23 Best Sandwich Shops in Sarasota

“We love this place! Great food, great service, reasonable prices. It’s everything I’m looking for when going to get breakfast with my fam.“

“🇩🇪 Wundervoller Besuch – absolut empfehlenswert! ❤️❤️❤️🙏🇭🇺 Wir waren gestern in diesem liebevoll geführten Laden und sind rundum begeistert! Der Baumkuchen war ein Traum – frisch, saftig und mit viel Liebe gemacht. Dazu ein hervorragender Kaffee, der das Genusserlebnis perfekt abgerundet hat. Besonders hervorheben möchten wir die unglaublich freundliche Eigentümerin, mit der wir ein sehr nettes Gespräch führen durften. Man spürt sofort, mit wie viel Herzblut sie ihr Geschäft führt. Auch der Service war aufmerksam und herzlich – man fühlt sich sofort willkommen. Das Geschäft selbst ist sehr sauber und gepflegt, mit einer warmen Atmosphäre, in der man gerne verweilt. Wir kommen definitiv wieder – ein echter Geheimtipp!“

“love the food and of course, they have excellent Sweet Tea ! Employee's are pleasant and respectful and the place is clean, very important!“

“Having an stellar sandwich and excellent coleslaw, a must try if you are downtown SRQ.“

“My first time here and it was the bomb!!! I had been wanting a good Ruben for a while….. well needless to say you guys ROCK! My sandwich was awesome and I will definitely be back 💪🏾💪🏾💪🏾“

“A friend recently recommended Maximillian’s for a catering lunch at work. The ordering process was simple, they had the food ready in individual boxed lunches, and the customer service was excellent. Everyone was excited about the sandwiches and I will for sure be ordering for more work lunches from them. Highly recommend!“

“They are the very best phillies in Sarasota!! Please say they didn't close?!?!?!? Come back. Sarasota has no quality food or restaurants anymore. And you still have to pay $100+++ to even get remote quality for a family dinner out. We need to take care of our small businesses because they need us and we need them!!“

“Always vary pleasant great service“

“The staff was friendly and my Italian sub was perfect, which is the kind of quality I expect from Jersey Mike's. But I have to ding at least one star here because I was the only one in the shop and although I only ordered one sub, the person preparing my sandwich was also preparing three other sandwiches at the same time. I understand phone in and app orders need to be filled, but I believe a customer standing there waiting for their subs should be given at least some deference. I had somewhere to be, and this almost made me late.“

“Hot zamn, this place was AWESOMEEE! They embodied “freaky fast” before my eyes. Shoutout Christy!!!! My sandwich was so good, I can say that because I have gotten the same sandwich at every Jimmy John’s from here to Colorado, and this was the best. They also didn’t mind my friend doing my hair really quick. Such a positive energy in there!“

“They finally have chicken salad subs again, I’m very pleased!!! The chicken salad mixture is nice and normal….no weird additions and very tasty!! Update! I visited again today and the Chicken Salad wasn’t on the menu!!! But I asked and the guy said they still have it for the time being… but it will be going away soon…… so sad but happy that I was able to order it today, they were very nice about it!!“

“Best cheesecakes I've ever had. The perfect crust to cheesecake ratio. My current favorite is the pina colada cheesecake.“

“The food is always good but the Ghost Pepper sub bread is amazing, so if you want to try something interesting, you should try this. Unfortunately, since I'm used to eating extremely spicy foods, although it has Ghost Pepper in the name, you'll only find jalapeños on the bread so it's not as spicy as I'd like but what can you do. I really recommend every sub here since it's all good but if you are as much of a spicy food fanatic as I am, you'll need ALOT of jalapeños. Come eat and enjoy. I know I do, at least once a week I'm there.“

“SOOOOOO disappointed that you were NOT welcoming the nation wide promotion of $6.99 for any club.. I did order (as I or we normally do) because of one of your staff. YARELY is so helpful, knowledgeable, and friendly. She remembers customers and their interests. A real pleasure to come in when she is working.“

“I came to this store on 8/27/25 around 7pm after having a bad experience trying to get a pub sub. When I walked in I was greeted by everyone in the store, including the staff that were in the back. They made my sub with care and definitely uplifted the rest of my night. Everything was clean and I was acknowledged while walking out as well. I’ve always had great service here. It’s the little things that go a long way.“

“Let me start by saying Wow. I am absolutely floored by the level of customer service provided in this location. My daughter is very picky, but has some how come to love the club sub from Jersey Mikes and refuses to get a sandwich from anywhere else. In particular she loves this location. Generally, every store we visit provides a great food experience, but there is something or should I say someone this location has, that others don’t. This gentleman’s name is Todd. Todd provides exemplary service. He recognizes my daughter and to a T remembers her exact order, and even got her to try a different bread. If this man doesn’t run this store he SHOULD. I cannot say enough positive words about what I experienced as I watched him interact with our whole family. Thank you Todd, for going above and beyond. Thank you for being a shining example of what it means to make a difference in somebodies day.“

“Potbelly's is your go-to sandwich spot in Sarasota! Whether you're in a hurry or if you want to dine in, Potbelly's has got you covered! My favorite is the Pizza Melt Sandwich! Great food and great staff! One of the better sandwich places I've been to! Definitely a place to go for a quick bite to eat!“

“I wish I knew who made my sandwich today so I could give her special recognition, because I just had THE BEST Subway sandwich I've ever had! The ingredients were fresh and full of flavor! Maybe you could say it was because I was so hungry, but I don't think so. Anyway, Thank You, whoever you were!!!“

“The food is delicious, Jashika's attention is the best, she is very friendly every day My colleagues and I go there to eat, she is excellent at doing her job... the bad thing is that there is only her on the shift, there should be 2 people at the same time I think it's a bit tiring for one person.“

“This location has good Manager(s). When they saw that something went wrong, they fixed it.“

“Thank you John for making the Riverview Cheerleaders Senior Splash pizza dinner so wonderful last night! The pizza was delicious you are the best!“

“SUBWAYS ARE THE BEST SANDWICH SHOPS IN SARASOTA PERIOD.Subway is always amazing and delicious but I am biased for they make the very best Tuna Sub in America and maybe even the world but I may be the only person who eats Tuna subs for I have never seen the container not full when I order them y'all haven't lived till you have a tuna with sweet onion sauce and lettuce and pickles from any subway I have never been disappointed“

“Quick service and great food ! Have been to this Firehouse subs before and great food as usual“