8 Best Italian Restaurants near Winter Garden

Simply Capri Italian • $$
Flamingo Crossings, 114 Ruby Red Pl, Winter Garden

Customers` Favorites

Burrata with Sun Dried Tomatoes
Spaghetti a La Carbonara Di Mare
Scialatielli Dei Faraglioni
Schiaparelli Dei Faraglioni
Polipo Grigliato Octopus
Spaghetti and Meatballs
Limoncello Cake Dessert
Spaghetti Con Polpette
Frittura Di Paranza
Caccavella Caprese

“Food: I would give the food 3.75 stars, there was more to be desired. Since this restaurant's claim is for authentic Italian food, my hopes were high. The sauce was very scarce with the seafood pasta and it was a little too 'al dente'. It was good, but I do think there is better Italian in the area. Would go back - going to try the pizza next time. Cocktails and mocktails were fantastic. Service: Service was good. Very polite and attentive. We had two servers which was interesting. Ambiance/ Atmosphere: Loved the decor and vibe in the restaurant. They had a good amount of indoor and outdoor seating. Would be a good place to go for drinks and an appetizer.“

4.6 Superb235 Reviews
BELLA Italia Ristorante Italian • $$
13848 Tilden Rd #192, Winter Garden

Customers` Favorites

Bruschetta Al Pomodoro
Frango à Parmegiana
Flatbread Alla Bella
Fettuccine Alfredo
Chicken Parmigiana
Eggplant Rollatini
Mozzarella Fritti
Chicken Marsala
Chicken Piccata
Calamari Fritti

“Exceptional authentic Italian food, great service, and nice and clean inside. The booth seats were uncomfortable so try to avoid those. I tried squid ink for the first time in my life and I enjoyed it! Definitely try the mushroom appetizer.“

4.7 Superb112 Reviews
MANGONI Italian Market Pizza Pizza • $$
251 Tremaine St, Winter Garden

Customers` Favorites

Pepperoni Pizza with Sausage Topping
Prosciutto and Fig Pizza
Salad Balsamic Dressing
Mangoni Brisket Pizza
Craft Your Own Pizza
Ensalada de la Casa
Caprese Flatbread
Charcuterie Board
BBQ Chicken Pizza
The Mangoni Salad

“Messias was amazing from the start to the end of my visit. He made my experience at mangoni better than expected. He was efficient, respectful and paid attention to detail ensuring me and my sister had everything we needed! ????? they also have a great outdoor area !“

4.5 Superb371 Reviews
La Piccolina Italian • $$
15502 Stoneybrook W Pkwy #118, Winter Garden

Customers` Favorites

Lomo Saltado Con Fettuccine En Salsa Huancaina Sautéed Sirloin with Fettuccine Huancaina Sauce
Lomo Saltado Sautéed Sirloin
Lomo Saltado Con Fetuccini
Chicken Parmesana
Lucuma Cheesecake
Pasta Carbonara
Winter Garden
Apple Pie
Octopus
Mixed

“I have been here twice and have enjoyed both of my experiences. The food is great quality and the ceviche is delicious. When I go to a Peruvian restaurant I need a good pisco sour and a good ceviche and this restaurant has this and more. You can feel the love and care the team puts into this restaurant, it is very much a family dinner type of environment. Thank you!“

4.5 Superb83 Reviews
Cariera's Fresh Italian Italian • $$
1041 S Dillard St, Winter Garden

Customers` Favorites

Italian Beef Rigatoni Catering
Mozzarella Sticks
Gnocchi Carbonara
Chicken Francese
Chicken Parmesan
Fried Calamari
Garlic Rolls
Cannoli Cake
Meatball
Marsala

“I didn’t get the name of the employee who helped me today, but she was very sweet and kind. I have never met a more kind and caring worker in the restaurant industry.I think when I called to place my order, she was the one who helped me and gave recommendations for meals. I ordered 2 kids meals and a couple of sides for me and my 1 kid.I love this restaurant so much. I come here a few times, but I have been coming back once a week here just for the food and customer service. The food is really good and service is above and beyond.“

4.4 Superb86 Reviews
Caieras Italian • $$
1045 S Dillard St, Winter Garden

“My sister and I had our first visit to Cariera's in Winter Garden, FL, a family owned restaurant, for lunch about a week ago. I first heard about it a few years ago on the NextDoor App for the Dr. Phillips neighborhood in Orlando, which I believe was their original location. We grabbed the menus, sat at a booth, made our selections and then went up to very friendly Cashier/Waitress Valerie to prepay our meals and tips. I had the Fried Calamari, Shrimp & Crab Ravioli ala Vodka, fruit infused red sangria and for dessert, Limoncello cake. Sis had the Lasagna. Everything was delicious (see pics)! The calamari was seasoned crispy on the outside but light and tender on the inside. The ravioli didn't have as much crab as I would have liked but plenty of shrimp. The vodka sauce was creamy and cheesy. Even the garlic roll was fresh and warm. Everything was perfect and there was plenty leftovers to feed us a couple more days. The owner and Valerie and other servers checked on us periodically throughout our meal. The food, welcoming atmosphere and excellent customer service provided our first-time visit with a very happy, delightful experience! There are plenty of veggie and vegetarian options and a $10 'Little Bambinos' menu. Cariera's is located in a strip mall with plenty of parking except handicapped spaces are limited. We plan to return to try different things on the menu and would highly recommend for indoor and/or carry out meals with family, friends and visitors.“

4.4 Superb17 Reviews
ORLANDO CITY PASTA Italian • $
625 E Bay St, Winter Garden

“I pass by Orlando City Pasta at the Winter Garden Farmers Market regularly and finally decided to give them a try. They had a few flavors to choose from....all sounded great but I went with garlic. It cost $6.00 for what I am guessing was an eight ounce package. It was worth every penny. The pasta was sturdy and yet still tender. The flavor was bold but smooth...It was not pungent. I thought that the pasta was so delicious that I skipped the sauce and fresh grated parmesan....instead I tossed it in the tiniest bit of butter. It was a star all on its own.“

4.3 Superb12 Reviews
Romano's Macaroni Grill Italian • $$
3143 Daniels Rd, Winter Garden

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Parmesan Dinner
Spaghetti Meatballs
Fettuccine Alfredo
Shrimp Portofino
Chicken Marsala
Lobster Bisque
Penne Rustica
Caprese Salad
Mama's Trio
Romano

“We flew into the Orlando Airport . We ended up here at Romanos. Both my husband and I had the Bibb and Bleu cheese salad. Super delicious. We added chicken. I would definitely suggest this salad Lots of protein. Between the walnuts, Bleu cheese and chicken it kept us full and satisfied.“

3.7 Good121 Reviews
Loading...
map Map