16 Best Ice Cream Shops near Matlacha

“I just had the best cotton candy Italian ice and it was fresh and tasty. 10 out of 5 stars every time I walk in there. Thank you for taking care of my sweet needs.“

“What can I say? Amazing gelato , amazing experience , and amazing food love this place.“

“Delicious ice creams, Sanet’s attention is super thanks for helping me say such a delicious ice cream“

“An entirely wonderful experience from walking in and seeing the smiling faces of Matt and Barbara to tasting the delicious HOMEMADE ice cream and Italian Ice. There are countless options of flavors and delectable concoctions! Definitely a 5 ⭐ place!!“

“Highly recommend this place! Excellent ice cream and good service. It is always a pleasure to be here.“

“Off on an adventure to go bowling but the place was booked up. To appease the kids during the wait, we headed over to Spaghy Gelato waited for our friends to arrive, got all 5 kids out of the car to open the door and find it was locked! Strike two of the day! As our heads hung low a woman drove up letting us know she was the owner and they didn’t open until 3. I looked at my watch and it was almost 2:30. The woman offers to let us in anyways and says she can’t do the spaghetti but that she could scoop us ice cream! 🥳 We said “no problem, that’s great,” and thanked her! She proceeds to rush inside offers and lets each kid try multiple samples until they were sure of what they wanted. Then she says she can do the spaghetti for us but it may take awhile and we said that’s no problem! She took each child’s order and was patient when they were indecisive. Everyone got their order and was happily digging in when she comes out and offers each child the option to choose a toy from the little bins which was beyond kind! Then as she is doing this, 2-3 groups of people came in asking if they were open and she said she wasn’t, but since she already helped us, then she would help them too! This woman went well above and beyond with kindness and patience and completely made our kids (and our) day! We will be back for sure and encourage everyone to try it! People and places like this deserve to be shouted from the rooftops 😉 Enjoy!“

“AMAZING bubble waffle sundaes!!“

“An excellent spot, full of creative and delicious treats made with love. Simply magnificent“

“I’ve eaten ice cream for 67 years. This is the best ice cream I have ever had.“

“Love this little place! All the flavors we’ve tried have been delicious, the artwork on the building is wicked fun and funky. I keep meaning to stop in for a breakfast sandwich and a coffee, but I’m sure it’s all as good as the ice cream.“

“This was our first time at Jeremiah’s and it was delicious. I got the mango one and it was so refreshing.“

“A great place to bring the kids and people are friendly.“

“The best ice cream in town!!!“

“Its awesome ice cream. Enough said.“

“I definitely recommend Gulf Coast Fudge Co!!!! the staff is so amazing, specifically Sarah! Very friendly environment. I had the “Mint To Be” freak shake and it was delicious!!! Will be back for sure!“

“They have some of the most flavorful ice cream in SWFL!“