Baxter's Restaurant
$$ • American, Bars, VegetarianAbout Baxter's Restaurant
Customers' Favorites
Twin Lobster Tail
French Onion Soup
Blue Cheese Steak
Chicken Marsala
Fresh Grouper
Fish and Chips
Surf and Turf
Fried Shrimp
Key Lime Pie
Rack of Lamb
Baxter's Restaurant Reviews
276 ratings
Share your opinion about Baxter's Restaurant
First time visitor- recommend by a local - she was spot on - food was amazing- especially the green beans, best I’ve ever had (and I live in the south), steaks were delicious as well - our waitress Summer was great - very friendly and attentive
Would definitely recommend and would definitely come back
Would definitely recommend and would definitely come back
Best margarita made by Barbi! The ribeye was delicious and perfectly cooked to a medium rare. Excellent service. Highly recommend!
Tasty food. Excellent wait service from Emma. Older establishment but they know how to keep customers coming back!
Hours
| Monday | 5 - 9PM |
| Tuesday | 5 - 9PM |
| Wednesday | 5 - 9PM |
| Thursday | 5 - 9PM |
| Friday | 5 - 10PM |
| Saturday | 5 - 10PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
Baxter's Restaurant serves high-quality steaks, including the recommended Steak au Poivre and a 14 oz ribeye steak that is full of flavor, tender, and juicy. The staff is friendly and efficient, with minimal wait times and customers highlighting the great service from staff members like Caitlin and Susan. The restaurant's convenient location and great steaks make it a good option, though prices are on the higher side. Customers have praised the excellent food, particularly the lamb chops and steak, which many consider the best on the island. In addition to steak, guests have enjoyed dishes like steak diane, eggplant, fried green tomatoes, and shrimp as appetizers. The atmosphere has an old vintage charm that some describe as reminiscent of a time when Dean Martin might be found at the bar. While many enjoy the setting, some feel it could use a refresh. Baxter's has been a popular choice for special occasions, such as a wedding rehearsal dinner and a birthday dinner, where customers have enjoyed great food at reasonable prices.