17 Best Pizza Restaurants in Winter Garden

“Local Gem We live a 15 minute stroll from Mangoni's Italian Market, but at "feels like" temps hovering around 105°, strolling to lunch hasn't been as attractive ? Sunday, hubby wanted a relaxing lunch with sangria! So, we drove (& charged our EV in the parking garage). We had the entire patio to ourselves, as diners likely expected unbearable heat. Mangoni's pergola and great ceiling fans made patio dining the experience we wanted---even when the afternoon storm blew up from the west, we were protected from rain. We enjoyed our favorite, GF goat cheese pizza, with our sangria. Unlike most places, Mangoni's GF crust is an excellent, thin cauliflower crust. And, it’s not an upcharge. We also enjoyed meeting Georgia, the regional manager, who chatted with us about the social hour (11-6pm weekdays). She made a GF garlicky cheesy Flatbread for us to try--now we have more reason to stroll (or drive) over! Oh, and take away is a frequent option. Really, Mangoni's is a local gem.“

“There’s nothing quite like finding a gem of a local mom-and-pop pizza place, and this one hits all the marks! The pizzas are absolutely amazing: each bite feels like it’s made with love and years of pizza-making expertise.
I had no idea Brazilian Pizza was a thing, and discovering it locally is a blessing.

The first pizza is a comforting classic with a twist. The golden crust is cooked to perfection, with just the right balance of chewiness and crunch. The toppings are generous, especially the melt-in-your-mouth cheese and what looks like perfectly seasoned chicken. The herbs scattered on top bring out the flavors in a way that only a small, local place can do there’s that special touch you just don’t get from big chains.

The second pizza takes things up a notch with creative flair. Topped with savory meats like ham or prosciutto, and crispy bacon, it’s already a feast on its own. But what truly sets this pizza apart is the stuffed crust! Each corner has a surprise treat, a fried, possibly cheese-filled bite that’s crunchy on the outside and oozing with flavor on the inside. This kind of creativity is what makes supporting a local pizza spot so rewarding.

When you eat here, you’re not just grabbing a quick bite, you’re experiencing something that’s handcrafted and special. Knowing this comes from a small, family owned business makes it taste even better. They really care about the food they make, and it shows. It’s places like this that make a community feel like home! Pictures in the comments. Chef’s Kiss ??‍?“

“huge rave to Pieology staff! Went with a group of 10-15 for my birthday last night, arrived early so we could ask the manager where we could sit to not disrupt anything and Jules went above and beyond! She helped clear the back section, push tables together, offered to change the tv and even the restaurant music, amazing customer service, constant check in, and even gave our elderly member a cookie after we left while thanking us for leaving the place clean as well. The entire staff was so friendly and patient and it made birthday dinner a success. Also, thank you to the Disney cast member, that works photopass in her daily job, for taking the time and not only moving seats so we could all sit together, but even took a photo to remember for us! Highly recommend Pieology out by Flamingo’s Crossing!“

“Food and Service was amazing !! Family owned and operated great conversation while waiting for my Pie ! Very friendly will be a regular from now on ! My new go to for great food . They even had a deli slicing fresh meats . Can’t wait to try the other items in the future !!“

“Trust tried Pizza Press for the 1st time! Great pizza, fresh ingredients and really fast. We enjoyed it and will definitely be back!“

“This was our first time but it won't be our last. They were very accommodating with Gluten free options like GF pasta and GF bread. They also offered to make almost any entre GF.

The service was EXCELLENT!! Antonio and Josephine were amazing hosts. They really made you feel welcomed and were happy to answer questions about the menu.

We had the shrimp scampi and it was delicious with plenty of jumbo shrimp. This came with rainbow carrots and broccolini.
We also had the Filet Mignon with mashed potatoes and vegetable. The food was prepared exactly how we wanted and seasoned to perfection.

We had the house Tri-Mozzarella platter appetizer and it was amazing!!

We had an excellent meal and great experience!!!
We definitely recommend this restaurant!

Dietary restrictions: Gluten free options available such as pasta and GF bread. They also are very accommodating in offering to prepare almost any entre GF!!

Parking: Huge parking lot.

Kid-friendliness: High chairs available.“

“Our server, Kim, extraordinarily accommodated our party of six.. We had 3 different arrival times. She returned to the table 4 times without complaint to take food orders. She refilled glasses without being asked and did all of this with a very kind and warm demeanor. Overall she anticipated every possible wish. We really appreciated, how she was able to accommodate our family with a senior and a person with autism and made our lunch very special and suitable to the occasion of meeting in my Father’s memory. Many thanks!“

“It's a small Blaza Pizza. So if you want to dine in, just something to be aware of. The parking itself is horrible, very limited, and traffic in and out is bad.

Service would have been 5 star, but they forgot to give part of my order. ( brownie was old it was even date made 5 days before)

Parking: Shared parking with multiple businesses limited near the building. Just be aware of parking at night.

Kid-friendliness: Yes

Wheelchair accessibility: Yes“

“Brian and his team really were local hero’s. They worked together with a team of Senior Care Providers to provide pizzas to their families after a long days work!“

“I just picked up my pizza & it is pouring rain. I did curbside & this lovely man brought my pizzas out in it! (I was waiting for several cars to leave so I could to pull up to the building.) Thank you so much!! That was next level customer service!!“

“The pizza was delicious #onebiteeveryoneknowstherules“

“When there with my family on November 4th and Love It. Our server Madison make all of us feels at home, in the meanwhile Josh was handling the pizza making like a Maestro...
Pizza was Riiiica and the Wings were ?...the Oreo Zeppolis to Die For!!!
100% Recommended“

“Great location, always order and it’s the best . I had an issue last week and I’m a regular since I live close by , not only did they take care of my me right away but also through in a cookie brownie for the inconvenience , I did not even ask and it made my night ! Thank you guys and I wish I could give a bigger tip everytime !“

“The service is always friendly. Our oldest started going as an infant and she loves all the pasta dishes and the pizza. We decided to skip the long wait times at the restaurants closer to the shopping areas. Far more relaxing!“

“Great customer service! Very friendly customer service inside and they also carried my pizza out to my car since I was holding my baby. So considerate! Thank you, all!“

“They're very good about knowing their customers. Most of the time I show up and they immediately hand me my pizzas. They do this for name customers. Never had that level of service from any pizza place!

Parking: Sometimes hard to find a spot right away“

“Never have I ever felt more at home with a fast food chain! I am always greeted by smiles and excellent customer service. I'd like to specifically point out Brandon W, as he is always there with a beaming smile and always eager to give out the best service there is! The pizza is always on point as well. This Domino's is by far a favorite to order pizza! Thank you for the top tier service Brandon!“