50 Best American Restaurants in Key West

“Great food and atmosphere. Servers and staff make you feel right at home . Jungle atmosphere with roosters galore !“

“Our favorite breakfast spot in Key West. Great service and super food.“

“Delicious food and great service! get.the conch fritters and mahi bites. best fritters we had on our trip!“

“Baby’s Grill is a must stop on your way to & fro Key West. It’s no lie the best food we ate in The Keys. It’s a food truck next to Baby’s Coffee serving up a menu of American favorites. There’s plenty of parking and tables to sit. We got Étouffée, a Philly Cheesesteak and fries with Coral Aioli. Everything was incredible and masterfully crafted. The food was made with love and serious flavor that truly satisfied. The Coral Aioli is other worldly and will knock your socks right off. Don’t take my word for it, go and see for yourself. 👀🔥🪸“

“if you know you know. I plan my key west trips around Mary Ellen's calendar....... especially Thursdays. I have the best time every time I go. it never lets you down.“

“Great food, had the tacos trio, fabulous.“

“My husband and I were there tonight. We were at your restaurant 12 years ago and we had the Soul Mama soup then and I had to go back while in Key West to have it again. Even in 100 degree weather I had to order me some soul mama soup. The lobster special was very tempting, but I couldn’t pass up my favorite. Thank you for keeping Soul Mama on the menu ❤️🎉“

“The guy who attended was really nice, the food was delicious congratulations!!“

“Surprised by how good the food was because the place was so unsanitary. Tables, chairs, bathrooms were so gross. Great location just wish it was taken care better.“

“I highly recommend the Reverend Joe’s Burger and the Cuban! They serve an Island Life Lager that is brewed by Waterfront Brewery right in Key West! It was awesome as well!“

“Usually, I go to Salutes at night. However last Friday myself and a good friend met for an afternoon lunch. I have to tell you from the moment we were seated and our server introduced herself the luncheon was spectacular. Mary Jo was so bubbly, excited and energetic that it changed the whole dining experience. She made the lunch fun and all about us. Apparently, Mary Jo works Monday -Friday and that's why I never ran into her before. Make sure you visit and look for her. Barbara Bosco Crespo“

“Went to dinner at the bar before a show my wife had the best margarita of her life. Long haired bartender was entertaining and attentive. great place! great food! Tacos rock. highly recommend going there.“

“Excellent food. Their tomato bisque! Historic building. Charming.“

“We spent a little over a week and each day was better than the previous! The breakfast was amazing, the bar and food were also great! Every single staff member we were in contact with was friendly, gracious, and beyond accommodating! Special shout out to Felix and Lisa! The rooms were beautiful… So clean, large, with great views, and the beds were super comfortable! Our son goes to school and lives in Key West so we are down there often… This was our first time at the Capitana and definitely not our last! From here on out we will stay nowhere else! I have been telling people and will continue to tell everyone I know that this is the best place to stay in Key West!“

“got a coffee one morning coffee was so good came back the next morning for breakfast did not disappoint Great service great guys unique food A really nice hidden gem in Key West“

“Lovely anniversary dinner. Excellent service and meal. They had a sign on our table wishing us a happy Anniversary and we had the best view of the sunset!!“

“Great service and very friendly“

“So so good…. The food, the service, the vibe!!“

“We had our wedding dinner here March 28th and they were absolutely amazing! They handled our large party well, drinks and food were amazing and service was super fast! We will definitely be stopping in on our next trip!“

“Wow! We are blown away with Marquesa hotel. From the beautiful king suite poolside room, to the delicious cookies at noon, and the amazing staff… Great job! We’ve been coming to Key West two times a year every year for the past 10 to 15 years and we’ve stayed at many beautiful properties, but this one wins above them all. I highly, highly recommend this property. We will be returning guests for sure!“

“Great key west vibe! Delicious food and drinks- great happy hour! Amazing staff!“

“Tonight was our second time here and it was just as perfect. Being from Charleston SC we have been to some excellent restaurants and this is right up there. The atmosphere, view, service, and food are all 110%“

“Food was good , service good but so many fans running our food was all cold in a matter of minutes. We didn’t eat it all because it was cold! Every thing else was good just turn all those fans off or down.“

“We dined here on Sept 14, 2025 The toasted coconut piña colada was amazing!! Everyone had a cheeseburger with French fries, everyone was pleased! We would eat here again.“

“One of the best meals that we have ever had in our years of coming to Key West! Our only complaint is that we didn’t discover this gem sooner. Fantastically delicious menu options; everything was prepared and presented perfectly. Our waiter was personable and professional. We will definitely be back soon!“

“Awesome restaurant and menu. Very, very friendly service!“

“⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ Absolutely Amazing Experience! From start to finish, everything was exceptional! The food was fresh, flavorful, and beautifully presented — truly some of the best we’ve had in a long time. The drinks were perfectly crafted and delicious, and the service was outstanding — friendly, attentive, and made us feel so welcome. Every detail was spot-on, and we can’t wait to come back. Highly recommend to anyone looking for great food, great service, and a great atmosphere!“

“First Flight Island Restaurant & Brewery was one of the highlights of my Key West trip! The atmosphere is fun and relaxed, with a perfect island vibe. The food was fresh and flavorful, the drinks were amazing, and the service was friendly and attentive. It’s the kind of place where you can sit back, enjoy great food, and soak in the Key West charm. Definitely a must-visit! 🍹🌴✨“

“food was good our server was awesome“

“this restaurant is one of the best in Key West. It has an exceptional atmosphere, extensive menu and great service. We were pleased with all that this restaurant has to offer including impeccable drinks and food selections. We were delighted to have Mercedes as our server and she did everything possible to make us feel like family.“

“Southernmost Beach Café has the view, the vibe, and the beachside location — but what really stands out are the people behind the bar, especially Doina and Saunders.\n\nThey’re the kind of bartenders who make you feel welcome the moment you sit down. Friendly, upbeat, and always in a good mood, they bring the kind of energy that turns a simple breakfast or drink into a great experience.\n\nThey’re also more than happy to put on whatever game you’re hoping to catch, and the nachos make a perfect snack during football. It’s become a regular stop for me, and it’s because of the way they treat their guests — with genuine hospitality and great conversation.\n\nHighly recommend grabbing a seat at the bar and letting Doina and Saunders take care of you.“

“Spectacular from start to finish, 3 hour fine dining experience with amazing menu options, beautiful wine list, and top quality service! A must if you’re in Key West!!!“

“All I can say is check this place out! The food is amazing!“

“Best coconut margaritas 🍹“

“Very Friendly! Great roll!“

“Thank you for making my wife's birthday dinner enjoyable. Everything was first class. We have been here many times and Azur is one of our favorites in town.“

“Wonderful locally owned shop with an amazing staff. Excellent food! A must try and repeat in Key West.“

“Extremely overpriced food. Worst sloppy joe sandwich I've had in my life! certainly not worth $15.49 and NO SIDES included. Small, and not much filling, I've had better at a church picnic! Drinks are no better than anywhere else. Party atmosphere, but if you want good food and decent portions for REASONABLE prices, look elsewhere.“

“Unbelievable! We had the calamari app which was sautéd. Freaking amazing! Next my wife ordered the Ceviche. Off the hook! Now for the coup de grace, the Black Grouper with passion fruit and mango chutney. OMG!!! A foodies dream! A must stop when in Key West!!!!“

“Great Cuban coffee and breakfast; warm and friendly staff, great service, and delicious food.“

“Excellent staff and owner who cares about everyone.“

“Amazing 🤩 stop by for food and amazing drinks 🍺“

“Can't wait to go back the next time we're in Key West, we love this place! Great atmosphere Great views, highly recommend❤️“

“The entertainer, John Solinski, was fantastic! Very talented and engaging with the audience. And it turns out he was from the same home town as my lifelong best friend! Small world keeps getting smaller! Drinks and service were well above average too! Highlight of my weekend in Key West!“

“tasty brunch followed by relaxing on the beach. Kids loved it here“

“Beautiful place great staff“

“Great experience during lunch. Go straight to the bar. It’s on the water. Beat the dinner crowd and enjoy a great view during a lunch visit. Much more relaxing! No reason to fight the crowds at night.“

“We spent a nice evening here during a recent stay at the Hyatt Centric. Service great, dockside, marina, bay view … beautiful place to hang out, right next to the hotel pool! Lots of blue lights… made many of the pics blue… LOL. Drinks were typical island bar, but very good! We had the fish tacos and key lime pie, both delicious! Highly recommend you stop here!“

“Great experience during lunch. Go straight to the bar. It’s on the water. Beat the dinner crowd and enjoy a great view during a lunch visit. Much more relaxing! No reason to fight the crowds at night.“

“Somewhere in that bar, you will find a painted plaque dedicated to Capt Mark Gamble, he and his wife perished on a vessel that was modified in Key West. Captain Paul Worthington was so touched by their story he allowed a painted plaque to be placed in his bar, You as a person from afar are allowed to drink here not knowing the history of the great masters who sat here like Hemmingway and Mel Fisher met their demise thur their love of the ocean. I miss all of these men dearly, I am shedding tears for all as I write this story. You are fortunate to sit in their shadow and consume drinks in a place where only the greatest of men have hollowed. This is not your normal bar, this is a shrine to men who loved the ocean and have perished. You should feel privileged to sit and drink here.“