this location, atleast the one who was there today, was exceptional. Incredibly nice, and friendly. Actually sincerely asked how our day was going and even offered my son a free cookie when he didnt finish his pretzel. The world needs more people like this guy.“

“Boy try the scrambled egg sandwich ? in the morning hours before lunch. Tasty and cheap. I might have to go there tomorrow morning come to think of it.

Parking: Parking on Hutton street where I did some asbestos cleanup abatement a couple months back is also an option.“

“Purchased two Italian Subs on Tuesday. They were fantastic. Received everything we asked for . All products were fresh. Highly recommend.“

“This place is AMAZING! The young man that greeted me suggested & sandwich that turned out to be quite tasty. I stopped to grab a quick bite & met the most nicest people working at Jimmy’s! It was such a pleasant experience & I even met Jimmy himself (see pic). The prices are great, the food is great & the owner & employees just burst with positive vibes! This is definitely one of my favorite places on market st. You may just catch me outside of Jimmy’s with my guitar & a sandwich. 15 Star ⭐️ place!!!“

“Great place for sandwiches! Hoagies are really good! They make cheesesteaks. Wings. Burgers. Fries. They also cater. Staff is friendly and welcoming. There’s indoor seating. You don’t have to wait long for your food. I had an Italian hoagie. Wife had home style Turkey Hoagie“

“Love going here. Service is always super quick. Staff might actually be mind readers because they know exactly what I am going to order depending on the weather. It's really nice to go someplace where they always remember your name. Never had a bad meal here“

“I have been doing a job two half blocks away from Young's, therefore I have been in there quite a bit lately. For a corner store their food is pretty good and the kid behind the counter is friendly. It seems to be much cleaner than most other corner stores in Wilmington also.“

“I left a negative review of the Newark location because the staff are just brain dead college kids but I've always loved Capriotti's. It's just part of living in Delaware, for whatever that's worth. This location had a few weeks where it was touch and go about half a year ago (looks like the reviews reflect that as well, quite a few disgruntled remarks), they'd be closed at odd hours and some of their staff were questionable to put it politely, but it looks like they've turned it around since then. If one of these places has the staff it needs, then it's worth going to. It's really a matter of knowing what's going on in what location. This place seems like it's up and running efficiently again so hopefully they keep it that way.I hardly ever have a problem with this place at least when it's actually open.“

“i love jimmy johns so much. i always order 16" #6's. a little sad my phone's service fies in there,but gosh. also shout-out to Cheryl, or Sherry? Cherilee? oh gosh im so sorry ? i suck with names but you're the bomb. thank you so much for the paper plates and getting something out of my hair :3 you rockalso it's nice on others to recognize me and get the usual too c:

Vegetarian options: the #6 veggie. i usually ask for no cheese and no mayo too“

“We go there often, I get my Big Kahuna and wife gets her sub in a tub.. Workers behind the counter are very friendly and attentive. Keep up the good work!“

“We come down from Bucks County, Pa for your amazing subs! Love you guys! 😻“

“Really good experience every time we order here, nice staff and excellent food! Order is always ready within 2 minutes of the pickup time.

Vegetarian options: Some vegetarian options.

Parking: Loads of parking spots.

Kid-friendliness: Staff is nice to kids.

Wheelchair accessibility: Wheelchair accessible“