41 Best Ice Cream Shops near Siesta Key

Made In Rome Organic Gelato Ice Cream Shop • $
5204 Ocean Blvd, Siesta Key

Customers` Favorites

Ricotta Cheese Honey and Mascarpone Gelato
Stracciatella and Ricotta Gelato
Vegan Chocolate Gelato
Pistachio Ice Cream
Coconut Ice Cream
Chocolate Brownie
Pistachio Gelato
Pink Pineapple
Ferrero Rocher
Organic Gelato

“The best gelato this side of Italy 😍“

4.8 Superb170 Reviews
Kilwins Siesta Key Ice Cream Shop • $
5140 Ocean Blvd, Siesta Key

Customers` Favorites

Gelato

“Best ice cream on Siesta!“

3.8 Good58 Reviews
Main Street Creamery Ice Cream Shop • $$
1359 Main St, Sarasota - 4.78 miles

Customers` Favorites

Banana Pudding with Chocolate Peanut Butter Sauce
Cookie Dough and Siesta Ice Cream
Cotton Candy Mocha Almond Fudge
Peanut Butter Cup Ice Cream Cone
Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough
Soft-Serve Birthday Cake
Toasted Marshmallow
Toasted Coconut
Cookie Monster
Brownie Sundae

“The best ice cream in Florida! Generous portions, friendly staff and a wonderful location. You can sit inside or outside, both are fun. Can't wait to go back, yummy!!!“

4.9 Superb185 Reviews
Jake's Ice Cream on Siesta Key Ice Cream Shop • $
6575 Midnight Pass Rd, Sarasota - 1.39 miles

Customers` Favorites

Others Greats Salted Caramel Pecan and Cinnimon Biscoff
Espresso Double Scoop Ice Cream with Rainbow Sprinkles
Toasted Coconut Ice Cream with Waffle Come
Orange Pineapple
Chocolate Almond
Cookies & Cream
Cookie Monster
Wicked Cobbler
Chocolate Chip
Brownie Fudge

“Absolutely the BEST ice cream around. As a family we drive an hour nearly every week to eat Jake's ice cream...YES, it's that good! Incredibly kind owner and staff as well, this place is a must visit if in the Sarasota area (and beyond!) Once you've tasted Jake's ice cream it's hard to ever eat anything else, he's raising the standards for homemade ice cream with every flavor - although we all have our favorites we've never tried one we didn't like!! (My personal favorite is Salty Turtle)“

4.9 Superb151 Reviews
Great Heights Creamery Ice Cream Shop • $
1371 Boulevard of the Arts Unit 3, Sarasota - 5.15 miles

Customers` Favorites

Ice Cream Cone
Gelato

“Hands down the BEST craft ice cream in Sarasota. The passion and heart the owners put into every scoop is evident at your very first bite. I highly recommend this amazing ice cream. You just gotta try it!“

5 Superb102 Reviews
Pete's Sweet Treats Ice Cream Shop • $
6616 Superior Ave, Sarasota - 1.94 miles

Customers` Favorites

Cookie Dough Ice Cream - Pint
Lemon Poppy Seed Ice Cream
Limoncello Cake - Slice
Cookie Butter Ice Cream
Acai Italian Ice - Pint
Lemon Italian Ice - Cup
Strawberry Ice Cream
Black Raspberry Chip
Chocolate Ice Cream
Chocolate Brownie

“Awesome experience. Amazing ice cream! Highly recommend for all!“

4.8 Superb194 Reviews
Abel's Ice Cream Ice Cream Shop • $
1886 Stickney Point Rd, Sarasota - 1.5 miles

Customers` Favorites

Chocolate Raspberry Truffles
Chocolate Ice Cream
Homemade Vanilla
Ice Cream Cone
Bear Claw
Gelato

“Great tasting coffee based ice cream, yummy 🍦“

4.9 Superb85 Reviews
Crystal Cream Rolls Ice Cream Shop • $
157 N Tamiami Trail, Osprey - 5.81 miles

Customers` Favorites

Rolled Icecream Sundae
Smores Ice Cream Rolls
Peanut Butter Rolls
Chocolate Lovers
Ice Cream Sundae
Cookies & Cream
Banana Split
Strawberry
Very Berry
Hot Fudge

“What a delightful ice cream find right here in Osprey Florida. Service with a smile and a delicious product. We're introducing our friends to this treat and the Janey's beautiful smile as she crafts each rolled treat. Try this, you won't regret it ;)“

4.8 Superb116 Reviews
Scoops & Sprinkles Creamery Ice Cream Shop • $
3303 Bahia Vista St, Sarasota - 4.71 miles

Customers` Favorites

Creamy Soft Serve Custard
Chocolate Fudge Brownie
Any Flavor Ice Cream
Cookie Butter Crunch
Toasted Coconut
Hot Fudge Sundae
Ice Cream Cone
Cotton Candy
Waffle Cone
Waffle Cones

“This has become my family’s favorite little ice cream spot! The flavors are amazing! And the staff is always friendly 💕“

4.9 Superb73 Reviews
Settimi's Gelato Ice Cream Shop • $
367 St Armands Cir, Sarasota - 4.06 miles

Customers` Favorites

Sea Salt Caramel Gelato
Caramel Waffle Cone
Almond Joy Gelato
Almond Chocolate
Chocolate Gelato
Affogato & Latte
Pistachio Gelato
Tiramisu Gelato
Nocciola Gelato
Small Gelato

“The best gelato place in this area, let alone Florida! Please open a location in LWR ❤️“

4.7 Superb105 Reviews
Olaf's Siesta Village Ice Cream Shop • $
5208 Ocean Blvd, Sarasota - 1.26 miles

Customers` Favorites

Pistachio Ice Cream
Small Waffle Cone
Toasted Coconut
Brownie

“Busy busy busy, day 1 they were out of waffle cones, day 2 they said sorry we're not offering samples at the moment. And the place smells like bug repellent. The icecream is yummy though. Best tasting ice cream. The staff need to get trained for better customer service.“

4.8 Superb55 Reviews
Orange Octopus Ice Cream Shop • $
1220 Old Stickney Point Rd, Sarasota - 1.3 miles

Customers` Favorites

Strawberry Cheesecake
Ooey Gooey Brownie
Coconut Ice Cream
Sea Salt Caramel
Dutch Chocolate
Toasted Coconut
Chocolate Chip
Coffee Crunch
Birthday Cake
Gator Tracks

“I was having a bad day and went to get some ice cream to cheer me up. I got blueberry lemon crunch and it was so good!
The service though, phenomenal. This tattood dark hair girl helped me the entire way from her favorite flavor, what i should try and talked to me :) therapy AND ice cream? Period queen.“

4.6 Superb103 Reviews
Sweet Melissa's Ice Cream Shop Ice Cream Shop • $
720 Albee Rd W, Nokomis - 10.97 miles

Customers` Favorites

Cookie and Cream with Vanilla Ice Cream and Rainbow Sprinkles
Hot Fudge Sundae
Or Cake Cone
Waffle Cone
Waffle Bowl

“This place is the best! Anytime we travel to the area we go at least once! They have great service and delicious ice cream with a great selection!“

4.7 Superb56 Reviews
The Skinny Dip Frozen Yogurt Bar Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt • $
6616 Gateway Ave, Sarasota - 1.89 miles

Customers` Favorites

Candy Toppings
Fruit Toppings
Frozen Yogurt
Acai Bowl

“A good low cal treat! Delicious too!!“

4.7 Superb54 Reviews
Orange Octopus Ice Cream Shop • $
4141 S Tamiami Trail, Sarasota - 2.11 miles

Customers` Favorites

Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough
Mint Chocolate Chip
Ooey Gooey Brownie
Sea Salt Caramel
Dutch Chocolate
Birthday Cake
Cotton Candy
Strawberry

“The ice cream is fabulous and the waffle cones are made fresh daily. Chocolate peanut butter was rich and creamy. Mint chocolate chip was very minty and the sea salt Carmel had just the right amount of Carmel & salt very creamy. Very clean, no line with a water cooler to gab a sip if you need it.“

4.7 Superb43 Reviews
Gelato-go Sarasota Ice Cream Shop • $
14 S Orange Ave, Sarasota - 4.8 miles

Customers` Favorites

Mint Chocolate Chip Gelato
Croissant Coffee
Pistachio Gelato
Homemade Gelato
Small Gelato
Large Gelato
Cookie Cake
Focaccia
Tiramisu
Cannoli

“My family and I spent the afternoon at this pleasant ice cream shop. In addition to the excellent quality of the ice cream, the service was fantastic, including the pets. This filled me with joy.“

4.6 Superb63 Reviews
Sub Zero Nitrogen Ice Cream Ice Cream Shop • $
4065 Clark Rd, Sarasota - 3.6 miles

Customers` Favorites

Create Your Own Ice Cream or Yogurt
Birthday Cake Capacitor
Peanut Butter Bonds
Non Dairy Ice Cream
Peanut Butter Cups
Bernoulli Brulee
Waffle Cone
Hot Fudge
Custard

“The Custard was really great 😁“

4.6 Superb32 Reviews
Blue Pineapple Ice Cream Beneva Ice Cream Shop • $
935 N Beneva Rd #413, Sarasota - 6 miles

Customers` Favorites

Ice Cream Cone
Banana Split
Soft Serve

“🍦🍦🍦❤️❤️❤️ Very good ice cream lots of choice and clean store“

4.4 Superb76 Reviews
Jeni's Splendid Ice Creams Ice Cream Shop • $
190 N Cattlemen Rd #4, Sarasota - 9.92 miles

Customers` Favorites

Brown Butter Almond Brittle Pint
Variety of Ice Cream Choices
Lemon & Blueberries Parfait
Buttercrisp Waffle Cones
Wildberry Lavender Pint
Chocolate Ice Cream
Gooey Butter Cake
Texas Sheet Cake

“I come here just for the smell!! The smell of waffle cones in the air is the best part. Everyone is super friendly. There is a chalkboard for you to entertain yourself, and the ice cream is so delish and creamy. Love coming here for a pick me up. Highly recommend.“

4.4 Superb70 Reviews
Blue Pineapple Ice Cream Shop Ice Cream Shop • $
3973 Cattlemen Rd, Sarasota - 6.26 miles

Customers` Favorites

Bubble Waffle Cone
Hot Fudge Sundae
Chocolate Chip
Salted Caramel
Butter Pecan
Cotton Candy
Banana Split
Cheesecake
Tiramisu

“🍦🍦🍦❤️❤️❤️ Very good ice cream lots of choice and clean store“

4.4 Superb64 Reviews
Big Olaf Creamery Ice Cream Shop • $
561 N Washington Dr, Sarasota - 4.06 miles

Customers` Favorites

Ice Cream Cone
A Waffle

“Absolutely recommend. We make a trip up to Siesta key every year and HAVE to stop here. Workers are the sweetest and they always have the best service and sweets. 100% make a stop here on your trip!!!“

4.4 Superb61 Reviews
Tyler's Gourmet Ice Cream Ice Cream Shop • $
5350 Gulf of Mexico Dr, Longboat Key - 12 miles

Customers` Favorites

Soft Serve Ice Cream
Ice Cream Cone

“Tyler’s is awesome 🍦🍨 Highly recommend!“

4.4 Superb53 Reviews
Pinecraft Ice Cream Shoppe Ice Cream Shop • $
3350 Bahia Vista St, Sarasota - 4.72 miles

Customers` Favorites

Blueberry Cheesecake Ice Cream Cone
Double Scoop of Ice Cream
White Chocolate Raspberry
Soft Serve Ice Cream
Waffle Cone

“I just wanted to let you in on a little secret. I have lived in Sarasota for 3 years and i have found the best ice cream shoppe in Sarasota. Pinecraft Ice Cream is the best. Located at 3350 Bahia Vista St. They have a delicious variety of ice cream some even dairy free. My favorite is the soft serve twist. While your there order a pizza from Village Pizza By Emma. Reminds me of the great pizza when I lived in New York. Tell them Bob sent you.“

4.4 Superb42 Reviews
Siesta Pops Ice Cream Shop • $
4515 Northgate Ct, Sarasota - 7.39 miles

Customers` Favorites

Gourmet Popsicles
Mexican Chocolate

“Homemade popsicles and donuts“

5 Superb5 Reviews
Cold Stone Creamery Ice Cream Shop • $$
140 University Town Center Dr Unit 299, Sarasota - 9.86 miles

Customers` Favorites

Cold Stone Creamery Creation in Hand
Mix & Go Create Your Own Creation

“I visited Cold Stone a couple of weeks ago. Although it was a bit tricky to find in the mall, once I found it, it was an excellent experience. I was served quickly and politely, and the ice cream - some sort of seasonal, heavenly, cinnamon roll concoction - knocked my socks off. It was insanely sweet, which is exactly what I was looking for. I ate off of it for 3 days. Amazing. 10/10.“

4.4 Superb15 Reviews
Deep Sea Diner Ice Cream Shop • $
1600 Ken Thompson Pkwy, Sarasota - 4.93 miles

“We were looking for somewhere to grab a quick lunch before visiting Mote Aquarium. We wanted somewhere quick and convenient and you can get much more convenient thank the Deep Sea Diner. I had a Nathan’s hotdog, my hubby a burger and my granddaughter had a grilled cheese, all included fries. The servings were more than we could eat. They, also, serve ice cream and shakes. It’s a great, convenient place for lunch or a snack while visiting the aquarium.“

3.9 Good10 Reviews
Kurtos Chimney Cake & Bread Sandwich Shop • $
1312 Main St, Sarasota - 4.7 miles

Customers` Favorites

Savory and Sweet Chimney Cakes
Traditional Sweet Chimney
Chicken Salad Sandwich
Cinnamon Chimney Cake
Hungarian Sandwich
American Sandwich
Boxed Salads to
Budapest Kurtos
Hot Dog Chimney
Ice Cream Cone

“Atmosphere is nice, clean and cute, outside seating is available too. The food is delicious and fresh, they have authentic Hungarian and new contemporary creation options to choose from! The staff is very friendly, kind and polite! Overall an excellent experience, I would recommend this place to all who visit the area!“

4.9 Superb91 Reviews
Haagen-Dazs Shops Ice Cream Shop • $$
140 University Town Center Dr, Sarasota - 9.96 miles

“I pass by this location almost every day on my usual afternoon Starbucks Run. Yesterday I happen to notice something seemed different. Behind the counter, and the establishment in general seemed less cluttered and very clean. I happened to be looking over when the young lady behind the counter made eye contact with me and smiled. She greeted me with the biggest Smile and said, “how are you doing today?” And I told her I was great. I mentioned to her how good things were looking over there. She then introduced herself to me as the new General Manager. I believe she said her name was Sarah. I was struck by how confident yet polite and sophisticated this young lady, Sarah seemed to be managing and ice cream store. I told her that I was waiting in line at Starbucks but sometime I would have to come over and try some ice cream. She again smiled, warmly and enthusiastically welcomed to me to stop by sometime on a break. It’s funny how she had noticed in the past week or two I had been going to Starbucks almost every day. Very observant on her part.Overall, I was thoroughly impressed by being noticed and then so graciously being welcomed to stop by. I will most definitely be going to this location the next time I am craving ice cream.“

3.7 Good13 Reviews
Crumbl - South Sarasota Dessert • $$
4942 S Tamiami Trail, Sarasota - 1.34 miles

Customers` Favorites

Chocolate Chip Cookie
Mini 3-Pack
Mini 12-Pack
Party Box
Cookies
4-Pack

“Very sweet treat and very yummy !

Vegetarian options: good options for everything

Dietary restrictions: good options

Parking: Good parking

Kid-friendliness: sweet and good for summer

Wheelchair accessibility: Parking for everyone“

4.7 Superb183 Reviews
Evie's Family Golf Center Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt • $$
4735 Bee Ridge Rd, Sarasota - 4.95 miles

“My whole family had a good time here. The mini golf course is lots of fun. Range balls are affordable and very easy access to the outdoor bar. They also have an ice cream counter and game room. There's something for everyone to do here!!!“

4 Good45 Reviews
Norman Love Confections - Sarasota Ice Cream •
8109 Cooper Creek Blvd, University Park - 10.28 miles

Customers` Favorites

Tiramisu and Chocolate Mousse
Chocolate Caramel Cake
Chocolate Mousse Cake
Ice Cream Options
Coffee Pecan Tart
Chocolate Cake
Key Lime Tart
Carmel Tower
Croissant
Truffles

“Norman’s has become my second home! I love the staff always great service and great quality crepes! My favorite chicken pesto! Quite out of my budget but I limit spending as much as possible! Worth every cent! No more Starbucks for this woman!!

Vegetarian options: Not sure not a vegetarian

Dietary restrictions: Cater to all

Parking: Plenty of room but crowded at times

Kid-friendliness: Great!“

4.8 Superb95 Reviews
The Fudge Factory Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt • $$
5263 Ocean Blvd, Sarasota - 1.18 miles

“Too many yummy things to pick“

3.9 Good39 Reviews
Paleteria Y Neveria La Mexicana Ice Cream Shop • $
1303 N Washington Blvd unit A, Sarasota - 5.79 miles

Customers` Favorites

Coktel de Frutas

“duros preparados con extra aguacate son sabrosos“

3.8 Good29 Reviews
Crumbl Cookies - Sarasota UTC Bakery • $
215 N Cattlemen Rd #56, Sarasota - 9.85 miles

Customers` Favorites

Cookie Selection for the Week
Chocolate Mallow Cupcake
German Chocolate Cookie
Milk Chocolate Chip
Chocalate Croissant
Cookie Butter Lava
Pumpkin Pie Cookie
Cookies & Cream
Brownie Batter
Cinnamon Roll

“im always in crumbl and i love the workers and the cookies so much! i belive her name is emilya and she always provides the best customer service!! i went today after the gym and she recognized me because of how often i come in. she deserves a raise. i come at least once a week on a different day and she’s always there when i go in. i love crumbl and the service“

4.6 Superb282 Reviews
Menchie's Frozen Yogurt Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt • $
257 N Cattlemen Rd #85, Sarasota - 9.79 miles

Customers` Favorites

Pure Chocolate Yogurt
Peanut Butter Yogurt
Cake Batter Yogurt
Frozen Yogurt

“Just purchased a birthday cake from Menchies for grandsons sixth birthday. Cake was delicious —decorated so amazingly —Mario theme—big hit at his party!!! Great service ..fun place ..recommend !😀“

3.7 Good35 Reviews
Ice Cream Shoppe Lakewood Ranch Ice Cream Shop • $
8151 Lakewood Main St, Lakewood Ranch - 11.08 miles

Customers` Favorites

One Scoop of Strawberry Cheesecake Ice Cream in a Waffle Cone
Peppermint Ice Cream

“Kate was a pleasure.We came in with 12 people and she handled it all so well. No long wait time, the kids were happy and helped first, I forgot to mention she was the only person working that day. Much praise for her patience, how courteous & kind she was to our big family.“

3.7 Good39 Reviews
Kilwins Waterside Place Ice Cream Shop • $$
1561 Lakefront Dr Unit 107, Sarasota - 10.41 miles

“Amazing ice cream and chocolate! Best in the area for sure“

3.6 Good34 Reviews
Vampire Penguin SRQ Dessert • $
4976 S Tamiami Trail, Sarasota - 1.32 miles

Customers` Favorites

Watermelon Snow with Marshmallows Whipped Cream Chocolate Sauce and Sprinkles
Polar Affagato and Vampire Penguin
Strawberry Cheesecake Bliss
Watermelon Shaved Ice
Strawberry Shortcake
Chocolate Something
Thai Tea Shaved Ice
Mango Shaved Ice
Mango Snow Ice
Coffee S'Mores

“Such a cool place!!! The employee that served us was amazing, super friendly and helpful since it was our first time here. The desserts were delicious. I can’t explain the texture, it’s like nothing else I’ve ever tried. It’s not like traditional shaved ice. It’s cold but creamy and light. Melts in your mouth. Definitely a must try!“

4.7 Superb51 Reviews
The Fat Donkey Ice Cream Shop • $
1461 Main St, Sarasota - 4.82 miles

Customers` Favorites

Waffle with Ice Cream
Ice Cream Sandwich
Ice Cream Cones
Butterscotch
Birthday Cake
Waffle Cone
Gummy Bear
Soft Serve
Hot Fudge
Sorbet

“I LOVE ❤️ the donkey!“

3.8 Good113 Reviews
Southside Deli Deli • $
1825 Hillview St, Sarasota - 3.53 miles

Customers` Favorites

Meatball Slider Special
Muffaletta Panini
Reuben Sandwich
Chicken Salad
Spanish Salad
Italian Sub
Tuna Wrap
Gelato

“large, delicious sandwiches!“

4.3 Superb65 Reviews
Le Macaron Macarons • $$
140 University Town Center Dr, Sarasota - 9.94 miles

Customers` Favorites

French Macarons

“We got a dozen split among six flavors and they were ALL delicious. Pistachio and Tiramisu were far and away the best, absolutely stunning. Not cheap but well worth the price for a little treat. We're looking to see if they ship, ha.“

5 Superb2 Reviews

You May Also Like