33 Best Ice Cream Shops near Fleming Island

“Thank you for your customer service! For going above and beyond for a family you don’t know!! Thank you to your staff for being awesome! Kudos to this store manager & owner! Leaders by example!!“

“awesome..incredible...magnificent“

“This charming local chocolatier and gelato shop features two tabletop confection mixers (one for milk and one for dark chocolate) as well as a preparation area where guests can watch chocolates being made in small batches.

The chocolates are made continuously with high quality ingredients, and they have a “sophisticated” taste with rich flavors and less sweetness than supermarket candies. On this trip I enjoyed dark chocolate peanut butter squares ($3 each).

Also on this trip, we enjoyed cherry chocolate gelato in a waffle cone dipped in dark chocolate ($6). The creamy desert contained thin, crunchy dark chocolate shavings and the cherries were tart and refreshing! Peterbrooke has a few sit down cafe tables inside as well as restrooms. So guests can eat gelato while enjoying the small town shop ambiance.

The store was festively decorated (for Halloween) and featured a table of spooky seasonal treats in addition to the regular offerings of chocolate bars, candied nuts, and sweet treats.

A great stop on Fleming Island for desert or a candy treat to gift or share.“

“Tasty Creamery has an array of flavors and toppings at the perfect price. my favorite is their "A La Mode" where you choose a bakery item such as a warm cookie with a scoop of ice cream and your choice of toppings.“

“My wife & I just got ice cream cones there and it’s excellent! The ice cream was fabulous & the service was friendly and enthusiastic! A great place to end a date night.“

“Best Ice Cream! Great flavors! 💛“

“We love cool eddys for an after school treat. She was shorthanded and so busy but was handling it wonderfully and so friendly even under the stress.“

“We love Whit’s! We love to come here with our dogs and get them pup cups! Always delicious and the workers are always very nice!“

“Every time we visit Pelican’s, we always get friendly and efficient service. The snowballs are fantastic and you can even get them stuffed with ice cream! The pelishakes are their version of a milkshake but to me they are so much better! You can get any flavor on the menu!🍦🥤🍧 If you haven’t tried Pelican’s you are missing out!“

“Great Service. Delicious Treats 🙌🏼“

“BEST ICE CREAM AND SERVICE I go every Sunday“

“Been coming here since before it became a chain and the way they still are is amazing they still have that cornerstore ice cream shop that dairy queen used to have back in the day. All the ice cream used to be cheaper I have to admit but they havent raised prices a lot only by about 5-8$ maybe all in all between all sizes. They also have cake but it is expensive. Overall 10 out of 10 staff and business. The ice cream tastes better and smoother than dairy queen almost like a custard consistency (which is what ice cream actually started as if you didnt know)“

“Great place to visit ice cream was wonderful 💚♾️💙“

“Some of the best Ice cream I’ve had“

“Vanessa was awesome helping me find the right flavors for my ice cream loving fiancé. Customer service 10000/10.“

“My wife & I just got ice cream cones there and it’s excellent! The ice cream was fabulous & the service was friendly and enthusiastic! A great place to end a date night.“

“The Caramel Pretzel flavor is soooooooooooooooooooo good. Your staff is as sweet as the yogurt“

“Best Gelato & Italian Ice!! love That you have a Taste sample to pivmck what you desire.“

“Over all really good tasting cookies, good texture, and good service and packaging.

Dietary restrictions: There should be a section on the menu that offers people on dietary restrictions a healthier alternative to fulfill their cravings. High protein crumbl cookies with lower macros would be a good idea for people with goals“

“Everything is just absolutely delicious!“

“Delicious! Beautiful environment! loved it! Owner and staff very friendly! A wonderful "treat yo'self" spot! ❤️ 💙 💜“

“Best cookies I've had in a long time! Came all the way from the UK for the experience! Great selection and I love you can get mini versions so you can get a selection and try them all. Reasonably priced. Great staff and service and love the little pads to order from as you get overwhelmed deciding what to get and can take your time.“

“My sister chose to go there for her birthday lunch. Very nice employees.“

“Good stuff!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!“

“I love everything!!! I highly recommend this place.“

“Need a quick gift? Invited to dinner at last minute and want to take a gift to the host? Look no further... who can resist chocolate? Not me! First of all I've always loved Peterbrooke... if I worked there I would eat all the profits lol. Their chocolate is so good. This store has pre-made gifts that you can grab, pay, and go! And if you have time, browse around and if you don't see what you want just ask! The staff here are super nice and accommodating. Check them out! P.S. the ice cream is delicious too!“

“The best chocolatier! 👏👏👏“

“Cozy little coffee house by Spring park in Green cove springs. Friendly and fast .. Best iced coffee ever! having an almond joy iced coffee and French toast muffin! 😋 omg Highly recommend 🛵.....“

“ice cream was delicious. The cashier was friendly and order was accurate and fast“

“Yummy, Best burger in town by far“

“I have been patronizing our neighborhood DQ for many years. It’s the spot I always took our kids after a hard sports practice or to celebrate the last day of school or a great test grade. Lots of good memories here and lots of delicious ice cream! Special shout out to Will at the drive thru window who served our ice cream with a smile!“

“Great place Friendly folks“