31 Best Italian Restaurants near Seffner

“Just had the regular larger delux and the new magnifico old style pepperoni and they were both definitely magnifico !! Thank you Marco’s 🥰“

“This place is great.. have ordered from here thousands of times. If you tell them what you want that's what you'll get..

Parking: Be careful going in going out

Wheelchair accessibility: Seems like I remember seeing a ramp“

“Went to Carrabba’s for the first time to dine in. The ambience was nice, the service was excellent and the food was nice and hot! Just the way I like it. I was starving when I arrived and my food was up and ready in short order. Impressive! My waiter, Josh, was amazing! He had other tables to wait on, but he made us feel like we were the only ones. I think I’ll be spending a lot more time dining in. Carrabba’s exceeded all of my expectations! Great work guys!“

“Fast and delicious and friendly service“

“Steven was wonderful 👍🏾😊. He gave me a glass to celebrate and blend with my group“

“Great Food here in Brandon Like you never left NEW YORK! This is my favorite Italian Restaurant in Florida. It first has a wonderful ambience classy and romantic. I tried it with clients. Since then my wife and I have been going back ever since. The food is Amazing their Red Sauce is perfect could not be better. Their Chicken Parm is some of the best. Their Alla Vodka one of the best in Florida and they are always making memorable specials that you will be using bread to soak up the last drop. Great appetizers like the Carozza will tease your palate for more and more yummy goodness. A slice of delicious Limoncello cake and a cup of espresso is the perfect way to end a fantastic dinner out. The setting is perfect not to big “you feel you are in a subway station but not to small that you are eating dinner on the other table's lap.” It has a romantic and calming décor. Every other Wednesday they have live music. The wait staff is attentive, professional, playful, and friendly. Vito the manager and his nice wife are the best. They are from New York owned restaurants in New York they know how to make great food.“

“My friend and I wanted to have catch up session over a nice Italian meal, so what other place to go than Olive Garden? Unfortunately even before we sat down at our table we started getting stares from other parties. My friend had her very well behaved 4 year old son with her, and I had my almost 2 year old son with me. Clearly no one wanted kids around .

As anyone with toddlers knows , they can be a bit active. Mine was no different and grabbed the sugar stash on the table to play with. Another guest felt the need to tell me what he was doing wrong . She got all worked up about it .

We asked to move to another table and our waiter was happy to help us do that to tbt other side of the restaurant. They even gave us a free appetizer ! Eli was so kind and got teary eyed when we told her about our horrible experience with the other guests. We clearly felt attacked by them on a racist level.

Just having a staff who was sympathetic toward us made the crappy experience a lot better. For this reason we’ll definitely be back. Angela, Eli and Felix were so caring and accommodating. Thank you Olive Garden.“

“Nicest people i’ve met, they always do right by me when I come in and the food is always good!

Vegetarian options: There’s all types of toppings from meat to veggies

Parking: In a plaza

Kid-friendliness: small pizzas that are filling even for me!

Wheelchair accessibility: Straight forward from door to counter“

“Dodici's pizzas definitely never stop surprising me, the best quality in ingredients, the best flavor and combinations that without hesitation will make your mind blow... an excellent experience, unbeatable service and flavors that will drive your palate crazy 100% recommended“

“5 stars all the way! If you want delicious food, great customer service and a great place to hang with the family, look no further. I've been eating at Amicis since moving to Fishhawk, and they are always on point. I've had their Pizza, Pastas and Sandwiches and they are all 10/10, everytime.“

“Several friends recommended this place and I'm glad they did. Love this place, very trendy cozy decor, food was delicious, staff was great and the drinks were tasty. Highly recommend.“

“Great food and service. We will be back.“

“We had the family meal of Caprese Chicken and Penne delivered! The food quality was excellent! The chicken was tender, juicy and flavorful! The penne was well seasoned and perfectly sauced. The whole family loved it! We will definitely order again!“

“You can smell how delicious the food is in the parking lot.It's so good . This place is really overlooked.It needs to be shouted from the rooftops. But be prepared the sizes of the food. The servings alone are so large.You will be taking home food.“

“This is the best fried chicken you want in your life! Also the best customer service and care. They know each of their regular customers by name! And, surprisingly by voice! This is a wonderful family establishment and a great place to spend time and money and this is an all around great place to get great chicken and great service. THANKS TORRIE! You provide a service that far exceeds the expectations. I will forever be a loyal customer!“

“Best pizza ever!! Especially the deep dish! We normally pick it up but really enjoyed the atmosphere and service eating in as well. 5 stars!! ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️“

“I went to Cipresso last night for dinner.I took advantage of the ICON half off deal.It was half of everything including alcohol. Such a great deal. John the bartender is an absolute rockstar and gem .The filthy martini and espresso martinis( i ordered one dark and one creamy) were all phenomenal .I ordered the scallop special with polenta.Fresh U-8 scallops with polenta and vegetables.The picture does not do it justice.It tasted wven better than it looked The spaghetti and meatballs is a consistent win.I was really impressed by the food and service“

“The best pizza in Plant City!“

“I LOVE PIZZA ROCK!!!!!!!!“

“Yummy our family have been going here for years! We enjoyed our get together! Great pizza!“

“Pizza could have been hotter. The rest of the order was good. Thx for allowing our dogs to sit outside with us (unlike Mellow Mushroom 😡 dog haters.) If the heaters were working we would have stayed longer ate more and spent more. 🤷‍♂️“

“Casual atmosphere, good food, and average service. I like the pasta as well as the garlic rolls, and of course the pizza is great. They serve Chigago-style deep dish pizza, with the sauce on top, and my baked ziti was perfectly covered in cheese.“

“Our Italian salad was absolutely delicious! Great price for the large amount of cheese, meats, and lettuce. All the flavors were super fresh!!! Wait time was less than 10 minutes, which is awesome for a handmade salad! There were so many yummy desserts in the cases too that we want to try out on our next visit!!!!!“

“Always have an excellent time. Going to Cappy’s. The pizzas excellent and it’s a great atmosphere. Staff is always on point.“

“👍 pizza and service. friendly staff“

“I have been a long-time frequent customer and was very disappointed after trying their new online order process. There was no disclaimer the order would be delivered through a meal service rather than their own drivers. I received cold pizza and soggy wings nearly 2 hours later after the new delivery service decided to drive my pizza around the area fulfilling other customer’s orders from other restaurants first, this is after it likely sat at the restaurant for 20-30 minutes after it was ready for delivery. Had I known this, I would have called in my order directly as I have done in the past. We live within 5 minutes of the store and always receive hot pizzas quickly when ordering via phone. I should have noticed the increased menu prices and realized it was to account for a delivery service fee, but I didn’t. There should be a disclaimer on your website that online orders are delivered through a contracted delivery service. When calling to get an update on the delay I was put on hold and hung up on four times before giving up.“

“After growing tired of eating chain store pizza with a seemingly decreasing quality, or being just outside of delivery area, our neighbors recommended Formaggios. We tried a meatlover, and a white pizza without spinach. I don’t see myself going back to chain restaurant pizza if I’m near Formaggio’s!“

“Y'ALL HAVE THE BEST PIZZA AROUND.. me and my fiance keep coming back and I would definitely give you guys 5 stars.“

“We are blessed to have LaSeptima as part of all of our life events. Today they wonderfully catered a family funeral. We are grateful for the memories while celebrating over great food. Thank you for being a part of our family for many years.“

“The food was excellent and made perfectly to my satisfaction. It was nice and hot... and seasoned well. The customer service was amazing and very attentive. I had a great experience. I definitely recommend eating there at the Brandon location.“

“I went to Hungry Howies in Fishhawk tonight around 6:45 p.m. The crew there was amazing. They were completely on top of everything, efficient, polite, and the pizza was great! They were super busy, and I was expecting sub-par pizza, but it was just as great as always. It made my heart smile to see such hard working, diligent young workers. Hats off to the crew!!“