50 Best Italian Restaurants near Bay Lake

“Good food! Nice staff. Pizza and chicken parmigiana absolutely delicious“

“Absolutely wonderful, fine dining Italian dinner at Epcot! It’s a gorgeous and classy dining room with incredibly kind and gracious hosts who checked us in and then led us to our table. Gian Marco was our very nice server who took great care of us. We started with good rolls dipped in olive oil, bread sticks, and the fried calimari appetizer. The squid rings were the most tender and tastiest we’ve ever had. For dinner, my wife had the Italian “surf and turf”, Mare e Monti, which was a delicious braised beef short rib and lobster ravioli. I had the Salmone, which was a nice piece of grilled salmon served atop mashed potatoes over diced tomatoes, capers, olives and anchovies. It was fantastic! We finished this gourmet meal with the tastiest Tiramisu and a Cannolo. The perfect end to a perfect meal. We spoke with Sarah, one of the managers, and she explained that much of the staff are actually from Italy and are working here and gaining experience at a resort style restaurant. They all work together to provide the hospitality and dining experience that must be savored and celebrated!“

“Sam (our server) and Angeline (our Sommelier), along with a very nice young man (been there about 8 months) who brought us in (sorry I didn’t catch his name) made sure we wanted for nothing. We asked for suggestions and they delivered all the way through dessert!! Professional, engaging, and genuinely nice people! Oh, and the food!!!!“

“excellent service!!!! very good food“

“Amazing service! The staff is outstanding. We got in early and were able to check in early! They were extremely helpful with our bags and even provided a pack and play for our son. Every day we’d come back to our room with clean beds and towels and they’d even set up all of my daughter’s toys and she thought it was the greatest thing ever. Check out was a breeze! They definitely played a very large part in the success of our trip!“

“We had a wonderful dinner on Saturday night, and our server, Carmelo, truly made the experience exceptional. He offered excellent menu recommendations, was attentive throughout the meal, and stayed on top of everything without ever making us feel rushed. His friendly, professional service really stood out and made our evening enjoyable.
My only complaint has nothing to do with the service. The restaurant felt much more crowded and stuffy than on previous visits, and the tables seemed to be placed much closer together, which made the atmosphere feel less comfortable and a bit noisy. Also in the past I could bring in my son's stroller, this time I wasn't allowed. This was a huge inconvenience as my son wasn't able to lay down when he had fallen asleep.

Overall, we'd definitely return, especially knowing we'd be in such great hands with Carmelo!“

“We are from Lakeland and always drive up here to enjoy the food and atmosphere. Our waiter Moe this evening was very nice and Ethan, the host, was also kind and great to talk to. The food here is delicious and the people are nice. We got the 4 for $40 deal which is an amazing promotion going on for the summer. I highly recommend this place! Shoutout to both Moe and Ethan! Definitely tell Moe I say dankje, which is thank you in Dutch. We will be back soon.“

“Big rave to this restaurant. An honest mistake was made and a few items were missing from our Uber Eats delivery. I contacted the restaurant and they immediately admitted to the error. Their asst manager personally drove the missing items directly to our hotel and even threw in some free dessert! They went over and above to quickly address and fix the issues! Would highly recommend them and the food was great.“

“We always enjoy lunch at this I-Drive location. The food is delicious and May, our server, is always amazing. May is extremely attentive and personable. Good job Carrabbas and May! Can’t wait to go back.“

“Food and service was wonderful! You have to try the cannoli! 10/10 recommend“

“We came rolling into Orlando after a long day of traveling! We were all very hungry for some good pizza! V Pizza did not disappoint us! Our 13 year old granddaughter kept saying it was some of the best pizza she'd ever eaten! As previous owners of a pizza restaurant, we thought our pizzas were pretty amazing! The staff was very friendly and eager to serve us. The restaurant was clean and had very modern decor. We will probably go back before returning home!“

“Great food and great service“

“Visited Orlando for the weekend golfing at Bay Hill. Fresco's was recommended by the folks at the Lodge. Glad we stopped in for dinner. The food is excellent. It will be my goto on future Orlando visits.“

“I recently had the pleasure of dining at Maggiano's Little Italy in Orlando on International Drive and it was an experience worth sharing. From the moment we walked in, we were greeted warmly by the hostess, who promptly seated us at a cozy table that perfectly set the tone for the evening. The waitstaff was exceptional—attentive, friendly, and knowledgeable. They made sure our glasses were never empty and checked in just the right amount to ensure we had everything we needed without being intrusive. For the main course, we chose the Chicken Parmesan, which was cooked to perfection with a crispy exterior and tender, juicy chicken inside. The pasta was al dente, and the meat sauce was rich and savory. It was really enough for two people to share. To top it all off, they brought two plates of their famous lemon cookies to our table, to celebrate our third anniversary. Overall, our experience at Maggiano's was nothing short of excellent. The combination of outstanding service, a welcoming atmosphere, and delicious food made for a memorable evening. I highly recommend Maggiano's for anyone looking to enjoy a wonderful Italian meal with top-notch service.“

“Blue Capri was a fantastic first experience for my family and me. From the moment we walked in, we felt genuinely welcomed. The restaurant has a beautiful, authentic Italian atmosphere - intimate, tastefully decorated, and completely immersive.

The food was exceptional. Everything tasted incredibly fresh, full of flavor, and was presented beautifully. The cocktails were equally impressive and complemented the meal perfectly.

Authentic Italian cuisine, exceptional service, and a wonderful atmosphere. We will definitely be back and highly recommend Blue Capri.“

“Amazing food and service! I real gem to have here in Windermere!“

“I would recommend this restaurant to anyone visiting Florida and I was informed that this is the only one left within the United States. The waiters and greeter were phenomenal and the service was exquisite. I had the shrimp scampi and my guest had the chicken parmegian of which had an amazing taste and blend of flavor. WE WIL BE BACK!“

“We ordered the calzones and they were very big. Definitely enough to share. The food was great and the staff was really friendly. The woman working the front area was so nice. She gave us a couple of cannolis for free and they were so good. They pipe them when you order so the shell is nice and crunchy.“

“My husband and I ate here tonight. The service was superb, the food was delicious and authentic, the atmosphere was very welcoming. The best lasagna I’ve ever eaten! The drinks and appetizers were delicious. Our server was very helpful. We hope to come back on our trip this time, but certainly will come back the next trip. Highly recommend“

“My favorite restaurant in Winter Garden. Decided to do Italian for Thanksgiving and it was outstanding. My favorite is their Pork Osso Bucco and they did not disappoint. Service and owners are always on point. Thank you for enjoying my first Thanksgiving being waited on. Always recommend this place, never a bad meal. Thank you Dorina“

“This was our best ever experience at Olive Garden. The food was great and service was amazing. We got seated quickly, the server was very friendly and attentive. We were visiting my son and we live about an hour away and he has always liked Olive Garden so we decided to go since it was close to home. This was our first time at this location. Honestly other locations near us have not been as good when we have tried them over the last few years. If they were like this location I would probably put Olive Garden back in my restaurant rotation.“

“They Best italiano fotos I loved si good“

“Huge RAVE for La Piccolina - Winter Garden. We went to celebrate my father’s birthday and everything was wonderful. The food was delicious, so flavorful and generous portions! On top of our delicious meals the service was excellent! They went above and beyond, surprised my daughter with a fun make her own pizza, which was so fun and a sweet surprise. This place is authentic and caters to hospitality! Thank you for making our dining experience so wonderful! We can’t wait to come back.“

“The staff was great with accommodating our whole family. Very friendly and outstanding service. The restaurant is beautiful inside. If I ever vacation this way again, I will be back.“

“Food was excellent, the atmosphere was warm and inviting, and the overall service was exceptional. Our server, Raul, was amazing—attentive, friendly, and made sure we had everything we needed. He truly made our dining experience even better. Highly recommend!“

“A truly delightful establishment.
Excellent cuisine and wonderful service, all set within a calm, home-like atmosphere.
The friendly staff—attentive to their guests at every moment—made our visit to the restaurant a truly pleasant experience; we simply didn't want to leave.
The Calabrian Steak & Shrimp Bucatini* was fantastic!
A special thank you goes to our waitress, Natasha!
We celebrated our golden wedding anniversary here—a modest affair, perhaps, but one of impeccable quality.
We look forward to seeing you again soon.“

“The food is amazing.The bartenders are friendly and efficient. My friends and I try to go at least once a month for happy hour .“

“Visiting Disney and needed a night in to rest —- great menu - delicious, hot and fresh food. Lots of vegetarian options. Great pizza and tasty sauce! Look forward to trying more next time we visit.“

“we had the soup and salad deal for 11 dollars and both were very nice, we also brought a chicken alferno and pasta and took it away for dinner and that was also very nice, the service was very good and it was nice and quiet , i would recommend it and will come again when i next visit.“

“My boyfriend and I came here for a date night, and everything was amazing! The food was delicious, the service was fast, and everyone was professional and welcoming. I believe our server’s name was Mery, and she was absolutely wonderful. She was friendly, funny, attentive, and very professional. She made our experience even better. We’ll definitely be coming back! ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️“

“This is one of the best Olive Garden locations I’ve visited. It was incredibly convenient being right across the street from my hotel, but what really kept me coming back was the exceptional team.

The service was consistently on point, and the food arrived at lightning speed every single visit. The staff was friendly, attentive, and made me feel welcome from the moment I walked in.

Leadership should take note—this is a great example of a thriving restaurant that’s doing things right. The team clearly takes pride in delivering an outstanding guest experience.

I ended up dining here every day during my trip because the service was just that good. Great food, great people, and a well-run operation. This will continue to be my go-to spot whenever I’m staying in the area. Keep up the fantastic work!“

“The atmosphere was very lively with many booths and tables to choose from. Menu has everything from pizzas to sandwiches. Our waiter was very prompt and courteous with a smile on his face. Portion sizes are very good!“

“I won a trip for 4 people To The Universal Orlando Resort in Oct of 2005 we were there right before Halloween 🎃 and we went to Mama Della's Ristorante for lunch the food was amazing and we met Mama Della herself and she was very , very sweet.

Love always
Lisa Roshak from Marquette Michigan“

“The Stuffed Veal Chop is to die for. Excellent food and service. Our waiter was super nice. Forgot his name.“

“Really good Pizza, location could use an update.“

“We had our first experience dining at Cala Bella while staying at Shingle Creek in Orlando — and it was absolutely incredible! Although the restaurant was bustling, they kindly found us seats at the bar, where we had a front-row view of the kitchen. It was such a treat to watch Chef Kermary put the final touches on each dish with care and precision. Our server, Enidsha, was warm, attentive, and perfectly timed with everything. Manager Austin set the bar high with his professionalism and presence throughout the evening. But the true highlight of our evening was watching one of the cooks, Ante, work his magic on the grill. He noticed our interest and went out of his way to come chat with us. When we told him how much we enjoyed watching him prepare the octopus — and how we couldn’t wait to try it next time — he said, “Why wait?” Minutes later, we were savoring one of the best octopus dishes we’ve ever had. Sooo good! Huge thanks to the entire Cala Bella team for an unforgettable dining experience. We’ll definitely be back!“

“Delicious food and amazing service !!“

“Very good food , great service . Had gnocchi, veal Marsala and chicken special . Meal comes with garlics knots and a salad . Nice to meet Vito but I still miss Bruno“

“Osteria is really an excellent restaurant. To me, excellent cuisine is all about the flavor. And the combination of flavors, yet without compromising the distinct flavors of the herbs and spices used, is a highpoint of this establishment. Today, for lunch, we enjoyed the tomato basil and cream of mushroom soups. The tomato basil was hearty and impeccably seasoned. The cream of mushroom was not overly rich and chock full of mushrooms--incredible. The soups, paired with the Osteria house salad made for a perfect lunch. Our sons opted for the classic Margherita pizza. Their comment, "to die for!" Finally, I will not patronize a place if they act as though I am doing them a favor by patronizing their restaurant (or whatever). Quite the opposite at Osteria. From the owner, Steve (who we met 2 years ago, to the wait associate (Kevin) today, all are both gracious as well as exceedingly responsive to any request. If you wish a delicious meal, within the context of a casual, albeit very nice setting, Osteria is worthy of consideration. This has and will remain a go-to destination for our family whenever visiting Reunion Resort and the Champions Gate area!“

“This is a wonderful new spot and very welcome to the neighborhood. The food, management, and wait staff are top-notch!“

“Amazing setting, music, and food. Everything is very presentable, and fresh.“

“Tonight was our first time eating here. I love how close by it is to where we live. We split an "Antipasto" salad and ordered a 16" "Mediterranean Chicken" pizza. The place was not busy in-house, but they were dealing with a good number of takeout orders. The pizza and salad came out quickly. The pizza was "oven hot", but eating the salad first allowed it to cool a bit. Excellent pizza... thin crust that had a nice chewy texture without being tough. They told us that the crust is "aged" for 72 hours after being mixed to develop flavor. Toppings were freshly prepared and tasty. Our pizza had a pesto base... really good. Very happy with our meal here... we'll definitely be back!!“

“Peperoncino’s was absolutely amazing! The menu offered such a fantastic variety, and every dish was cooked to perfection. The desserts were a true delight, and the service couldn’t have been better. Our server, Daniel, was a joy—his menu descriptions were spot on and made the experience even more enjoyable. We can’t wait to come back, and I highly recommend you visit too!“

“We ordered the fig prosciutto pizza and it was delicious!! Also ordered the pork, veal, beef, Bolognese. So yummy and very meaty! The portions were a big size. My daughter-in-law and I shared our Bolognese, and we also shared our pizza. I gave it 4 stars for value/ price because I think all restaurants are overpriced these days! 🤣 Actually we loved the food.“

“Piesanos provided pizza and delivered it to our church for a youth event recently. They were super friendly and the pizza was a huge hit with our teens! Thank you for the awesome service and delicious food!“

“Can’t believe this hidden Jem was right under our noses all the time!! Highly recommend this truck!!! Food excellent! Staff is awesome!!! Can’t find this good anywhere in Orlando !“

“Best dinner and breakfast!“

“Amazing, great food, love the ambiance!“

“That was my first visit here. The food was amazing to the point that I ate something that I usually don't eat, and I finished everything. The servers were very attentive in the food was very well seasoned and portioned. My mother was happy for her Mother's Day, we will be back!!!“

“My family enjoy eating at, I love new york pizza“