16 Best Italian Restaurants near Valrico

“First time visiting and we will definitely be back. The pizza was the best we’ve had in the Brandon area. The staff were friendly and professional. They truly care about the quality of food and customer service they provide.“

“Y'ALL HAVE THE BEST PIZZA AROUND.. me and my fiance keep coming back and I would definitely give you guys 5 stars.“

“I have been a long-time frequent customer and was very disappointed after trying their new online order process. There was no disclaimer the order would be delivered through a meal service rather than their own drivers. I received cold pizza and soggy wings nearly 2 hours later after the new delivery service decided to drive my pizza around the area fulfilling other customer’s orders from other restaurants first, this is after it likely sat at the restaurant for 20-30 minutes after it was ready for delivery. Had I known this, I would have called in my order directly as I have done in the past. We live within 5 minutes of the store and always receive hot pizzas quickly when ordering via phone. I should have noticed the increased menu prices and realized it was to account for a delivery service fee, but I didn’t. There should be a disclaimer on your website that online orders are delivered through a contracted delivery service. When calling to get an update on the delay I was put on hold and hung up on four times before giving up.“

“Me and my family love ordering from here! We always get the very huge Calzones! And the Philly cheese steak sandwiches! Also the salads are pretty good too! Food is always ready on time, no wait! We order anytime between 3pm -6pm on usually busy days, never had to wait. Was always ready at pickup time and usually ready earlier that the pickup time! and also very fresh/hot! Today they gave us a free platter of cinnamon bites, that the guy said were new to the menu! Those were really good too! We have ordered several times now and the team members are always very nice and welcoming! Very clean inside! Im guessing older bad reviews are from older management. Because we have never had a problem with our 10+ orders so far! Definitely give this place a try! :) A++“

“Had a marvelous dinner. A most wonderful server Mykaela. She was fantastic. Energetic, knowledgeable, thoughtful. Breath of fresh air. Thank you so much!“

“Steven was wonderful 👍🏾😊. He gave me a glass to celebrate and blend with my group“

“What a hidden gem! The food was some of the best Italian I have ever had! All fresh ingredients, beautiful presentation and truly delicious! The restaurant is small and gives cozy, friendly vibes. Our server, Francesco was great! Friendly and helpful with recommendations. We highly recommend you check it out. We cant wait to go back!“

“Went today for the first time (Plant City) and didn't get free breadsticks, all in all the food was good, the customer service sucked!“

“Poppa’s Italian Factory is a fantastic place! The food is amazing, freshly prepared, & fast! Donna & Ken are super-sweet & treat you like family! I’m a huge fan of their eggplant parmesan & the desserts are all delicious—especially the Italian pistachio cake! They recently made a big box of Italian cookies for an event to support Hope Services & it was a huge hit!
Thank you so much for your all you do & for being there all the nights I don’t have time to make dinner! 😊“

“Several friends recommended this place and I'm glad they did. Love this place, very trendy cozy decor, food was delicious, staff was great and the drinks were tasty. Highly recommend.“

“Great food and service. We will be back.“

“5 stars all the way! If you want delicious food, great customer service and a great place to hang with the family, look no further. I've been eating at Amicis since moving to Fishhawk, and they are always on point. I've had their Pizza, Pastas and Sandwiches and they are all 10/10, everytime.“

“We had the family meal of Caprese Chicken and Penne delivered! The food quality was excellent! The chicken was tender, juicy and flavorful! The penne was well seasoned and perfectly sauced. The whole family loved it! We will definitely order again!“

“ALLISON at the Brandon location WAS AMAZING! She was very attentive, so sweet, food came out quick and hot! She was very helpful with any questions and our drinks were never empty without a refill next to it! Highly recommend, would come back just for her!“

“I went to Cipresso last night for dinner.I took advantage of the ICON half off deal.It was half of everything including alcohol. Such a great deal. John the bartender is an absolute rockstar and gem .The filthy martini and espresso martinis( i ordered one dark and one creamy) were all phenomenal .I ordered the scallop special with polenta.Fresh U-8 scallops with polenta and vegetables.The picture does not do it justice.It tasted wven better than it looked The spaghetti and meatballs is a consistent win.I was really impressed by the food and service“

“This is no ordinary, hungry Howies. Hands-down, the best all you can eat pizza buffet anywhere from the piping hot pizza delivered constantly to the buffet do the clean and well stock salad bar. You won’t be disappointed Ali’s contributions to the community speak for themselves (google his story) and he has a way of personally making the youngest of patrons feel like they’re a part of the operation. Our grandson loves to eat here, not just for the pizza, but for the lessons he receives in pizza making. Bring your whole family and especially your small kids. You won’t be disappointed.“