22 Best Ice Cream Shops in Sarasota

Main Street Creamery Ice Cream Shop • $
1359 Main St, Sarasota

Customers` Favorites

Banana Pudding with Chocolate Peanut Butter Sauce
Cotton Candy Mocha Almond Fudge
Soft-Serve Birthday Cake
Toasted Coconut
Brownie Sundae
Cookie Monster
Waffle Bowl
Coffee Bean

“Always love coming here. Everytime i am in Sarasota i come here. Always new flavors, always wonderful staff and always leave happy. Will always come back here. Sorry no picture dove right in when I got my ice cream, got the blueberry cheesecake, highly recommended. Also have gotten the cotton candy and Cookie Monster. All good. 10/10“

4.8 Superb163 Reviews
Pete's Sweet Treats Ice Cream Shop • $
6616 Superior Ave, Sarasota

Customers` Favorites

Cookie Dough Ice Cream - Pint
Lemon Italian Ice - Cup
Acai Italian Ice - Pint
Cookie Butter Ice Cream
Mint Chip - Pint
Rasp Cheesecake
Snickers Bar
Cotton Candy
Blueberry
Mango

“We had a great first visit earlier this week and have returned two more times. The Italian Ice is outstanding and the owner is very friendly. He has board games built into the tables and giant Uno cards and more. Perfect for our extended family. We will be back ... and telling our friends to come as well. Easy access and dedicated parking in Gulf Gate“

4.8 Superb129 Reviews
Kurtos Chimney Cake & Bread Sandwich Shop • $
1312 Main St, Sarasota

Customers` Favorites

Savory and Sweet Chimney Cakes
Traditional Sweet Chimney
Cinnamon Chimney Cake
Hungarian Sandwich
American Sandwich
Boxed Salads to
Budapest Kurtos
Hot Dog Chimney
Chimney Panini
Ice Cream Cone

“I loved this little cafe right in downtown Sarasota I got flashbacks of Europe. The food is so good I loved the Hungarian style bread it’s absolutely incredible. The service was totally ?% they were always asking us if everything was ok and if we needed anything. I will definitely go back.“

4.9 Superb77 Reviews
Gelato-go Bakery Sarasota Bakery • $
321 John Ringling Blvd, Sarasota

Customers` Favorites

Cookie Dough
Key Lime Pie
Lemon Tart
Cannoli
Gelato
Mango
Oreo

“Delicious Gelato Experience!I recently had the pleasure of visiting the gelato go place on St.Armand's Circle in Sarasota, and it was an absolute delight! From the moment I walked in, I was greeted with a warm and inviting atmosphere that set the tone for a fantastic experience.The gelato itself was a true masterpiece. The flavors were incredibly rich and authentic, and you could tell that they used high-quality ingredients. I especially loved the unique and seasonal flavors they offered, which added a delightful twist to the traditional gelato experience, I have chosen chocolate, mango and pistachio.The Owners husband and wife are from Thailand, but gelato tastes very Italian:)). They were not only friendly but also very knowledgeable about the different flavors and were more than happy to give samples to try. Their passion for their craft really shone through, making the visit even more enjoyable.The portion sizes were generous, and the presentation was impeccable. I couldn't resist taking a few photos of my gelato before digging in. Plus, they had a wide range of cakes, fruit salads, cookies, coffee, smoothies and gluten free options to choose from, allowing you to customize your treat to your heart's content.Overall, my visit to the gelato-go place on St.Armand's Circle was a memorable and delicious experience. Whether you're a gelato aficionado or just looking for a sweet treat, I highly recommend stopping by and savoring the flavors at this delightful establishment. You won't be disappointed!“

4.9 Superb75 Reviews
Jake's Ice Cream on Siesta Key Ice Cream Shop • $
6575 Midnight Pass Rd, Sarasota

Customers` Favorites

Others Greats Salted Caramel Pecan and Cinnimon Biscoff
Espresso Double Scoop Ice Cream with Rainbow Sprinkles
Toasted Coconut Ice Cream with Waffle Come
Orange Pineapple
Chocolate Almond
Cookies & Cream
Wicked Cobbler
Cookie Monster
Chocolate Chip
Brownie Fudge

“My family had an amazing experience today at Jake’s. As a person with a lot of food allergies there is nothing more comforting then a place that invites conversation around individual dietary needs. From the signs posted letting you know to mention allergies, to checking ingredients, and taste testing-every moment made me feel safe to enjoy ice cream with my family. Thank you for all of your work to help make quality products that accommodate food allergies. Thank you for the kindness and passion that is clearly poured into every moment. It is the small moments that really make a difference and Jake’s is amazing at creating joy through small moments and interactions! Added bonus-the ice cream is beyond words good! So happy to have found this ice cream shop!“

4.8 Superb119 Reviews
Abel's Ice Cream Ice Cream Shop • $
1886 Stickney Point Rd, Sarasota

Customers` Favorites

Chocolate Raspberry Truffles
Ice Cream Cone

“My wife and I had ice cream here, and it was delicious. A very nice lady who I assume is the owner helped us out. She took her time with us and offered us samples to try of any ice cream we would like, what good customer service! She even had a nice conversation with us. This is the best ice cream I’ve had, my wife agrees as well. We will definitely be coming here each time we visit Sarasota“

4.8 Superb73 Reviews
Vampire Penguin SRQ Dessert • $
4976 S Tamiami Trail, Sarasota

Customers` Favorites

Polar Affagato and Vampire Penguin
Dulce De Leche

“Absolutely our favourite dessert place in town, I can't recommend enough. The Mexican Candy is my favourite but you really can't go wrong they're all delicious! The owners are really the best kind of people and their staff are always friendly and kind. It's the type of dessert where you won't feel heavy or sick after, it's so light and fresh.“

4.8 Superb58 Reviews
Crumbl - South Sarasota Dessert • $
4942 S Tamiami Trail, Sarasota

Customers` Favorites

Chocolate Chip Cookie
Cookies

“Out of this world delicious cookies! Love the weekly menu changes too. If you haven't tried them yet do yourself a favor and get a cookie! Today, I ordered cookies as a gift. Lightning fast service! Delivery was made within an hour of me placing the order!“

4.7 Superb92 Reviews
Settimi's Gelato Ice Cream Shop • $
367 St Armands Cir, Sarasota

Customers` Favorites

Pistachio Gelato
Tiramisu Gelato
Waffle

“Best gelato in the Sarasota area. All there gelato is homemade and extremely fresh. The pistachio and hazelnut are unbelievably delicious. I’ve been here well over a couple dozen times and always been my friends after trying many of the other ice cream and gelato places. I definitely give this one five stars.“

4.7 Superb88 Reviews
Scoops & Sprinkles Creamery Ice Cream Shop • $
3303 Bahia Vista St, Sarasota

Customers` Favorites

Creamy Soft Serve Custard
Any Flavor Ice Cream
Toasted Coconut
Waffle Cone

“The ice-cream was great, although there was quite a long line, it moved quickly and we didn't have any trouble finding a spot to sit and enjoy. This place is NOT a brick and mortar though. It is pretty much a food truck alongside another building and it's parking lot. There is nowhere to use the bathroom.Dietary restrictions: They did have 3 or 4 dairy free options on the menu.Parking: There were a significant number of spots considering its just an ice-cream food truck, but the lot was very full. They were quite busy.Kid-friendliness: Menu had a kids cone/dish option (still very large), the seating area had small kids picnic tables, and although no bathroom, there was an outdoor sink for kid washup.“

4.8 Superb47 Reviews
The Skinny Dip Frozen Yogurt Bar Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt • $
6616 Gateway Ave, Sarasota

Customers` Favorites

Candy Toppings
Fruit Toppings
Frozen Yogurt

“? Fabulous! Best frozen yogurt I’ve ever had! I can’t stop eating it but it’s practically healthy AND it’s bonkers delicious. We love supporting local family businesses! Bring your kids/friends/visitors and enjoy this high-quality, charming little dessert spot “

4.8 Superb44 Reviews
Orange Octopus Ice Cream Shop • $
1220 Old Stickney Point Rd, Sarasota

Customers` Favorites

Strawberry Cheesecake
Ooey Gooey Brownie
Coconut Ice Cream
Sea Salt Caramel
Dutch Chocolate
Toasted Coconut
Chocolate Chip
Coffee Crunch
Birthday Cake
Gator Tracks

“Many locals told us to take our little one to get ice cream at Orange Octopus. Their recommendation did not disappoint! Thankfully they were open late so we were able to eat dinner elsewhere and venture over to this gem. Toasted Coconut and Mint Chocolate Chip were VERY good.“

4.6 Superb104 Reviews
Olaf's Siesta Village Ice Cream Shop • $
5208 Ocean Blvd, Sarasota

Customers` Favorites

Brownie

“Wow. Logan is great. Served us great ice cream and went the extra mile for us by making flavor suggestions based on our astrology signs. Logans soft brown eyes were chocolate chips, and his shining smiling was the vanilla ice cream. Honestly a night me and my friends will never forget. Rename this restaurant Logans creamery!“

4.7 Superb51 Reviews
Orange Octopus Ice Cream Shop • $
4141 S Tamiami Trail, Sarasota

Customers` Favorites

Sea Salt Caramel
Dutch Chocolate

“Tucked away behind Captain Curt's this little place came up on my MAP search. The flavors ALL sounded amazing, so I tried a few! Ended up with the Kentucky Honey Bourbon and it did not disappoint! I should have got more, since I ate two spoons and gave it to my wife to hold while i got the car going...and when i looked over, it was gone!“

4.8 Superb30 Reviews
Gelato-go Sarasota Ice Cream Shop • $
14 S Orange Ave, Sarasota

Customers` Favorites

Mint Chocolate Chip Gelato
Homemade Gelato
Small Gelato
Large Gelato
Cookie Cake
Croissant
Focaccia
Tiramisu
Cannoli

“Came here with my SO. There was a very nice selection of gelato (~20 flavors). I got their passionfruit and mixed berries sorbet. It was quite good and not too sweet. The service was friendly, and I heard it was family owned. The ambiance is quite nice with both outdoors and indoors seatings. I was hoping that their fruit-flavor gelatos were not limited to just sorbets, hence the 4-star review. I would come back again regardless though.“

4.6 Superb66 Reviews
Siesta Pops Ice Cream Shop • $
4515 Northgate Ct, Sarasota

Customers` Favorites

Gourmet Popsicles
Mexican Chocolate

“I discovered this place’s delicious popsicles from my visit to the Marie Selby Botanical Gardens, where I fell in love with their Mexican Chocolate flavor! The location at Northgate is a bit hidden, but I was warmly greeted and assisted with my order once inside! They have so many flavors to choose from, and thus far I’d say the Mexican Chocolate and the Root Beer Float (photo of it attached) are my favorites! I definitely recommend stopping by to pick up a delicious treat! I was told they sell their popsicles at other various locations around the area, so I also suggest keeping your eyes peeled for them!“

4.9 Superb20 Reviews
Crumbl Cookies - Sarasota UTC Bakery • $
215 N Cattlemen Rd #56, Sarasota

Customers` Favorites

German Chocolate Cookie
Cookies & Cream
Chocolate Chip
Snickerdoodle
Birthday Cake
Caramel Cake
Crumbl Water
Strawberry
Cheesecake
Lemon Tart

“these are some of the best cookies I’ve ever had All of the employees that I met were very kind And it was a very clean workspace If you download the app, it gives you Points and eventually you can earn cash to get free cookies or accessories I very much recommend getting the app I’ve gotten two free cookies and a cookie cutter You also can get birthday rewards And it is very easy to get Extra crumb points“

4.5 Superb127 Reviews
Sub Zero Nitrogen Ice Cream Ice Cream Shop • $$
219 Avenida Madera, Sarasota

“I think this would be a great place to take kids--sundaes are super fun, colorful, and full of toppings. Also a sweet spot for instagrammable ice cream concoctions, especially if a spiked dessert is up your alley. The ice cream was a little rich for my taste, but tasty nonetheless! A simple regular size was too much for me to finish in one sitting, and I will usually inhale ice cream. Overall, would recommend for a kitschy & unique ice cream experience.“

4.6 Superb38 Reviews
Southside Deli Deli • $
1825 Hillview St, Sarasota

Customers` Favorites

Reuben Sandwich
Chicken Salad
Italian Sub

“It's only my third time going but every time The sandwiches are exceptionally good and the desserts are like going to a high end restaurant. And Whether it's been busy or not everyone is very nice and helpful. Expect to pay a little extra...“

4.5 Superb54 Reviews
Paleteria Y Neveria La Mexicana Ice Cream Shop • $
1303 N Washington Blvd unit A, Sarasota

“This is my favorite ice cream go to spot. So many options for flavors- they have ice cream, drinks, popsicles, mango, elotes. Staff are very kind and it's very conveniently located.It's bright and colorful inside and it is always busy, but there's usually no wait time!“

4.5 Superb22 Reviews
Pinecraft Ice Cream Shoppe Ice Cream Shop •
3350 Bahia Vista St, Sarasota

Customers` Favorites

Blueberry Cheesecake Ice Cream Cone
Soft Serve Ice Cream
Waffle Cone

“What a fabulous ice cream experience! A wonderful selection of flavours makes it difficult to choose, but we managed it and then enjoyed sitting outside in the sunshine enjoying the really generous "small" servings. Really good prices too.There are a few parking spaces, so it's easy to stop and enjoy.Highly recommended“

4.4 Superb36 Reviews
Sub Zero Nitrogen Ice Cream Ice Cream Shop • $
4065 Clark Rd, Sarasota

Customers` Favorites

Create Your Own Ice Cream or Yogurt
Peanut Butter Bonds
Peanut Butter Cups
Hot Fudge

“We had an awesome experience here. Zero was a concept that was introduced on Shark Tank and there are two locations in the area, one in Siesta Key Village and one off Clark Rd.The staff was fantastic, they took time to talk to us and explain everything with a positive attitude and smile. We enjoyed our ice creams and the atmosphere. thanks, Sub Zero, we will be back!“

4.4 Superb31 Reviews
Loading...
map Map