7 Best Sandwich Shops in Newark

“Food was 2 sandwhiches, 2 bags of chips, and a banana foster muffin. Sandwhiches were very good & worth the money. Think Panera prices (I think, haven't been in a bit), but the food is actually good and not hospital food.

The bananas foster muffin was amazing & makes me wish I lived closer!“

“I could have not asked for a better team today (8/9/25) at this location. Currently on a bus tour when our tour guide decided this was the place to stop. Dropping 50 plus people on a group of 4 employees. But let me tell ya, you never would have known that there was only 4 employees here. They took charge with a positive attitude and produced 50 plus subs in no time!!! The young lady was memorizing orders while the gentleman were all working in tandem. Needless to say, I am impressed and I am writing this to say those 4 employees need a raise. They took what could have been a less than fortunate situation and maybe it an absolute spectacular show of peak team work performance.“

“I have to disclose it was a free chips for a review but offered to all! I have come a few times to this new location for lunch and it has been very good. Every time it has a full staff who now recognize me. I have the turkey mini or regular size Mike's way on the toppings and I add the cherry pepper relish. I hope I only ever get this CPR! I walk usually but there is lots of parking. Easier to navigate than the Christiana Mall location which I have not gone to much because it is a hassle especially on the weekend. I like Zoup and Capriotti's as well but the Capriotti's on Main is always slow so this store will pick up more bizz from me. I'll be around!“

“Just pick up two bobby subs. Very good!!!“

“⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

Outstanding service and genuine appreciation for their customers!

Our office was truly touched by the kindness shown by Jimmy John’s. Sherry went out of her way to bring lunch to our whole office as a thank-you to one of our employees who faithfully purchases lunch from them almost daily. That kind of thoughtfulness is rare and speaks volumes about how much they value their customers.

Not only is the food consistently fresh and delicious, but the people behind the scenes clearly care about building real relationships in the community. This gesture didn’t go unnoticed and made our entire office feel appreciated.

Thank you, Sherry and the Jimmy John’s team, for going above and beyond. We will absolutely continue to support and recommend your business!“

“Good quality subs and steaks....They've never been loaded or skimpy, but fair....they seemed to of stayed with the same quality and quantity, just prices have really climbed. Of course, that's no fault of theirs. I would actually prefer that the product stays consistent and not shrink or use an inferior meat for the illusion that we're not all dealing with inflation. Casapulla's was known for good quality sandwiches, I'm glad they recognize their niche, we just need to adjust to the reality of that costs more.

I'd also like to include, I've never been there (50 years between Elsmere and Glasgow) and gotten bad service. The staff is always courteous and probably batting .999 on the order being complete and correct. Unheard of in this day and age.“