31 Best Seafood Restaurants near New Castle

“Superb seafood. The quality of this establishment is unmatched in the area. And the staff? The best, they go beyond service and treat you like family. Everyone there wants you to have a great meal/time and it shows. I am thankful that they are here when the seafood cravings hit!!!!! Much love Lestardos!“

“I ordered a snow crab steam pot and added jumbo shrimp. Everything was really good. 😋“

“Nice place, We always drive from an hour away for the excellent food! We love snack Mondays, karaoke is a plus in the atmosphere which is very good, we had a great time. The drinks are very good (we love the tamarind margarita) and the service, not to mention, we were served by the Colombian who wears braids, a very good representative, everything was impeccable.“

“great little place to hang out to watch the game! Great food and service! And cold beer!!“

“I just wanted to take a second to say the wings at this location are the best I ever had! Just the right amount of sauce and nice and crispy just how I like them.! Mohammad Eusuf who was at the front desk when I arrived . He was so nice and pleasant and actually cared I had such a long day. I really appreciate this store for providing great customer service and great wings! Thank you so much !“

“Best food ever. Everything was fresh. Service was great and with a smile. Loved the live Jazz to! Will definitely be back soon.“

“This is my second time going to this restaurant and I’m never disappointed. The food is fresh tasty so good drinks follow along right with it waitresses very patient and very nice. I recommend going. They have nice specials every day of the week.“

“😋😋😋🤗🤗🤗🤗buenísima comida...“

“When my company arrived from Kansas and Indiana in April, I took them to Crabby Dick's in Delaware City and they absolutely loved it! They especially enjoyed the crab cakes and Maryland Crab soup. I got my usual favorite, steamed clams! Our server's name was either Mattie or Maddie. Not sure of the spelling, but she was outstanding. We were there on April 22nd.“

“My first time at Gus's Crab Shack was back in December of 2021 when a band that i represent was hired by Gus to entertain his guests. Since that time, we have been a regular part of his entertainment lineup. What started as a spot at the back wall turned into a stage being built for all bands to play on and then with a new huge stage outside under a tent and then again, he added yet another stage outside under another tent. He started with just two bands a weekend and now has up to 5 bands a weekend. he has pulled out all stops in providing the best entertainment that he can for his patrons. As far as the food and service are concerned, we have no complaints. We always get what we ordered in a timely manner. The food is served hot, and beverages are ice cold. If we had any problem with an order, the staff makes it right very quickly. Gus, the owner makes it a habit to go around to meet his guest to see how they are doing and if everything is all right. We highly recommend Gus's Crab Shack. The staff is very courteous and friendly.“

“😍Tucked just off the road like a well-kept secret, Snuff Mill Steakhouse & Butchery is a revelation—a celebration of fine dining wrapped in the warmth of a neighborhood favorite. Step inside, and you’re greeted by a cozy, intimate interior that feels both polished and personal. High tables, rich wood tones, and a welcoming bar set the tone. And just to the left of the entrance, a gleaming meat case—like a culinary altar—builds anticipation with its marble-cut promise of things to come. Whimsy lives here too, from the surprise artworks to the playful presence of pigs in unexpected places (don’t miss the one keeping watch near the door). The wine list? Impeccably curated, with a focus on hand-selected bottles that beg to be explored. Cocktails are more than drinks—they’re small works of art, mixed with precision by bartenders who clearly care. Then there’s Bill Irvin—proprietor, oyster whisperer, and front-of-house magician. A certified oyster expert, Bill pairs briny beauties with grace and authority. The chef and kitchen brigade bring French-influenced finesse to every plate, sourcing only the finest local ingredients. The results? Steaks seared to sublime, seafood that sings, and appetizers that linger on the palate like a good memory. The in-house pastry chef seals the deal—so save room. The desserts are nothing short of transportive. Snuff Mill is more than a meal; it’s a destination. Guests travel from near and far, and once you’ve experienced it, you’ll understand why.“

“What an awesome server Joey was!!!! So attentive, So friendly. The manager on duty was great and the food was amazing 🤗🤗OVERALL AWESOME EXPERIENCE“

“My family and I were visiting from out of state and looking for fried fish. This place was perfect! The fish was so good and for me, it was more than the seasoning. The pieces were big and had the right amount of crunch. Loved it!

Vegetarian options: All sides are beef and pork free.“

“Cam n Noah just wonderful order crabs every weekend always awesome“

“Endless Shrimps was delicious. My grandson loved it. The waiter was extremely nice“

“Best seafood and portions are large. Tommy is great!“

“Caitlin is awesome!killed the service and wonderful time“

“Great homemade food. Crab cakes were exceptional. No filler. Service was great. Made you feel like you were welcomed. I recommend.“

“Great food. Excellent service.“

“Work across the street for 15+yrs & have been patronizing this establishment ever since… Food & service have always been excellent! We like breakfast best, even if it’s lunchtime. Have placed up to 10 orders for staff & everything was perfect. Hidden gem in the city. Never been disappointed & prices are reasonable.“

“Excellent cioppino and clam chow chowder! Our waitress suggested which oysters to get and they did not disappoint! Fantastic service! We’ll be back👍🏼🦞🍤😋“

“I love this seafood spot the owner is so friendly 💖💖 see you soon“

“First time ordering from here tonight and we WILL BE BACK… like a lot. We live in pike creek and will make the drive. We got the red beans and rice, gumbo and tomato soup and we need to try the rest of the menu! My husband and I just got back from New Orleans and my husband was sad because he loved the food so I googled and found this place! The gumbo was literally better than we had down there 😍 SO GOOD. And everyone working when I picked up (one was the owners daughter) were so passionate about how they make everything from scratch and kept giving me samples of everything and telling me their story. It’s a WONDERFUL locally owned place that should be protected at all costs. Cannot recommend enough!“

“Feby’s has the most delicious seafood. Always fresh and never disappoints.“

“I have been there 4 times already I absolutely love this place . I get the cinnamon french toast oh my goodness it is so good. I could not put my fork down . Everything was excellent!!! My new breakfast and lunch spot!!!❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️“

“I enjoyed the blue crabs I got from here. Upon ordering we were asked if we would like to add beer as an ingredient and we said yes. This gave the crabs more flavor and made them very juicy. They have a hot or mild seasoning to choose from. The hot is spicy so be careful. Adding butter garlic is an extra charge. We also tried the Cajun crab sliders. They were a bit too spicy for us, but tasted good. All forms of payment accepted.“

“I’ve only had wings from here but they are always fresh,hot, XHARD as I prefer upon ordering wings aren’t scary big, meat is white & clean I typically order lemon pepper but I’ve tried other flavors this is my fav ?combo 10 wings fries and soda for 14.99“

“If you like sushi and also enjoy Chipotle or El Diablo, you will LOVE this ??️
I would eat 3 bowls a day if I made twice as much as I do and the element mercury didn’t exist ?️
Poke Bros. is quintessential poké.
If you’ve had it once you’ll get the same exact experience here.
Is it healthy? It can be ❤️
Could it be 900+ calories? Absolutely ?
Good staff, great food… I just wish the serving sizes were much bigger!“

“We recently hosted a bridal shower at Bahama Breeze in Newark, DE, and it was an outstanding experience from start to finish. Our servers, Shannon and Emma, were incredibly attentive and resourceful—every dish for our group of nearly 20 guests was perfectly prepared and served without delay.

A very special thanks to General Manager, Mike Links, who went above and beyond to accommodate last-minute arrangements and ensure the bride’s day was perfect. He personally checked in with us, made everything seamless, and even took a beautiful group photo of our entire party—such a thoughtful touch that meant so much.

Thanks to Mike, Shannon, Emma, and the entire Bahama Breeze team, the event was stress-free, joyful, and truly unforgettable. We are deeply grateful and highly recommend this location for any special occasion!“

“Amazing! We had the BEST server ever. Michael was friendly, funny and so attentive! My fiancé and I had the greatest first time here. We 100% recommend and will be back!“